4 ms·
Again: fingerprints are absolutely unsuitable as 'passwords'. They are at most, usernames. Because they cant be changed regularly, are left around for people to
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Again: fingerprints are absolutely unsuitable as 'passwords'. They are at most, usernames. Because they cant be changed regularly, are left around for people to find (on the yubikey device itself!), are readily connected to you as a person, have terrible entropy (a few bits).
- theptip 7y agoThis product does not make your fingerprint into a password. The fingerprint is a third factor. Your password is the first. The physical key is the second. And the fingerprint is the third. If your fingerprint is compromised, this system reverts to the security of a 2FA system with a normal physical token (i.e. very strong).
- tialaramex 7y agoYour understand that in this flow the password isn't used right? You plug the key into the Windows PC, and you put your fingertip on the sensor and you're signed in. That's two factors, "Something you have" and "Something you are" not three.
- djsumdog 7y agoBut that's not how must Yubikey flows are implemented. For an AWS console, you sign in with a username and password, then tap the contact on your Yubikey. The only difference here is that the key now only works with your finger print and not any random person's.
- tialaramex 7y agoYou're correct, that's not how most flows are implemented. But it is the new flow enabled by this device. For your AWS sign in obviously it won't need a fingerprint and so it'd be kind of silly for the demo to be "this more expensive product works like the older cheaper product you already have" they wanted to show off the new feature which is the "resident credential" user verification mode.
- nobodyshere 7y agoFingerprints aren’t passwords here.
- eeZah7Ux 7y agoThe problem is still there.
- nobodyshere 7y agoThe problem of your misunderstanding in this case. That can be fixed though.
- eeZah7Ux 7y agofacepalm
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI believe the 'convenience' mentions was, no longer needing the password. Else this would be more inconvenient, not less? And the fingerprint is absolutely not a good password replacement.
- WatchDog 7y agoIt's just another layer on top of an already well built crypto system. It can prevent someone that gains physical access to your yubikey from easily using the device. It might not stop a very advanced attacker, but it at least makes things more difficult.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoDidn't the password do that already? The one that can be changed?
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoNo. Passwords can be phished. Even password+OTP has proven to be weak. This cannot be phished, and it’s far more user-friendly. The fingerprint is not a password replacement. The yubikey is a password replacement. The fingerprint prevents a random person from using your yubikey before you notice that it’s gone and you revoke it.
- hirsin 7y agoPasswords can be used from anywhere. Keys cannot. That is the attack this blocks.