3 ms·
The problem with pointing to the influx from rivers is that you also have to look at the outflow of uranium (and there must be such an outflow, probably reducti
by pfdietz 7y ago
The problem with pointing to the influx from rivers is that you also have to look at the outflow of uranium (and there must be such an outflow, probably reduction of uranium to insoluble U(IV) in sediments, since it's in steady state.) Any human extraction is on top of this existing outflow, it doesn't replace it.
- manfredo 7y agoThe outflow is from the earth's crust at the bottom of the ocean. Sure, it doesn't get replaced. But there's enough uranium to last on the order of billions of years. By this logic, solar power isn't renewable either because the hydrogen in the sun doesn't get replaced.
- pfdietz 7y agoNo, I believe it's mostly from rivers. Oceanic crust is depleted in uranium relative to continental crust. Moreover, uranium becomes soluble in oxidizing conditions (as U(VI)), not in reducing conditions (as U(IV)).
- pfdietz 7y agoI misread what you wrote there. Anyway, in steady state the consumption from the oceans can be only equal to the inflow from rivers. If that's (as I've seen estimated) 25,000 tons/year, that's enough to power the world if breeders are used, but not enough if today's thermal burner reactors are used.
- wahern 7y agoThe paper does look at the outflow. In fact, in the same paragraph as the "money quote" I copied it says, "uranium has a residence time of approximately 500,000 years". It's not clear to me that the 9000 tonnes is net or gross, but either way your original point still stands: ocean uranium is nowhere near a limitless resource, and could likely be made economically unviable[1] in a rather short timespan, perhaps even in a single human lifespan if we switched overnight to 100% energy generation from dissolved uranium. What's more surprising, actually, is how much uranium we consume currently. And AFAIU, we do so very inefficiently. Seems to me we'd get a much better RoI by using uranium more efficiently than by turning to seawater for more uranium to waste. [1] Assuming it becomes viable in the first place. It certainly doesn't seem economically viable, today.