7 ms·
This is brilliant. If you ask me this is exactly the type of approach that has been missing from the climate discussion. As a natural born skeptic, the curren
by mistermann 7y ago
This is brilliant. If you ask me this is exactly the type of approach that has been missing from the climate discussion. As a natural born skeptic, the current approach of simplistic, repetitive, and often technically incorrect news articles and half-informed scolding by politicians, celebrities, and internet armchair climatologists smells way too much like propaganda or a cult.
> The front page shows the main indicators. Beneath each one there is additional detail, drilling down into why the indicator is important, how it has changed and how it was calculated. The pages also link through to the data so that you can explore it for yourself.
Just the facts (well, it's a start anyways) presented visually (presumably honestly) so the the meaning is obvious, with the ability to drill down to learn why the numbers are important, where the data comes from and how to get to it yourself, as well as links to where to learn more. Beautiful.
Under democratic governments, people need to largely align their opinions before we can finally start doing something about this problem, and I believe this is a crucial part of the type of persuasion it is going to take. I think there is still room for improvement, but I haven't seen this approach taken before and hope it becomes more popular. In fact, I believe the "pro" side should team up and produce one single authoritative website, and advertise the hell out of it - the fact that such a resource doesn't exist has always added to my skepticism.
- perfunctory 7y ago> If you ask me this is exactly the type of approach that has been missing from the climate discussion. Missing? Did you live under a rock? All these charts aren’t new information. It’s always been just one click away if you cared to look. Ok, maybe two clicks.
- kaybe 7y agoI can recommend looking at the IPCC reports for anyone missing data plots from the discussion: https://www.ipcc.ch/ https://www.ipcc.ch/ eg https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/ https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/ https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar5/syr/ https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar5/syr/ Each of the report pages has 'Graphics' subpages for the chapters that give you just the figures and some explanations. (You might need to look at the pdf for some more details.)
- mistermann 7y ago> All these charts aren’t new information. You seem to have not read my entire comment. Perhaps you didn't care to look. This sort of behavior is interestingly common in forum discussions on this topic.
- CuriousSkeptic 7y agoOne issue with these graphs is that they show a linear response, from which people extrapolate a linear forecast. People talk about the impact on future generations and such. But if you closely on the ice cap graph for example you’ll notice an increased oscillation in more recent data. This has been described as a sign of a complex system reaching the end of the linear response, a tipping point if you will. You’ll need to listen to the experts to interpret the data, and what most of them seems worried about is the non-linear changes.
- PavlovsCat 7y ago> the current approach of simplistic, repetitive, and often technically incorrect news articles and half-informed scolding by politicians That's not "the" current approach, that's your selective perception and/or framing. Democracy restrains governments, not people. At some point "failing to convince" has to translate to "shun and withdraw support from". We can't possibly throw away the human species because "some people weren't convinced there is an issue", as if they were children and the others adults with a burden of convincing, which does not exist. Climate change has been warned about since I can remember, it's certainly been a topic in the last 20 years. At this point, no adult has a solid excuse anymore.
- mistermann 7y agoSo why is nothing being done? I think we both want something done, and yet here we are. Democracy doesn't restrain people, really? The issues are numerous, but each person gets one vote for one party/person, effectively they are approving all of the subsequent decisions of the party they've voted for, when what they're really doing is accepting the aggregate of their promises. Shun and withdraw support all you want, is that producing results, or not? If your approach isn't producing results, am I crazy for suggesting we think more deeply about strategy?
- PavlovsCat 7y ago> Democracy doesn't restrain people, really? Not socially, not when it comes to the individual relations. I didn't mean convicing or voting are pointless, but it's not the end-all, be-all. It works for the lucky cases, but the bulk of the problem will require stepping on toes and deciding between mutually exclusive things. Nobody who denies climate change actually wants to grow up in a refugee camp in 100 years and die at age 10, after 10 years of horror, to name just one of the consequences. Or in a society ravaged by Neonazis (unless they're Neonazis, then fuck what they want). So it's up to their betters to enforce their lack of consequence and intellectual integrity on them. They can't leave it at "failed to convince". Which, by definition, contains prior attempts to convince, just not an infinite number of them. > If your approach isn't producing results, am I crazy for suggesting we think more deeply about strategy? Who will "convince Trump", for example? You are simply are assuming good faith, functioning humans on the other hand without mental health defects, so what's your answer to where that isn't the case?