4 ms·
Ripping off someone else's project and doing a 'find and replace' of the name is IMO morally fine. If they can do a better job of marketing with that new name,
by londons_explore 7y ago
Ripping off someone else's project and doing a 'find and replace' of the name is IMO morally fine.
If they can do a better job of marketing with that new name, they deserve the success.
- guptaneil 7y agoLet's say 2 companies raise $10 million each. One company spends $8 million on R&D and $2 million on marketing. The other company re-uses the former company's open source work and pours all $10 million into marketing. Who will win? Who should win?
- jwkane 7y ago^^ this is exactly the right way to approach this. The answer is not obvious, not to me anyway. The $10 million marketing company will crush the original company, the product will wither without technical backing and fade into obsolescence. Long term everyone loses. How can we change the rules of the game (license?) so the end users win. It would please my personal sense of justice if the big R&D company also won, but I am satisfied with the simpler requirement of end users not getting shafted and the product thriving.
- capableweb 7y agoWhat does "win" mean here? Survives 5 years without being bankrupt/bought? Has a high valuation? Survives 20 years? It's no guarantee that a company with 10/2 of marketing/R&D split would be any better than the other company with 2/10 of marketing/R&D.
- MFLoon 7y agoIs it morally fine in every case? Or just in cases where the project was initially open source? If the latter, why, and why should anyone try to maintain an open source business if that's the case? Anyway, "morals" aren't the standard by which these things are judged in practice, ethics via laws are, and I'm fairly certain most legal systems don't see the practice of IP theft as fine.
- Strom 7y agoOne might say it's morally fine because it was explicitly allowed by the license. There are a lot of different reasons [1] why someone might want to maintain an open source business and the threat of someone forking your business might not outweigh other positive effects. -- [1] Transparency for privacy/security reasons, political leaning towards free software, hope of third parties tracking down bugs, PR boost within the open source community, etc.