3 ms·
Your alphabet / google analogy has zero connection to what we are talking. There doesn’t need to be anyone with the cash available to pay the entire price of A
by zepto 7y ago
Your alphabet / google analogy has zero connection to what we are talking.
There doesn’t need to be anyone with the cash available to pay the entire price of Amazon.
If Jeff Bezos wants to purchase something, he can trade Amazon stock for it.
The corporation doesn’t have any control over whether he does that or not.
It is exactly equivalent to money.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> It is exactly equivalent to money. By this logic Google has an infinite amount of money because it has the ability to issue new shares. It can create a zillion dollars of new shares and sell them in the market and now it has a zillion dollars higher market cap because it has an extra zillion dollars in cash. But it's not actually infinite, for two reasons. First, the money (or whatever you're exchanging the shares for) still has to come from somewhere. There isn't unlimited demand. It's not possible for every billionaire to sell their shares at once because then there would be nobody to sell them to. If they all tried to at once, the share prices would crash into the floor. More importantly, if Bezos sells some shares in Amazon, it doesn't cause Amazon to have less capital. The company is still the same size. All you've changed is who owns it -- and unless the price he sells it for is dramatically lower than its current market value, it has to be some other rich people because nobody else has the money to buy it from him. The only way for a rich person to reduce their holdings in a corporation in order to spend the money is for some other rich person to reduce their spending by the same amount and use the money to buy the shares in their place -- and then the corporation is in control of that person's wealth, in the same amount as the original shareholder's. The things that cause corporate officers to control less wealth are things like corporate spinoffs, taking existing public companies private (which then puts actual control into the hands of the owner), competitors eroding the incumbent's market share, corporate bankruptcies, etc. Two rich guys trading shares for real estate doesn't do that. At the end the corporation still has the same amount of wealth and the two rich guys have the same amount of wealth, you've just changed which one has their wealth in stock vs. land.
- zepto 7y agoThe statement you made about google issuing more shares has nothing to do with my logic and is completely irrelevant. You are right that Bezos selling shares does not change the amount of capital Amazon has. The fact that nobody has enough money to buy all of Amazon from Bezos is also completely irrelevant. You are right that Bezos exchanging stock for real estate doesn’t reduce his wealth unless the real estate is overpriced. When you buy something with money, the same thing happens - the amount of wealth held by both parties doesn’t change unless the goods are overpriced or are consumed. You haven’t refuted anything I said in the previous comment. Bezos can use Amazon stock to buy whatever he wants, the same way you and I can use money, and the corporation has no control over this. Bezos’s wealth is exactly what it looks like. He can indeed use it just like money.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> The statement you made about google issuing more shares has nothing to do with my logic and is completely irrelevant. Your logic is that shares are money, but companies can print shares, which would imply that they could print money. The shares are only valuable because they represent the company. The value in the shares isn't independent or duplicative of the value of the company. If the company burned to the ground then the shares would be worthless too -- it's the same wealth, and as long as the resources are invested in the corporation, it's the corporation that has control over it. You're trying to make a lot out of the fact that the owners could sell their shares, but there are two reasons that doesn't do it. The first is, that doesn't come into play unless they actually do sell their shares. But if they did that in practice and spent the money (not just move it to another investment security) then we wouldn't be having this debate because then they would no longer be billionaires. And the second is that they can't actually do that at scale, because in order for that to happen, you would need somebody else to buy the shares from them, which would mean that that person would have to commit an equivalent amount of resources which then couldn't be used for some other purpose. As long as Amazon exists, it necessary that somebody be foregoing their own use of an Amazon-sized quantity of wealth. > When you buy something with money, the same thing happens - the amount of wealth held by both parties doesn’t change unless the goods are overpriced or are consumed. The most relevant part of that being consumed, because that's what the disposition of resources is really about. Trading one investment for another is still investment -- and investment in corporations is giving control of your resources to someone else. Actual spending is consumption. You burn fuel or use electricity. You pay a person to do a job and their time is consumed and can't be used for something else. You occupy some land that then nobody else can use at the same time. Those are the things that actually matter to people and affect the world, not whether Jeff Bezos owns shares of Amazon and Larry Page owns shares of Google or vice versa. What I'm getting at here is that if you want to reallocate resources from adtech to something else, it is actually necessary to deallocate it from adtech, not just sell your shares in the adtech company to somebody else so that the same total amount of resources are allocated to adtech but now it's somebody else's name on the documents. If the same amount of labor continues to be spent on targeting ads, that labor is not being spent on curing cancer, regardless of whether ownership of the shares changes hands.