9 ms·
I don't disagree except with this: > But if you've ever been in the situation, or seen it up close, you know it's not at all what it looks like. I've personal
by jessriedel 16y ago
I don't disagree except with this:
> But if you've ever been in the situation, or seen it up close, you know it's not at all what it looks like.
I've personally known a guy on unemployment for over a year, able-bodied with a college degree. He snowboarded 5 days a week, but admitted that when his unemployment ran out he was probably going to have to start looking for a job. It really was "party time" for him, though I don't claim he was the norm. I'm just giving this anecdotal evidence to say that if we want to discuss the usefulness of long-term unemployment benefits, we're going to need hard data. Your descriptions of what unemployment is really like aren't any more convincing evidence than the OP's.
- dailyrorschach 16y agoWell, again this is all anecdotal. But in my experience with friends and personal, it really depends on whether or not the young person has a support system from their parents or others. In my case, less then a year after graduation the agency I was working at lost our biggest client, I was the newest hire, and was in the first round of what ended up being a reduction of, no exaggeration 90% of the entire company so it could then be acquired. This was March 2009. I didn't have any real savings, and my parents couldn't bail me out. I qualified for the maximum which was about $316 per week after taxes. So of course immediately I was looking for a job, and had an offer in hand by the end of April, but it was for a lower paying job, it was clearly a stop-gap job. I think many people my age, don't want stop-gaps, but when you don't have a support system you need to do what needs to be done. Of course I kept moving forward and looking to move up, made a move from DC to NY for better money, and continue advancing. But had I not taken the "stop-gap" I would've crashed and burned. And so, the other folks I know who didn't take similar paths had one thing in common: they could count on their families or some financial support system. I don't begrudge that, I would do the same for my future heretofore unborn children, but it seems to me to be a common thread.
- roc 16y agoIt's not evidence. It's an anecdotal counter-point to an unfounded and all-to-common lazy characterization. Feel free to look up any number of sociological and economic studies about what happens to people who are on unemployment. Suicide rises, separation rises (divorce itself tends not to, as divorce is expensive), domestic abuse rises, savings plummet, bankruptcy rises, foreclosure rises, future earnings drop. The studies have shown that it looks nothing like party time in the aggregate. But somehow that doesn't stop people moralizing from a privileged vantage. Edit: Frankly, it's just the same damn Welfare Queen argument all over again and I keep hoping that nonsense was long since disproved and buried, back with Trickle Down and the rest of Reagan's 'conservative' fiscal bonafides.
- presidentender 16y ago>It's not evidence. In fairness, neither is yours. My anecdotes regarding the unemployed match GP poster, not yours. For the unemployed young I've known, it is "party time." I do not claim that my anecdotal information is data on which to base policy decisions.
- loup-vaillant 16y agoActually, they're both evidence. What count are their respective strength. Nevertheless, your data point suggest we could characterize the "partying unemployed". I'd guess these people are mostly, young, middle class, don't have any family to feed, and can count on their parents to back them up if they really mess up. (Some of these factors are of course correlated by causation links.)
- presidentender 16y agoMine are entirely young, lower-class, and without family. They've all been students in the recent past, which corresponds to an inexpensive lifestyle... and they still get the same amount of unemployment as anyone else. One particularly striking example is a fellow who works summers fighting fires for the forest service, and is "unemployed" the rest of the year. It's not a safety net or insurance in his case, it's planned (I'm unsure as to whether he's able to do this repeatedly, or only for the one year).
- roc 16y ago> "In fairness, neither is yours. " That's what I said. At least,that's what I meant to say. Trying again: My post is not and was not meant to be 'evidence'. It's just a (somewhat exasperated) refusal to swallow Greenspun's characterization of 'unemployment==party time' without any support. > "For the unemployed young I've known, it is "party time."" And from the outside, many knowledge jobs can appear to be "party time" too. If I had a nickle for every time I heard someone characterize my job as "just sitting at a desk" or "surfing the internet all day", I could enjoy some party-time. The point being: if someone is going to cast aspersions from the outside, they should probably bring more than some selective reporting highlights and appeals to "what we all know".
- marquis 16y agoYes, these examples certainly are not fair-use. I see it as that we decide, as a people, to not force difficult requirements on getting unemployment. It is a humanitarian decision: in the hopes that 99% of those who get it, need it, rather than denying support to those who cannot meet strict rules in the attempt to avoid abuse. Similar to the rule that it is better to let 100 guilty criminals go free rather than incarcerate a single innocent person.