5 ms·
The study had a tiny sample size (104 kids? There's 7.7 billion people total), it asked kids to do arithmetic while lying in a brain scanner and found it can't
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
The study had a tiny sample size (104 kids? There's 7.7 billion people total), it asked kids to do arithmetic while lying in a brain scanner and found it can't distinguish between the two sexes in the results of the experiments. Or in other words, a weak study turned up no significant result. That's not news.
The meat and potatoes of the article are in this passage, which has true explanatory power (and seems to be based on actual experimental results):
But Geary says an international study he did with Gijsbert Stoet at the University of Essex suggests a different explanation.
Using an international database on adolescent achievement in science, mathematics and reading, they found that in two-thirds of all countries, female students performed at least as well as males in science.
Yet paradoxically, females in wealthier countries with more gender equality, including the U.S., were less likely than females in other countries to get degrees in fields like math and computer science.
Geary thinks the reason may be that women in these countries are under less pressure to choose a field that promises an economic payback and have more freedom to pursue what interests them most.
Also, males may be more likely to choose science because they are less likely than females to have strong reading, writing and language skills, Geary says.
If in most countries girls do as well as boys in science we can lay to rest any ideas about genetic advantages. If women and men behave differently with regards to maths and science in different parts of the world we can safely assume the differences are cultural.
The international study mentioned above is the one that npr should be reporting. Not this garbage study looking at kids' brains on Sesame Street.
- pfortuny 7y agoBoys and girls in a brain scanner use the same area of brain for mathematics... What could be wrong...
- SiempreViernes 7y agoLook, the "gender paradox" results aren't super new, going back to something like 2012, don't blame a npr pice about a new study for you not knowing older news. Additionally, the gender paradix results don't have any clear interpretation, they robustly indicate a lack of understanding but little else: https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/10/gender-differences-in-personality-are-bigger-in-egalitarian-countries/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/10/gender-differences-i... Finally, discounting a MRI study that does high resolution studies of brain activity as garbage based on critera apropriate for surveys isn't apropriate. Samples of around 50 participants are actually well motivated for fMRI studies: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3427872/#!po=1.00000 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3427872/#!po=1....
- Izkata 7y ago> If in most countries girls do as well as boys in science we can lay to rest any ideas about genetic advantages. Yep. > If women and men behave differently with regards to maths and science in different parts of the world we can safely assume the differences are cultural. No, we cannot safely assume that. That's not even what the part you quoted says. Probably the single most common argument about why the split occurs in wealthy countries is around interest, not ability. And that can indeed be genetically driven. To me it looks like the "gender paradox" has a trivially simple solution: Men are more interested in math and math-like fields than women (and women more interested than men in people-focused fields, just look at ones like nursing or teaching), this is at least partially genetically driven, and ability has nothing to do with it. This is part of the reasoning in what you quoted: > Geary thinks the reason may be that women in these countries are under less pressure to choose a field that promises an economic payback and have more freedom to pursue what interests them most.
- perl4ever 7y agoIn the abstract... An alternative hypothesis for why group X (and not Y) dominates field Z, is that members of group Y who are good at Z usually are also good at other things, which they usually prefer, while group X disproportionately contains people that are only good at Z. So it's possible that most Z's are X even though they are on average less able and without unfair discrimination.