3 ms·
The cancers you're thinking of in Tasmanian Devils are the result of a transmissible (!) tumor. The cancerous cells aren't the result of mutations within the an
by duskwuff 7y ago
The cancers you're thinking of in Tasmanian Devils are the result of a transmissible (!) tumor. The cancerous cells aren't the result of mutations within the animal's body, but instead are introduced into it from another infected animal. As such, genetic therapies are unlikely to have an effect.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoAs such, genetic therapies are unlikely to have an effect. Can you back that up somehow? That doesn't sound at all right to me. Edit: For the upvote, downvote brigade -- with zero reply so far, but this comment has gone to zero and back to one umpteen times already -- I'm genuinely curious. This isn't some kind of gotcha question. I have a genetic disorder. I have umpteen relatives who have had cancer. I actually have a serious vested interest in better understanding how this stuff works.
- Sniffnoy 7y agoWe're talking about genetic therapies that would make cells less prone to mutating into cancerous cells. This would have no effect on cells that are already cancerous, introduced from an outside source.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI read the article. It says this gene actively promotes apoptosis -- cell death -- in defective cells. I mean, I guess it would depend on how you are introducing the gene. How many cells it is getting into. But if it causes defective cells to suicide, why would it matter where the defect is coming from? I don't think we really have a good handle on what causes cancer. I suspect more cancer is due to some infectious agent than is generally believed and we know genetic variations have significant impact on the immune system and its ability to function at all.
- dEnigma 7y agoWhat the parent means is that in the Tasmanian devils' case it's the cancerous cells of another animal which are transmitted, not some kind of virus or similar that introduces genetic damage in the host. Since the improved/strengthened cell death mechanism introduced by the therapy would only affect your own cells (as the introduced cells wouldn't have the altered genes), there would be no change to the cancerousness of the transmitted cells.
- beerandt 7y ago>I mean, I guess it would depend on how you are introducing the gene. How many cells it is getting into. It's cancer. You're trivializing the ultimate source of the problem. If we could ensure universal targeting of cancer cells, we wouldn't need a technically elaborate method of cellular death, like gene modification. You might as well suggest solving world hunger by just feeding everyone.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYou're trivializing the ultimate source of the problem. No, I'm not. But it's occurred to me that I'm imagining this as treatment for Tasmanian devils that already have tumors. Maybe other people are envisioning it as a preventative measure. And maybe that's part of the problem in trying to discuss it.
- beerandt 7y agoIt is by definition a preventative measure. Otherwise, it's no different then any other cancer treatment in that it has the same fundamental weakness working against it: natural selection. If the cells knew when they were supposed to die, then it wouldn't be cancer. If the cure is telling the cells when they're supposed to die, then the cells that don't listen survive, ergo the cancer survives. Which, in the sense of (non-preventitive) treatment, makes it a problem of universal targeting.
- londons_explore 7y agoSee reply by Sniffoy
- duskwuff 7y agoShort answer: Transmissible tumors are fucking weird. They're less like normal cancers, and more like parasites made of cancerous cells. Moreover, they're not even typical cancer cells -- they're cancer cells which have been dividing (and continuing to mutate) since the disease first came into existence, to the extent that their genetic material has become wildly divergent from that of the host species. Typical genetic therapies for cancer focus on the hope that enough of the normal apoptotic pathways still exist that the cancer cells can be "convinced" to recognize themselves as cancerous and undergo cell death. In the case of transmissible tumors, though, it's likely that these pathways have been entirely destroyed through selective pressures on the cancer.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoOkay, that makes more sense. Parasites can be an absolute bitch to treat.
- Izkata 7y agoIs it just me, or does that description sound unnervingly close to nature having created a Grey Goo scenario?
- earthboundkid 7y agoNature is the grey goo scenario. This used to be a very nice rock in space and then life got it all slimy.
- seppel 7y agoCells are basically grey goo. It is also not uncommon for cancer cells to become independent of the host. See HeLa cells for a human example. These are cancer cells taken from a woman who died in 1951, but which are still living and dividing today (in some way forming a new species): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HeLa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HeLa
- amphitoky 7y agoas others have said, genetic therapies for these kinds of transmissible cancers are not so effective since the cells have already acquired the cancer phenotype. The usual regulatory mechanisms which prevent unchecked proliferation occur in each individual cell, and have already been circumvented by the time cells become cancerous. I thought I would add that what makes the tasmanian case interesting is that though the body is generally pretty good about detecting and removing foreign cells (including viruses and bacteria), somehow these contagious cancers elude this detection and are allowed to proliferate [1]. It is likely that if the tasmanian devil's immune system were able to detect the intruder cancer cells as coming from another individual, it would eradicate them with ruthless efficiency. Why these cells are able to skirt the host immune system though is a different question. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28695294 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28695294
- pmoriarty 7y agoCould you go in to more detail on why genetic therapies wouldn't work on a transmissible tumor? Aren't those tumors still affecting the genes in the cells and causing them to grow out of control?
- Sniffnoy 7y agoNo, the tumor is the cells growing out of control, not some separate thing that acts on the genes of nearby cells. Once cells have mutated into a tumor, it's a bit late to make them less prone to doing so.
- rob-olmos 7y agoThe article mentions possibly treating/curing cancer: "He believes there could be a drug that could mimic the effect of p53, or a way to deliver these genes to people at risk of developing cancer, or who already have it to treat or cure the disease."
- beerandt 7y agoMethod of cellular death doesn't really matter, at this level of discussion of a hypothetical cure. Targeting does. And this strikes me as killing a mosquito with a cannon. If you can ensure universal targeting, there are much easier ways.