4 ms·
How much would it cost to take a three-day course with five skilled teachers ( http://philip.greenspun.com/teaching/rdbms-iap-2011 http://philip.greenspun.com/t
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
How much would it cost to take a three-day course with five skilled teachers ( http://philip.greenspun.com/teaching/rdbms-iap-2011 http://philip.greenspun.com/teaching/rdbms-iap-2011 )? Maybe $2000?
If only Greenspun had thought this through - then he might have suggested something like this:
for people who’ve been unemployed for 12 weeks, simply pay for a year of education in programs with proven records of skills-building (I guess you measure by how many finished and were able to get jobs)
I guess ad-hominem attacks are a lot easier than addressing Greenspun's simple economic question: "Is the 99-weeks-of-Xbox system that Congress created more sensible than it seems?"
- tptacek 16y agoThere are ~15MM unemployed people in the United States. Let's say we want to improve the lot of 20% of those people. To what program can we direct 3MM people for a year of skills-building that will result in those people, with some degree of certainty, becoming employable?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI'm not endorsing Greenspun's plan, I'm just pointing out that the original poster didn't even bother to read Greenspun's blog post. I'm personally a proponent of imposing unpleasant conditions on unemployment insurance to reduce moral hazard and make minimally productive use of the unemployed. For example, we can build a physical (rather than virtual) border fence with mexico with labor costs close to zero - we do is select random able-bodied unemployed people and make working on the border fence a condition of receiving further benefits. (Or similar projects - for example, we can reduce the waiting time at the DMV to 0.)
- tptacek 16y agoIs your answer to my question, "I can't think of one"?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoYes - I don't believe that training or education is a particularly useful solution for the vast majority of the unemployed. Again: "I'm not endorsing Greenspun's plan, I'm just pointing out that the original poster didn't even bother to read Greenspun's blog post." My belief is that most of the unemployed should accept lower wages, less pleasant jobs, and many should relocate. (Government assisted relocation was another one of Greenspun's suggestions, BTW.)
- chokma 16y agoThe cost to turn unemployed clerks into construction workers is not close to zero. They would need training, equipment, supervision, health benefits etc. For this reason, when here in Germany someone suggested to get all those unemployed to shovel snow during the winter, the local politicians did not want any such workers - while the unemployed would receive next to nothing, the cost to the community would be higher than having professionals do the job. Forcing people down on their luck to work for free is going to put pressure on the wages of those who do the same work for a living.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoOk, so lets turn unemployed clerks/realtors into DMV clerks, and unemployed construction workers into construction workers on a border fence. As for lowering wages, that's a good thing. Wage stickiness is a major contributor to recessions - this is one thing that Keynes, recalculationists, Austrians and ZMPists can all agree on. Downward wage pressure can help break the back of wage stickiness.
- jbooth 16y agoOne mechanism for that might be by advertising for the positions to attract the right kinds of candidates for each type, and then paying them. :)
- euroclydon 16y agoI don't see how there is any difference between 1) Preserving high wages by stifling the availability of workers and then charging a higher tax on the employed to pay unemployment benefits. And, 2) Letting there be more competition for available jobs, forcing wages down, but employing more people.
- tptacek 16y agoIf you believe that unemployment benefits habituate people to unemployment lifestyles, then reducing wages and increasing employment has the effect of "unsticking" people who would otherwise be locked into unemployment. That's the difference. There isn't really a controversy about whether unemployment benefits incentivize unemployment. They clearly do. In the absence of beneits, people would very rapidly find ways of obtaining income. The point of unemployment benefits is to allow them to find better income streams; ie, not by selling blood. If all unemployment benefits do is delay the inevitable trip to the blood bank, they are indeed a poor idea.
- sedachv 16y agoAsk a few questions, and this argument is revealed to be nonsense. How does unpaid ditch digging help unemployed find employment? What is the effect of unpaid ditch diggers on employed earthmovers/DMV workers? What happens if the unemployed are laid-off earthmovers/DMV workers? This is just another conservative/libnerdtarian [sic] anti-social rant against lower-class people. Ditch-digging doesn't work, neither does job training. If the government doesn't want to interfere in job creation, the most viable alternative to prevent mass social unrest is to just give people money. The real waste comes from trying to spend it on ditch-digging and job training welfare programs. Read Gordon Lafer's The Job Training Charade for the statistics, to understand what will happen to the US in the next 20 years, and for an answer to tptacek's original question (spoiler alert: such a program doesn't exist, because it's impossible). If you're a conservative and steam starts coming out of your ears at the thought of the undeserving welfare queens getting your tax dollar hand-outs, think of it this way: they're going to have the freedom to spend it on whatever they want, no big government telling them what to do to keep their welfare check. Isn't that the essence of economic liberty?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 16y agoIf Greenspun had thought it through he might not have suggested such ludicrous examples: Subsidising the high costs of aerospace engineering training and certification to add a few people to the back of that unemployment queue (behind the people with a decade's experience and two decades' aviation enthusiasm) doesn't sound like a better use of funds than buying X-boxes. Maybe the existing unemployed engineers should revitalise their resume with study at efficient modern universities like the University of Phoenix? If I wanted to contract non-nerd programmers to cut costs, the ex-clerk with the six month boondoggle programming course isn't going to get a look-in ahead of the cheaper outsourcing company staffed by smart graduates motivated enough to endure a CompSci degree in the hope they might one day impress the boss enough to make manager. If Greenspun had thought it through he probably wouldn't be implying a shortage of demand could readily be addressed by investing in increasing the oversupply of mediocre job candidates. Or, working at the high end of the state-subsidised education market, maybe he still would... I'm all in favour of state sponsored training, but he couldn't have made a much worse case for it.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIf Greenspun had thought it through he probably wouldn't be implying a shortage of demand... There is no longer a shortage of demand. Sales, consumption and production have more or less recovered to their pre-recession levels. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/INDPRO http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/INDPRO http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/PCE http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/PCE http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/RSAFS http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/RSAFS http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/GDP http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/GDP This would not have occurred if we had a shortage of demand. The only thing that hasn't recovered is employment - firms are meeting the same demand with fewer workers. This is why profits are up: http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CP http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CP This also suggests that it will be very difficult to solve the unemployment problem - it appears that most of the laid off workers were completely dispensable (perhaps with some changes to business processes). If they provided little of value to their former employers, it will be hard to convince a new employer that they will provide value for him/her.