4 ms·
Wouldn’t taxing wealth reduce the real value of properties? Say you have a 100 acre farm[1] valued at $100 and produces $10 of goods annually. If you start ta
by mc32 7y ago
Wouldn’t taxing wealth reduce the real value of properties?
Say you have a 100 acre farm[1] valued at $100 and produces $10 of goods annually. If you start taxing on the $100, no one is going to pay $100 for the farm once a wealth tax is implemented as now they are taking on tax liability that previously didn’t exist.
[1]for the sake of argument and illustration, were ignoring property taxes which are like wealth taxes.
- croon 7y agoIs that a problem (within reason)?
- pjc50 7y agoDepends entirely on what the tax rates are and what other conditions apply. Pay 1% tax of a dollar, collect $10 in agricultural subsidies? Besides, for residential property, stemming the unsustainable increase in value is also a desireable goal to make it more affordable.
- naravara 7y agoAlternatively, it could create incentives to develop and use existing property for higher productivity applications.
- mc32 7y agoI see it being regressive and encouraging small farmers to sell out to large operators who can more economically scale production.
- croon 7y agoThey already compete under the same parameters before, so this should be unchanged.
- mc32 7y agoNot if the pressures pushes industry toward “higher productivity applications” as outlined by patent commenter.
- croon 7y agoSmall farmers don't want higher productivity already?
- mc32 7y agoHow? They can’t leverage the same markets they can’t leverage economies of scale, etc. A conglomerate can find new markets when another one dries up. A grocery store closes, it’s not easy for s local farmer suddenly find a new buyer, for example.
- croon 7y agoI understand that. What I'm pointing out is that the small farmer already needs to cover all expenses through their sales price, which already is competing with conglomerates capable of much higher economies of scale. An expense increase for both parties won't affect the dynamic already in place.
- naravara 7y agoYou'd be surprised. They certainly want higher yields and returns, but many people can be resistant to making the kinds of changes or long term investments to actually realize those goals. Corporate/bureaucratic governance is arguably more prone to doing the sorts of bloodless cost/benefit analysis that can push productivity, while smaller family farms might be more focused on just getting through the day-to-day work. That plus a lot of productivity gains come from returns to scale and logistical capacity that you need to be at a certain size to realize. It's just out of reach for smaller entities.
- croon 7y agoNone of these facts differ between a before/after of the discussed scenario.
- naravara 7y agoThe ship sailed on this decades ago. "Small farms" at this point are just sticking it out as a hobby instead of being able to make a livelihood out of it. They're mostly contracted out to BigAg now except in places where there is a strong farmer's union/Co-Op scene.
- throw0101a 7y ago> Wouldn’t taxing wealth reduce the real value of properties? Implementation dependent. You may use "net worth": so if you have a $1,000,000 property but a $600,000 mortgage, your net worth $400K. Many of the proposals for the US start "higher" ($32M for Sanders, $50M for Warren) which probably would not hit a good portion of the population.
- beefield 7y ago> Wouldn’t taxing wealth reduce the real value of properties? Yes. That's almost like magic. You get cheaper properties, the property tax revenue is used to reduce your other taxes so your net income does not decrease (on average, of course). So you actually get more money to spend otherwise than into your mortgage. Almost like alchemy. Turning taxes to wealth...
- Konnstann 7y agoYou don't get reduced taxes though, so your net income does decrease. The wealth tax isn't going to take the place of any other tax, it is in addition to the taxes already in place. Whether you believe in the legitimacy of the wealth tax or not the people paying it won't be better off, nor will most of the people not paying it (disregarding benefits of the programs funded by the tax).
- beefield 7y agoIf the other taxes do not decrease, then that means you get some other benefit where the money is democratically being allocated. Tax money generally does not just disappear in a modern relatively free society. (Of course you can argue that western democracies are kleptocracies by default and all taxes just disappear to the pockets of the thieves and you get no benefit from them, but I personally do not consider that as a feasible starting point for a reasonable discussion)
- Konnstann 7y agoThat's why I put a disclaimer in parentheses. I was responding to the claim that a wealth tax would result in unchanged or higher income, which is patently false. My answer to getting some sort of "benefit" is programs like corn subsidies, which are not democratic, and are one cause of the obesity epidemic in the US, because corn syrup is shoved into anything and everything, fed to animals, etc. Again, not arguing against the wealth tax, just the assumptions behind taxation that are being made.