3 ms·
I think idleness, xbox, unhappiness, and suicide are all compatible (in fact, reinforcing). In other words, I don't think the friend I mentioned was particular
by jessriedel 16y ago
I think idleness, xbox, unhappiness, and suicide are all compatible (in fact, reinforcing). In other words, I don't think the friend I mentioned was particularly happy.
Unless I'm grossly misinterpreting, you are constructing quite the straw man of the argument against long-term unemployment benefits. People who are skeptical aren't bothered because they think the unemployed are "too happy", they're bothered by the fact that the unemployed will have no direct incentive to find work. In fact, even the OP (who's post I think is stupid) doesn't characterize the unemployed as happy.
- jarek 16y agoReceiving barely enough to pay the bills, if that, that will soon end is not a direct incentive to find work in your book? Most people out there don't find new jobs in two weeks. Your friend could have afforded party time during the benefits period - once this run out, how long was he living off previous savings or external support?
- jessriedel 16y agoIt's the "soon end" part that's important. I'm not arguing against all unemployment benefits, I'm describing the argument against long-term benefits. My friend was living off solely unemployment benefits for over a year.
- jarek 16y agoInteresting -- was he living with parents? My impression was, and the comments here seem to confirm, that most (all?) U.S. unemployment payouts aren't really enough to live on carefree while casually paying slope fees.
- jessriedel 16y agoNo he was not. He was living in a house with his own room and one or two other roommates. From page 7 of this http://www.edd.ca.gov/pdf_pub_ctr/de1275a.pdf http://www.edd.ca.gov/pdf_pub_ctr/de1275a.pdf I believe that if you make $47k or more in the year leading up to your unemployment (technically, if you made more than $11.6k in the highest quarter of that year), your benefits are $450/week or $1900/month or $23,464/year. Raising a family of 4 on that would be challenging, but it's easily enough to live carefree in Santa Barbara, CA (where I lived, with one of the highest housing prices in the US) as a 26 year-old bachelor while paying $500 for a skiing season pass and several hundred dollars per year in mountain biking repair costs. (Both he and I were avid mountain bikers; trails are usually free, but the repairs weren't.) I took home $1600/month as a grad student while saving money and frequenting cheap bars, so I know this is very easily lived on. Of Course, I didn't have quite as much free time for boarding and biking as he did.