3 ms·
You failed to address literally all the things I pointed out. > The problem is 9 times out of ten not the government. Here's a better idea: let's make censorsh
by arcticbull 7y ago
You failed to address literally all the things I pointed out.
> The problem is 9 times out of ten not the government. Here's a better idea: let's make censorship impossible in all forms.
PayPal and Visa only make money when they process payments. Not processing payments means they don't make money. Not processing payments for Snowden is therefore likely outside pressure from the government. Not processing "immoral" transactions is likely outside pressure from investors or advertisers, or heck, probably their risk management team.
PayPal is a private company and can choose not to process payments for anyone, for any reason. The Fed/ACH doesn't have the same issues because they are a service in the public interest. They will process payments for anything legal for 1/10th of a cent each over the span of a couple of business days. By the end of the year, instantly, via RTP.
> The ACLU is currently suing New York state for financially censoring an organization which likewise committed no crime.
Luckily being a public institution remediation exists through the courts. BTC's irreversibility makes remediation impossible. You're pointing to a big feature as though it's a bug. Just ask the victims of the ransomware.
> Addendum: Not to mention the millions of people who live in censored countries (Iran, Venezuela, etc) who are totally innocent. Or the billions of people worldwide who are cut off from western monetary institutions in the name of anti-money laundering laws - people censored purely because they were born in the wrong country.
Take it up with your government. That's how government works. You don't like it, change it, don't circumvent it. It's like setting up your own parallel government because you don't like who's in power: that's not how it works. Do I agree with sanctions policy? Lord no. However, I can always lobby to change it. I think you'll find the majority do agree with sanctions policy and that you're undermining democracy.
> Or how about the billions of people who live under authoritarian governments which outright censor them. Are they expected to lobby their masters to achieve political change?
No, they're expected to overturn the government. Freedom isn't free, and all that. The censorship of their transactions is literally the least of their problems. Social problems require social solutions. Or phrased glibly: bitcoin won't help you as you mine minerals in the gulag. It won't help you avoid the gulag and it sure won't do anything to help you once you get there.
In fact, I'd be more worried about transacting on the indelible public (pseudonymous) blockchain than transacting in say, cash, if I didn't want the government to know what I was doing. You don't think the PRC would build automatic deanonymization tooling?
- Acrobatic_Road 7y ago>PayPal is a private company and can choose not to process payments for anyone, for any reason. The Fed/ACH doesn't have the same issues because they are a service in the public interest. They will process payments for anything legal for 1/10th of a cent each over the span of a couple of business days. By the end of the year, instantly, via RTP. Sure, PayPal is a private company and can do what they want. That doesn't mean they don't censor individuals. You said nobody ever got censored except for illegal deeds so I pointed out how that is wrong. Also, can an ordinary guy open a bank account at the federal reserve? I don't believe so so your point is moot. >Luckily being a public institution remediation exists through the courts. How about why the hell should we allow this kind of behavior in the first place? You shouldn't need millions in legal fees to participate freely in the economy. Most people couldn't even pay that. >Take it up with your government. That's how government works. You don't like it, change it, don't circumvent it. Why? If the policy is not moral there is no good reason to follow it. Civil disobedience. Besides, you see this changing any time soon? >No, they're expected to overturn the government. Freedom isn't free, and all that. Oh great. Who will pay for that? >In fact, I'd be more worried about transacting on the indelible public (pseudonymous) blockchain than transacting in say, cash, if I didn't want the government to know what I was doing. You don't think the PRC would build automatic deanonymization tooling? Luckily there is Monero which provides actual privacy.
- arcticbull 7y ago> Oh great. Who will pay for that? Are you kidding me?
- Acrobatic_Road 7y agoHow will a revolution against an authoritarian government be funded if the money system is surveilled and censored?