4 ms·
This idea that an art critic (or any cultural critic) has to be from the country in question (or of the same race/gender/etc) to have a valid opinion is anti-in
by dmix 7y ago
This idea that an art critic (or any cultural critic) has to be from the country in question (or of the same race/gender/etc) to have a valid opinion is anti-intellectual and misguided.
And that is all this is, just the views and opinions of a single person. It's not some foreign nation state trying to dictate what another country should be doing.
- coldtea 7y ago>This idea that an art critic (or any cultural critic) has to be from the country in question (or of the same race/gender/etc) to have a valid opinion is anti-intellectual and misguided This is not art criticism, this is telling another country what to do with the art in their museums...
- dmix 7y ago> This is not art criticism, I didn't say it was, but as an art critic he's more than sufficiently qualified to share his opinions on art galleries around the world. He visits art galleries for a living. He has plenty of credibility to make such a critique and there's absolutely nothing wrong with the fact he's American or writing for an American paper. It's amazing what some people choose to get offended by. Or how people seek out mini power-trips by rejecting a diversity of ideas, pushing the idea only people born in some place or with certain attributes can be allowed to critique things. Or at worst the inherent xenophobia of dismissing foreigners opinions because they weren't born in the same country of the thing they are critiquing (which France and the french are notorious for, even here in Canada).
- coldtea 7y ago>It's amazing what some people choose to get offended by. So like an author for NYT getting caught up by what a French museum has on display? >Or at worst the inherent xenophobia of dismissing foreigners opinions because they weren't born in the same country of the thing they are critiquing I didn't know not MYOB was "xenophobia". Let me see you criticize black or Native American culture now, and calling them "xenophobic" if they don't take lightly to your suggestions. Or is that accusation confined to the French?