2 ms·
> encouraged a tremendous amount of public debate I don't think "debate" is the right word for what happened in that thread. > then single-handedly reverted I
by matheusmoreira 7y ago
> encouraged a tremendous amount of public debate
I don't think "debate" is the right word for what happened in that thread.
> then single-handedly reverted Isaac Childers' commit
A perfectly good reason for reverting the commit was provided in the message itself: "All patches have to be signed off by either me or Bert." It looks like the patch didn't meet that criteria. He also cited other valid reasons for rejecting it: "have to collect and check the CLA, it makes git blame less effective, etc."
Is this change so overwhelmingly important and urgent that it overrides the aforementioned policy and concerns? I don't know.
Does the fact he rejected the patch excuse the way people reacted to his decision? No.