4 ms·
> That said, he doesn't seem to have done anything actually wrong here. It doesn't even seem to be alleged that he's done anything objectively wrong. If LF want
by mschuster91 7y ago
> That said, he doesn't seem to have done anything actually wrong here. It doesn't even seem to be alleged that he's done anything objectively wrong. If LF wants to disallow right wing trolls at its conferences, they need to put that into the code of conduct more explicitly than they did.
The LF CoC is quite explicit: "Harassment will not be tolerated in any form, including but not limited to harassment based on gender, gender identity and expression, sexual orientation, disability, physical appearance, body size, race, age, religion or any other status protected by laws in which the conference or program is being held."
Given Mr. Trump's political actions especially against members of the LGBT community, disabled people (e.g. him mocking a reporter) or women ("grab them by the pussy"), it is crystal clear that associating oneself with Mr. Trump by wearing a MAGA hat is at least accepting those values and actions, and that this is open harassment towards people affected by Mr. Trump's politics.
Additionally, two paragraphs from the CoC also are a justification of the removal:
> All event participants are expected to behave in accordance with professional standards, with both the Linux Foundation Code of Conduct as well as their respective employer’s policies governing appropriate workplace behavior, and applicable laws
While wearing a MAGA hat is not illegal in itself, it is a violation of any kind of professional conduct.
> If a participant engages in harassing behavior, the conference organizers may take any action they deem appropriate, ranging from issuance of a warning to the offending individual to expulsion from the conference with no refund
And exactly this was the consequence. The troll knew what was coming for him, and I don't shed a tear.
- ajross 7y ago> While wearing a MAGA hat is not illegal in itself, it is a violation of any kind of professional conduct. Wearing a MAGA hat is literally political speech protected by the first amendment. I don't like it either, but... you can't go there, not really. I mean, yes, it's legal (because of the same first amendment) for the LF to enforce a de facto "No republicans" policy (which is effectively what you're asking for) at their conferences. But to argue that that was the intent behind the code of conduct policy is stretching reasonability way too far.
- mschuster91 7y ago> Wearing a MAGA hat is literally political speech protected by the first amendment. Sure, but (at least from my understanding of both US and German law) employers can demand that their employees not blast their individual political speech into the faces of their colleagues or customers. > But to argue that that was the intent behind the code of conduct policy is stretching reasonability way too far. The thing is it's almost exclusively Republicans and outright neo-Nazis who regularly and intentionally cross the lines between speech and harassment. Left-leaning people, from the odd "off to Gulag" meme and beaten up Spencer memes except, don't do this. It's not a fault of the CoC that today's Republican Party is a toxic white male supremacist hellhole.
- DuskStar 7y ago> > Wearing a MAGA hat is literally political speech protected by the first amendment. > Sure, but (at least from my understanding of both US and German law) employers can demand that their employees not blast their individual political speech into the faces of their colleagues or customers. But this isn't "don't talk politics with colleagues or customers". This is "don't talk politics when off work, ever", which is a whole different ball game. > > But to argue that that was the intent behind the code of conduct policy is stretching reasonability way too far. > The thing is it's almost exclusively Republicans and outright neo-Nazis who regularly and intentionally cross the lines between speech and harassment. Left-leaning people, from the odd "off to Gulag" meme and beaten up Spencer memes except, don't do this. It's not a fault of the CoC that today's Republican Party is a toxic white male supremacist hellhole. Um. Every "look at this deplatforming!" post I've seen on HN has been against someone insufficiently far left, being attacked by someone farther left - including this one. How is it that the Right is both so prevalent that their harassment campaigns are the vast majority of incidents, while also being so ineffective that all the major events we see here are the opposite?
- gwright 7y ago> The thing is it's almost exclusively Republicans and outright neo-Nazis who regularly and intentionally cross the lines between speech and harassment. Do you really believe that? You could watch videos for hours on YouTube with leftists screaming the most outrageous and ridiculous things. Then you have the endless fake incidents such as Jussie Smollett's tall tale in Chicago. I don't know how you answer the question of who is doing it the most but the claim that members of the left aren't engaging in harassment is absurd.
- Veelox 7y ago>While wearing a MAGA hat is not illegal in itself, it is a violation of any kind of professional conduct. To reduce your argument a bit, in the name of inclusion and diversity we must ban anyone who wears a MAGA hat. Something seems off with that...
- ajross 7y agoThat's the paradox of tolerance in a nutshell, yeah. As stated, I don't think public conferences are an appropriate forum for this kind of polarized argument, but it's not wrong either. Wearing a MAGA hat is declaring your alignment with a political platform that pervasively equates mexicans with dirty criminals, muslims with terrorists, gay and trans people with the mentally ill, and anyone who isn't a white rural christian with "not a real american". That's intolerance, straight up. And that's what you're telling me if you wear that thing. And if it's my environment your standing in I don't have to put up with it. Refusing to tolerate intolerance is the paradox, and the solution is to get out of my face with that hat.
- BurningCycles 7y ago>a political platform that pervasively equates mexicans with dirty criminals, muslims with terrorists, gay and trans people with the mentally ill, and anyone who isn't a white rural christian with "not a real american". Those are some extraordinary claims, I'd like to see something to back them up with.
- jonbronson 7y agoThese are hardly extraordinary claims. If you survey the daily news from dozens of media outlets for the past 3 years, what was described above is barely scratching the surface of the platform in question. The content itself, on the other hand, is certainly extraordinary in a perverse way. It's why event organizers have to take action against individuals who promote it.
- BurningCycles 7y ago
- monksy 7y ago> it is crystal clear that associating oneself with Mr. Trump by wearing a MAGA hat is at least accepting those values and actions, and that this is open harassment towards people affected by Mr. Trump's politics. You used the world "the". Charles Manson also used it and liked it. Are you advocating for serial killers?