4 ms·
All personal opinions: It comes down to alignment of incentives. Google (for the sake of argument) has got into so many facets of peoples' lives that it's hard
by afandian 7y ago
All personal opinions:
It comes down to alignment of incentives. Google (for the sake of argument) has got into so many facets of peoples' lives that it's hard to tell what's what. If you're percieved to have contravened one of the TOCs, or your credit card fails or something, you could have your account suspended with no recourse. And Google have shown time and again that they have zero interest in universal due process, fairness or customer service. That's fine - it's their business model and their call to make.
But it is fundamentally out of step with the provision of essential services which should be afforded to all.
And then add to that the fact that when it goes wrong it disproportionally affects those more vulnerable. It starts to look a lot like disenfranchisement of minorities. What if you suddenly have no phone or email, and that's your only way of communicating with your support network? What if Google decides to pull the plug on your phone and you don't have money to buy a new one?
On the flip side, the government has a monopoly on welfare, violence, justice, etc. That's a good thing, and it's negotiated by democracy. However, using that monoploy to coerce people into using commercial duopolies is fundamentally anti-democratic.
- hestefisk 7y agoIsn’t the TurboTax / Windows monopoly with the IRS a similar case? Defacto standard gone monopoly for digital tax returns. I agree that the government cannot lock consumers into duopolies but you still have a choice to go and get a piece of plastic. They also really don’t have a choice if the objective is digital convenience —- outside of Apple and Google, there really isn’t any competition. If there were a proper, open mobile platform with no vendor lock in, I am sure NSW would support that as well.
- novok 7y agoYou can still use other tax return software, don't have to use windows with turbo tax and on top of it, use software that generates paper returns.
- astura 7y agoYep, I've been filing my taxes digitally for seven years (used paper forms before that) and I've never used TurboTax.
- robbya 7y agoI file using Turbotax using a web browser on linux. Why do you mention Windows?