3 ms·
Current usage implies illegal things done. With due respect to Latin, the choice of vigilante is odd.
by tomrod 7y ago
Current usage implies illegal things done. With due respect to Latin, the choice of vigilante is odd.
- dmos62 7y agoVigilante, in its current mainstream use, means a vigilant person who enacts justice without authority. The justice part is not in the etymology of the word, however. Vigilante, structurally, just means someone who is vigilant. I think calling a watch-dog or an independent peer-reviewer a vigilante is not inappropriate. It's a stylistic choice. I think it's important in literary education to be able to distinguish between what a word is and what cultural baggage it has (how it's used). Of course, where a word ends and its baggage begins is debatable, but it's a good debate to have.
- tomrod 7y agoI think we are aligned on our view of the word choice
- bayesian_horse 7y agoWhat about vigilantes in comic books and derivative media? Clearly positive! (though also illegal)
- dmos62 7y agoI guess the negative images associated with the word are lynch mobs and the like.