4 ms·
It would be useful if, rather than offering vague assertions that statistics exist, you actually presented some. The simplest way to determine whether unemploy
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
It would be useful if, rather than offering vague assertions that statistics exist, you actually presented some.
The simplest way to determine whether unemployment induces people to consume leisure: measure whether changes in the duration of unemployment benefits affect the duration of unemployment. Do you know of any such measurements, or are you simply assuming that reality supports your views?
Edit: The classic paper on this topic is Meyer, but it's a bit old. http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:xdATBYGtHBcJ:www.econ.upenn.edu/~hfang/teaching/socialinsurance/readings/Meyer90(4.12).pdf+%22unemployment+insurance+and+unemployment+spells%22&hl=en&gl=us&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEESijVugfxTMH8N17GpSU_u2JvA9mKUnU2-0yEbjnU4nwsZzfb6xylzJiPCE7EUAmsWycAgt74ZcB3dWYw4wZ-JRBbT5DLbajcMt_A0VhvZTgz74ppJlG27NwAeZXcun3IjfAtx70&sig=AHIEtbRr14Z-jKd0rYrZD25qNSBSVWlWEg http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:xdATBYGtHBcJ:w...
This paper strongly supports the theory that unemployment benefits create moral hazard.
Here is a more recent paper showing the same thing in Europe, after a natural experiment: http://ftp.iza.org/dp2171.pdf http://ftp.iza.org/dp2171.pdf
- tptacek 16y agoThere are indeed studies that indicate a positive correlation between duration of benefits and subsequent employment stability (ie, that giving people a longer cushion within which to find a job allows them to find better jobs). I'm sure you could reply with a study that supports your point of view. This thread would then get very boring, as few of us are qualified to vet the studies. It is, however, not very compelling to argue the lack of empiricism in a comment thread on a Greenspun article that takes as a premise the idea that people are spending 99 months playing government-sponsored Xbox. Maybe not so much with the high horse with you, on this particular thread.
- yummyfajitas 16y agogiving people a longer cushion within which to find a job allows them to find better jobs Actually, the second study I linked to (from iza.org) argues against that claim. I don't endorse that paper (not familiar with it), but you are welcome to take a look if you are actually curious about it. Of course, feel free to skip that step if empirics bore you. Note that roc was the one who smugly appealed to empiricism, but provided none in his post: "The studies have shown that it looks nothing like party time in the aggregate." Precisely 0 lines of his post provided empirical facts, but 2 lines (of 4) were devoted to attempts to lower the status of people who disagree with him: "moralizing from a privileged vantage...Welfare Queen...Trickle Down...Reagan's 'conservative'..." I'm just pointing out that it [edit: attacking one's opponents] adds nothing of value to the conversation.
- tptacek 16y agoI wrote my comment after finding and reading the abstracts of several surveys that supported my argument, but for the same reason you hedged against your example here, I didn't insult anyone's intelligence by posting my examples. The facts don't bore me, but I recognize that neither of us are in command of them. You also didn't address the sharp end of my comment, which is that you are defending a blog post that makes an even more egregiously unsupported claim.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoRoc's post was nothing but an attempt to lower the status of his opponents. He criticized his opponent for only having anecdotes, and didn't even provide one of his own (let alone data). The majority of his post was devoted to attacking those who disagree with him. Greenspun's post speculates a bit about the ineffectiveness of our current scheme, suggests some alternatives, and asks the reader if his speculation is wrong. I will defend theorizing - I think it's useful. If we can confirm or refute Greenspun's theory based on empirical evidence, that's even more useful. Roc isn't attempting to do anything other than lower the status of his opponents. That's [attacking one's opponent] not only useless, it's harmful.
- tptacek 16y agoIt looks to me that when you sympathize with an argument, unsupported noodley speculation serves a purpose, but when you disagree with an argument it becomes "not only useless, [but] harmful". I think you're being less rigorous than you think you are. Nothing prevented Greenspun from framing his argument in more neutral and objective terms. He could have said, "our scheme is ineffective because it induces people who don't have the skills for good jobs and like most Americans don't know how to effectively search for a job to waste many months of their lives fruitlessly". Instead, he played directly to the worst biases of his own choir of libertarians by evoking Xboxes. And now here you are berating people for having the temerity to take issue with a recklessly constructed, poorly supported argument. And THAT'S FINE, I don't mind, but I'm definitely going to call you out for pretending to take the high road on this.
- roc 16y agoIt would be more useful if Greenspun had, as he's the one who should carry the burden of proof in this case. He's made the implied claim that unemployment==party-time. You really shouldn't be asking me to refute his assertion. Feel free to disagree or use Google to sate your own curiosity if you don't believe me. I think it's notable that people are more willing to give his careless characterization a pass, simply because it aligns with our moral sense that economic outcomes have some sort of parallel to our sense of justice. (economic losers must be social losers who deserved and/or inadvertently caused their unemployment/foreclosure/bankruptcy with bad planning/habits/use of time, etc.) Speaking of Google: Moral Hazard has nothing to do with whether unemployment is party time. I agree that it exists and 99 weeks is far too long for a standard policy. I don't see how that has any bearing on my disagreement with the article.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoGreenspun doesn't bear the burden of proof because he isn't trying to prove anything. He is asking a question and admitting his uncertainty: "The standard 26 weeks of unemployment makes sense to me...But the subsequent 1.5 years don’t make sense...What’s wrong with my thinking?" Jessriedel did the same thing: "I don't claim he was the norm. I'm just giving this anecdotal evidence to say that...we...need hard data." You asserted the existence of evidence without providing it (potentially misleading), and then attacked the people who disagreed with you (harmful). If you have your own theory, argue it and acknowledge uncertainty (just as Greenspun and Jessriedel did). If you have facts to support your position, present them (if you do, awesome). Ad hominem attacks provide no value.
- roc 16y agoLet's take a step back. I didn't (intend to) take issue with any part of jessriedel's post. Clearly I misspoke in my reply and people were confused. My intent was to concede his point: I was not providing evidence about what unemployment looks like. I provided nothing more than my own opinion. We all agree on that. And I'm truly not interested in trying to solve political problems on the internet, so I invited him to sate his own curiosity as to what unemployment looks like. You're either interested in the issue and thus need to do your own research or you're not. If I'd used Google to scare up a link or two, that should not be sufficient for any critical and skeptical thinker. Feel free to disagree with my characterization of unemployment all you like. I invite you to. But please note that you only disagree with me, because I didn't provide any more evidence than Greenspun did. And then hopefully you'll take a moment to wonder why you're complaining about my lack of evidence, but not Greenspun's.