5 ms·
Instead of a functioning government you got traditional clan law, militia demanding protection money and offering nothing in return, and your route to the "free
by notahacker 16y ago
Instead of a functioning government you got traditional clan law, militia demanding protection money and offering nothing in return, and your route to the "free market" was greased by paying armed men collecting rents at checkpoints.
.
Of course, judging freedom using the Mises Institute benchmark of government spending being 0% of GDP left Somalia a surefire winner, but I'll happily trade some of that essential liberty for the second best of Western liberal democracy.
- nika 16y agoI do not understand why it is popular to characterize somalia in this way. Have you got a reference to militias demanding money and offering nothing in return? It seems this would be a very dangerous thing to attempt in somalia, as the members of most tribes are pretty well armed and would not put up with this. Somalia is a tribal country with institutions that provide legal and judicial support for resolving disputes peacefully going back centuries. I'm sure they do have private roads, for which you have to pay a toll, but you have toll roads in many countries. I read one report that the pirates who were operating off of the somali coast operated like startups. One guy would put up some guns, others would put up labor, another the boat, some would stay ashore and provide financing or support. The profits would be divided among them according to their shares. The system works because the desire to go out again keeps them honest. The "pirates" effectively operate as the somali coast guard, going after ships that are in their states waters. These pirates were previously fisherman until china decided that they could start overfishing the area. So they go and collect tolls. I guess it is romantic to call them pirates, and it certainly serves the interests of the west to characterize somalia as a hellhole. But the primary problem facing somalia is not that they don't have a functioning society-- they do-- but that the western interests, specifically the US and the UK, keep making war on them. The UN created schools but the teachers are unmotivated, and so the somalis, who are generally relatively wealthy, set up private schools of their own. I have a friend who has been there and who worked on a proposal to put in a port and a road across some of the territory into ethiopia. However, the investors were scared off when an american general promised to "bomb the hell out of it" if they built the road and the port. So, my knowledge of the situation on the ground is dated a few years and mostly relevant to the north. But Somalia is actually a relatively safe, stable society, it exhibits a fair bit of success in free market principles and in operating without a state. They are able to provide security, and repel invasions for the most part, without a central government.
- astrodust 16y agoI think what you're saying is for a country suffering under an oppressive level of religion, virtual civil war and a perpetual inter-clan power struggle, they're not doing too badly for themselves. Your assertion that Somalians are generally relatively wealthy does seem a huge stretch for a country with such a large population living in abject poverty.
- nika 16y agoThere is no civil war and no perpetual inter-clan power struggle. What defines and "oppressive" level of religion is in the eye of the beholder. It is unfortunate that ideology causes americans to believe propaganda over the reports of people who have been to somalia and somalis themselves.
- shadowfox 16y agoCan you provide some references to these reports?
- borism 16y agothere's no civil war!? wtf are you smoking?
- nika 16y agoThe truth. It's the anti-drug. Oh, I see now. In western propaganda the ethiopian invaders you armed and sent to take over our country are really somehow "Somalis" and your illegal and immoral invasion is somehow our civil war? Yeah, someone is smoking something!
- DennisP 16y agoNot only that but somebody's been dumping nuclear waste and other toxins near their coastline. Since they don't have a government with a coast guard, I don't know how else they're supposed to handle the situation.