3 ms·
> It's great that these folks didn't get thrown in jail but their approach is almost criminally ignorant. The epistemology or metaphysics informing the experim
by mistermann 7y ago
> It's great that these folks didn't get thrown in jail but their approach is almost criminally ignorant. The epistemology or metaphysics informing the experiment is so... i don't know, 18th century? Did we learn nothing from the 60's?
This seems like a reasonable criticism.
> I did it, and it didn't completely not-work for me, but from my POV, it's irresponsible.
Also fair.
> With the caveat that, for a very very small number of people (like, literally one in a million or fewer), a little experience with drug trips can be educational. But the odds are you're not one of them.
Unless I'm misunderstanding, are you saying only one in a million or fewer can experience an educational effect (or, any benefits/insights whatsoever) from drugs?
If so, is this based on studies of some kind?
> Simple muscular relaxation is about 90% of the profundity most folk experience with meditation.
Same question.
- carapace 7y ago> > With the caveat that, for a very very small number of people (like, literally one in a million or fewer), a little experience with drug trips can be educational. But the odds are you're not one of them. > Unless I'm misunderstanding, are you saying only one in a million or fewer can experience an educational effect (or, any benefits/insights whatsoever) from drugs? In the most general sense, no, of course not. You can learn a lot on drugs, including "don't do drugs". You can also blast your mind and ruin your life, as at least two of my friends have done. In the context of a mindfulness meditation retreat, though, yes, it's counterproductive to get high while meditating. The vast majority of people who are trying to "find themselves" or heal or figure out "the meaning of it all" or whatever, should stick to prayer and/or meditation with an experienced teacher and leave drugs alone. > If so, is this based on studies of some kind? You mean formal scientific studies? No, but then I've never looked. Science hasn't had a good track record for studying the inner world. It's hardly a secret that responsible teachers of meditation are united in decrying the use of drugs, eh? > > Simple muscular relaxation is about 90% of the profundity most folk experience with meditation. > Same question. Same answer. The vast majority of people spend the vast majority of their time in chronic tension, the patterns of which encode their problems and neuroses. Typically this is accompanied by numbness or localized physical amnesia. People literally are unaware of their tension patterns. In this context, anything that gets a body to relax and pay attention to themself will have a dramatic psychological effect. In a very real sense, meditation can only begin after the "kinks" have been worked out (like how R. A. Wilson recommended a full course of psychotherapy was before attempting the "work" of the O.T.O.) which is why it traditionally takes so long.
- mistermann 7y ago> In the context of a mindfulness meditation retreat, though, yes, it's counterproductive to get high while meditating. Counterproductive to what, and in what way? > The vast majority of people who are trying to "find themselves" or heal or figure out "the meaning of it all" or whatever, should stick to prayer and/or meditation with an experienced teacher and leave drugs alone. Why is that? > You mean formal scientific studies? No, but then I've never looked. Science hasn't had a good track record for studying the inner world. So all of the advice you're handing out is simply your opinion? > It's hardly a secret that responsible teachers of meditation are united in decrying the use of drugs, eh? I haven't heard many opinions, but even if they are, so what? Upon what is their opinion on the matter based, their own opinions? >> Simple muscular relaxation is about 90% of the profundity most folk experience with meditation. > Is this based on studies of some kind? And you proceed to tell me more "facts". Where do you pick up all of these ideas?
- carapace 7y agoIt doesn't feel to me like you are discussing this in good faith. If you want to assert that formal peer-reviewed scientific experiments are the only valid source of truth, just say it.
- mistermann 7y agoYou are making several claims, I'm curious to know whether they are true, but you will not provide the source of your information. Truth is not only derived from peer reviewed sources. What source are you using?
- carapace 7y agoWhile a comprehensive rundown of the sources of my information would include a massive bibliography, I'll admit my main source of information is just my personal experience and observation of the world around me.