4 ms·
How do you measure the level of the sea at the mm precision? It is highly doubtful we are able to do that with any kind of instrumentation, more so around the w
by ekianjo 7y ago
How do you measure the level of the sea at the mm precision? It is highly doubtful we are able to do that with any kind of instrumentation, more so around the whole world at the same time.
EDIT: they say they measure everything with satellites, but that does not mean there is no incertitude in the measurement. No measurement is 100% accurate, and I'd certainly like to see the error range of satellites, when even GPS can't do better than +/- 30 cm precision.
- hadrien01 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tide_gauge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tide_gauge
- throwaway744678 7y agoThese do not account for the movement of the ground itself, it wpuld only be a relative measure.
- superqwert 7y agoIf the ground is sinking rather than the sea rising, the impact will be pretty similar!
- pygy_ 7y ago1) Make a lot of imprecise measurements. 2) Average them. The more measurements, the closer the average will be to the truth.
- throwaway744678 7y agoOnly if the error is distributed evenly.
- pygy_ 7y agoSince we're interested in the delta, even if it isn't even, it will not matter as long as the error distribution is constant during the whole experiment.
- ekianjo 7y agoIf you are within the range of error of your instruments you can average what you want all you will get is random noise. Averaging within the noise threshold does not bring you closer to the truth.on top of that there are waves on the sea so this is not even a flat and fixed surface we are talking about.
- teraflop 7y agoAFAIK, satellite sea level measurements are only really accurate to a few cm. But when many measurements are averaged over long periods of time, that's still good enough to observe trends on the order of a few mm per year. A bit more information about the measurement process: https://research.csiro.au/slrwavescoast/sea-level/measurements-and-data/sea-level-measurements/#SatAlt https://research.csiro.au/slrwavescoast/sea-level/measuremen...
- mistermann 7y agoEach diagram should have a FAQ with answers to questions like ekianjo's, otherwise a conspiratorial attack is too easy. The "pro" side should read and learn from forum discussion like this (other issues pointed out: "All of the charts should use the same time scale. It's confusing and misleading to use different scales for each", "I wonder why the chart for CO2 concentration starts at 1960 vs 1850 for the global mean temperature difference", "Interesting graphs, but it's a little confusing that all but one of them use difference of the metric (i.e. relative values) instead of absolute values -- what and when are the differences relative to?"), making notes on criticisms and improving their presentations. I think "The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again, but expecting different results" has some relevance here.
- superqwert 7y agoThat is very interesting! how do they know that a difference in a satellite measurement is not due to slippage in its orbit?
- teraflop 7y agoThe nice thing about satellite orbits is that they are extremely steady and predictable. Over long time scales, a satellite's orbit drifts due to many effects, such as non-uniformity of Earth's gravity. But over short timescales, its motion is very precisely determined by its orbital parameters. In particular, there's a precise relationship between a satellite's orbital period and its orbital radius (technically, its semi-major axis). A one-centimeter variation in altitude would result in a timing error of several hundred microseconds per day, which is enough to be detected using precise clocks and Doppler effect measurements.