4 ms·
One thing I didn't hear noted is that unemployment is also considered a low friction way of getting money back into th economy. Those people on unemployment us
by kenjackson 16y ago
One thing I didn't hear noted is that unemployment is also considered a low friction way of getting money back into th economy. Those people on unemployment usually spend the money (not save), and there tends to be less protest in doing this than other forms of welfare.
Additionally, I think there is a belief that to really move the needle we're going to need to really get business back to hiring. I don't think the deamnd in the job market is low end programming -- you can find tons of students graduating from Phoenix U and Devry for that. It's the "hit the ground running" expert talent. Someone who can come in and immediately start building iPhone and Android apps (even web talent seems to have much more supply than demand).
For some of these people 99 weeks may be sufficient to get them up to speed for such a task, but I do think it will be difficult. First they have to find good training, which in itself will be tough if they aren't web or tech savvy. I just don't think someone who can edit a picture is going to be hired in this market climate.
- ams6110 16y agoExcept the money for unemployment is confiscated from working people's paychecks, so it's a net wash on the economy at best, less the sizable bureaucratic overhead.
- gwern 16y ago'at best' is an incomplete picture. Redistributing wealth is zero or negative-sum, yes, but utility is not linear in wealth. It's logarithmic or less (wealth diminishing marginal utility). To be opposed to redistribution despite the obvious fact that it would create utility, one has to bring in additional concepts. For example, one might take some sort of ethical stand on redistribution being Pareto-inefficient. Or one might argue that the additional growth from inequality will eventually outweigh the disutility of respecting wealth inequality. (Either of these might not apply during depressed economic periods.)
- kenjackson 16y agoBut the money taken from working people's paychecks are more likely to not be as stimulative (although you could argue that it effects morale which then indirectly has impact). Giving money to people in unemployment is probably 90% of the way to giving money right to small business. Which in turn will pay their employees. There seems to be very little reason not to do it except for the two psychological effects we alluded to earlier: 1) My paycheck is now lower by .2%... I'm going to spend less. 2) Unemployment isn't so bad. I can slack off, because I wouldn't mind a 99 week vacation. (or other similar sentiments). I'm not sure either is happening in measurable numbers to offset the gain had by the extra money pumped into the economy.
- _delirium 16y agoIn this case, it came from issuing new government bonds, which has effects as well, but not quite the same ones. Taxes were not raised to pay for unemployment benefits; in fact, in the short-term political calculus, extending benefits led to lower taxes (the unemployment extension was part of the bipartisan compromise on extending the Bush tax cuts). Future taxes will likely pay for it in some form, but not current ones, which is one reason it has a stimulative effect. It's also what most economists recommend in many parts of the political spectrum (countercyclic fiscal policy).
- encoderer 16y agoIf I got an extra $100 or so on my paycheck, it would have very little economic utility. It would just be added to my pile of savings. But if you take that $100 from me and give it to an unemployed person, they are going to spend 100% of that, guaranteed. Moreover, I'm not following you on the "less the sizable bureaucratic overhead" comment. You make it seem as if the gov't takes $100 from me, burns $10 in the White House Furnace, and gives $90 to the unemployed person. On the contrary, every dollar of "bureaucratic overhead" is income for somebody -- a government contractor, supplier or employee. I've never understood why people act like the money the government spends just vanishes from the economy. Yes, a small, small fraction of it goes overseas. But it's so small it cannot be described as "sizable."
- d2viant 16y agoIf I got an extra $100 or so on my paycheck, it would have very little economic utility. It would just be added to my pile of savings. Nonsense. That's great that you'd save the $100, but even if you do that it still has economic utility, presuming you're putting it into a bank account. It then gets lent out to businesses or reinvested into the economy. The bank isn't sitting on a giant pile of money.
- kenjackson 16y agoThe bank isn't sitting on a giant pile of money. I thought banks were sitting on giant piles of money (thanks to the Fed), hence the low interest rates?
- d2viant 16y agoIn a sense, yes, but that's mainly on the books and it depends on which interest rate you're referring to. You're right, much of the bailout money was used to cushion the capital accounts of these institutions. However, banks are businesses too and at the moment happen to be making tremendous profits, much of it due to the spreads they're getting on the low lending rate from the Feds.
- ZachPruckowski 16y ago