4 ms·
Cross-platform apps isn't really the point though. It's about openness. Native Android, for example, is Java. Java tools are plentiful and open source. Android
by tootie 7y ago
Cross-platform apps isn't really the point though. It's about openness. Native Android, for example, is Java. Java tools are plentiful and open source. Android dev tools work on Macs, Windows, Linux. Google also invests heavily in Chrome allowing for robust apps that don't require an app install at all.
Compare that to Apple who rule the App Store with an iron fist. The don't allow native Chrome at all requiring instead that Google deploy a reskinned Safari. You can't deploy an app to a phone that you own unless you also own a Mac workstation running OS X and pay Apple $100/year for the privilege of using the very expensive hardware you bought from them. They built Swift, they built Xcode. It's total vertical integration and it's all managed at the pleasure of their bottom line.
- st3fan 7y agoIs that correct? Is there a Mac App Store rule that says “thou shall use WebKit” ? Do note that the point on macOS is kind of moot because it IS an open platform. Unlike iOS you do not have to use the App Store.
- tootie 7y agoYes. And it was crippled for a long while outside of Safari. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2016/01/new-chrome-for-ios-is-finally-as-fast-and-stable-as-safari/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2016/01/new-chrome-for-ios-i...
- duskwuff 7y agoThat's with regard to iOS, not the Mac App Store.
- dep_b 7y agoI don't get it. You can deploy apps when you pay both Google and Apple or you can work without a paid subscription if you are just a developer dabbling at home. The vertical integration is true but that also has been the case with Microsoft products. Google basically doesn't have it's own desktop platform until pretty recently, of course their tools ran on other desktop platforms otherwise they wouldn't have any. It's nice to install other browsers on Android though. Using Firefox wherever I can.
- zepto 7y agoIf people want openness they can always buy Android. In fact most people do. The whole point of different platforms is that they have different characteristics. Openness is a characteristic of Android but not of Apple’s stores. This means there will be limitations on what cross-platform software can do.
- millstone 7y agoThis strategy improves their bottom line because it enables products that users are more willing to spend money on.
- darklion 7y ago> and it’s all managed at the pleasure of their bottom line. As if Android’s come-one come-all is done out of benevolence. Google doesn’t have a heart, it had a bottom line too, and supporting those tools makes dollars come its way. Google HAD an opportunity to ensure that one browser engine ruled the web—-but they chose to fork WebKit into Blink, in part _because_ they didn’t want to share the work they were doing. It propped up competitors. Google would rather have a competitive—-read, monetary—-advantage than ensure web technology is widely available for all to use. For example, when Google refused to share the multi-process mode that differentiated Chrome from other browsers, it was a compelling enough security feature that Apple/WebKit reimplemented it independently so that everyone using WebKit could have it. Google proceeded to cry crocodile tears, and then promptly forked the WebKit codebase into Blink. They claimed it was necessary to avoid having to carry around two multi-process models, but it was a A PROBLEM OF THEIR OWN MAKING. So don’t imply Apple is profiteering, as if other companies are trying to give you hugs. Everybody’s finding cash in the ways that play to their strengths. If Google was really interested in pushing the web forward, they’d swallow their pride, take the bottom line hit, and merge Blink back into WebKit.
- soperj 7y ago> Google HAD an opportunity to ensure that one browser engine ruled the web—-but they chose to fork WebKit into Blink, in part _because_ they didn’t want to share the work they were doing. Apple had the same choice when it forked KHTML to produce Webkit.
- darklion 7y agoKHTML wasn’t anywhere near the same position as WebKit when Apple forked it. At the time, KHTML was niche beyond its use in KDE. When Google forked WebKit, Safari and Chrome combined were something like 40% of the market.
- soperj 7y agoso? Chrome was clearly the leader. Apple should have moved to their fork then if anything.
- st3fan 7y agoThis whole storm about macOS. Which is an extremely open platform. You can develop apps with amazing tools by Apple or you can do C, C++, Ruby, Java, Electron you name it. You don’t even have to pay anyone money to build an app and share it. There are a lot of misconceptions in this thread and claiming that macOS is not open is really the biggest IMO.
- lonelappde 7y agoThe OP is literally about Apple locking down a Mac API.
- jachee 7y agoBut only for App Store apps. The platform is still wide open for non-App-Store development.
- jsjohnst 7y ago> You can't deploy an app to a phone that you own unless you also own a Mac workstation running OS X and pay Apple $100/year for the privilege of using the very expensive hardware you bought from them. This hasn’t been true for a while now.