4 ms·
There are currently three New York Times articles on the front page of HN. None of them are particularly interesting or well-written. I really don’t see why thi
by keiferski 7y ago
There are currently three New York Times articles on the front page of HN. None of them are particularly interesting or well-written. I really don’t see why this is necessary.
- lackbeard 7y agoI would be happy if the New York Times was banned from this site. An awful lot of low quality and off topic content from there seems to constantly make it to the front page here.
- gerbilly 7y ago> An awful lot of low quality and off topic content from there seems to constantly make it to the front page here. It makes it to the front page because people vote it up. This makes it de facto on-topic.
- nullc 7y agoHN moderation frequently removes things that people upvote-- including some of the most upvoted subjects (they're upvoted a lot because they're divisive political stuff). I think this is good, FWIW. I just don't think it's useful to argue that it shouldn't be removed just because it's upvoted because that's clearly not how HN is run.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoThat's a separate issue than what's happening in this thread: someone accusing upvoted content of being off-topic. afaict, HN mods generally remove submissions because their comments are a dumpster fire. Though I haven't witnessed it in a while. The last dumpster fire comment section I saw, dang just stickied his comment to try to encourage people to get back on the topic of the article and avoid the obvious knee-jerk response to it.
- gho77 7y agoIndividual contributor seeks change in group behavior to more closely appease contributors individual preference. Such high quality discourse
- deadbunny 7y agoI would hazard a guess that it's because other people find them more interesting than you, hence they get upvoted.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gho77 7y agoA hand wavey subjective dismissal at the quality of writing is hardly a substantive critique. How are they all to be seen as not well written? Too many comma splices? Are they factually accurate and you don’t agree with the tone? Are they factually incorrect and you like the tone? “Knee jerk hot take” is pretty unnecessary.
- 1helloworld1 7y agoNot surprising since they produce a lot of original content that's pertinent to the smarter crowd.