3 ms·
Roc's post was nothing but an attempt to lower the status of his opponents. He criticized his opponent for only having anecdotes, and didn't even provide one of
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Roc's post was nothing but an attempt to lower the status of his opponents. He criticized his opponent for only having anecdotes, and didn't even provide one of his own (let alone data). The majority of his post was devoted to attacking those who disagree with him.
Greenspun's post speculates a bit about the ineffectiveness of our current scheme, suggests some alternatives, and asks the reader if his speculation is wrong.
I will defend theorizing - I think it's useful. If we can confirm or refute Greenspun's theory based on empirical evidence, that's even more useful. Roc isn't attempting to do anything other than lower the status of his opponents. That's [attacking one's opponent] not only useless, it's harmful.
- tptacek 16y agoIt looks to me that when you sympathize with an argument, unsupported noodley speculation serves a purpose, but when you disagree with an argument it becomes "not only useless, [but] harmful". I think you're being less rigorous than you think you are. Nothing prevented Greenspun from framing his argument in more neutral and objective terms. He could have said, "our scheme is ineffective because it induces people who don't have the skills for good jobs and like most Americans don't know how to effectively search for a job to waste many months of their lives fruitlessly". Instead, he played directly to the worst biases of his own choir of libertarians by evoking Xboxes. And now here you are berating people for having the temerity to take issue with a recklessly constructed, poorly supported argument. And THAT'S FINE, I don't mind, but I'm definitely going to call you out for pretending to take the high road on this.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoAnd now here you are berating people for having the temerity to take issue with a recklessly constructed, poorly supported argument. I'm berating roc for making an ad-hominem attack in lieu of an argument (see the emphasis I added to my prior post, which was apparently unclear). My normal practice is merely to downvote such comments - I only bother responding to them when they receive a lot of upvotes.