10 ms·
> Section 75 came about as a result of a sweeping review of pension regulation in the wake of the Robert Maxwell scandal in the 1990s. > It's not some crazy b
by dmix 7y ago
> Section 75 came about as a result of a sweeping review of pension regulation in the wake of the Robert Maxwell scandal in the 1990s.
> It's not some crazy bureaucratic maze or malevolent government
hmm
Policy designed for big firms, and in reaction to a few bad billionaire's or hundred millionaire's actions, which then destroys or squeezing out the small companies is one of the most common complaints against regulations like this. It's how you end up with only mega-corps and no competition or upward mobility for the middle class, and everyone wondering why there's a wealth gap when your only option is to work at bigco.
This stuff always starts out with good intentions like "punishing the rich". And then some nobody middle-class plumber in Scotland is the one being forced to sell his house while Maxwell's family trust is still worth millions.
Meanwhile law changes are never a 'simple fix', these sorts of things stick around for decades.
Edit: note Robert Maxwell was the billionaire(?) father of Ghislaine Maxwell who was Epstein's second-in-command in the sex ring
- commandlinefan 7y ago> law changes are never a 'simple fix' The article’s completely baseless tie-in to Brexit illustrates this: “Hey, man, I’d love to fix your problem, but those xenophobic bigots voted on something completely unrelated, so there’s nothing I can do…”
- iamflimflam1 7y agoThere’s nothing they can do because all the legislative time is being taken up by trying to do something impossible.
- throwaway5752 7y agoYes, financial regulation is hard. People are always trying to game it. Unfortunately there are really good reasons to avoid ex post facto laws. So you have the cat and mouse game where people find a loophole, exploit it, and it gets fixed. It gives the appearance of people "getting away with it". Overall the system works, and - almost by definition - you just hear about the exceptions. The solution isn't to give up.
- friedman23 7y agoThe solution is to not offer pensions.
- behringer 7y agoThat's a great short term solution, but then what do you do with society's old people? We still haven't yet seen what's about to happen with the destruction of pensions in the US.
- Bombthecat 7y agoGermany will probably find out soon...
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoHow so? Germany's population is aging, but they're also importing immigrants like there's no tomorrow to ballance things out.
- Bombthecat 7y agoIt will take two or three generations before they make (enough) money to pay for the "high pensions" of old Germans... And even we get a ton of new people. The old generations are still more.. M
- distances 7y agoFor someone not familiar with the German situation, do you have some article or other details to clarify?
- xkde 7y agoThe same thing as the thousands of years prior to pensions?
- fzeroracer 7y ago
- pas 7y agoIt's not impossible. Any such punish the rich law must to start above certain size. Gradual (progressive) formulas work best.
- dmix 7y agoI'm a big fan of contextual laws with expiring timelines. One size fits all laws that are used like hammers for every industry and every company size are very destructive (the positive data supporting things like minimum wage laws are almost always limited to a few industries like mega-chain fast food restaurants, while there is plenty of evidence of harm for young and temporary workers). The conditions of marketplaces also constantly change where expiring/renewal should be a function of the policy.
- pas 7y agoI don't know, we don't have these sunset laws, they seem like an inefficient, because they lead to too much change without change in the environment. And become big rallying points to either keep them afloat or finally get rid of them. This of course could drive compromise, or just lead to a lot more tit-for-tat destruction. (You let expire that, now we'll let this one expire!)
- Spooky23 7y agoYou can’t exempt small plans because big fish buy companies for the express purpose of raiding the pension fund.
- Angostura 7y ago> This stuff always starts out with good intentions like "punishing the rich" No. This stuff starts out with good intentions like - "not leaving people who have retired, suddenly with no pension and having to live in poverty or rely on the state, rather than on the employer pension that they had promised would be there for them". It''s not there to punish the rich. In this case, however, the formula being used to determine whether a pension scheme is in trouble seems the problem and it needs to be reviewed urgently.