5 ms·
Besides the "X for Y" approach, I find it laughable that every time someone says they are doing just "X" that the usual Bay Area response is "How are you differ
by dheera 7y ago
Besides the "X for Y" approach, I find it laughable that every time someone says they are doing just "X" that the usual Bay Area response is "How are you differentiating from your competitors?"
Go ask how UPS differentiates themselves from FedEx. Or how Shell differentiates themselves from Chevron. In reality, while product differentiation is good, unless there already exists a monopoly that has eaten every inch of the market, the market is probably big enough to fit multiple nearly identical products at the same time and still have them all profitable.
- a13n 7y ago> the market is probably big enough to fit multiple nearly identical products at the same time and still have them all profitable. Agreed, but VCs don't need you to build a profitable company, they need you to build a billion dollar company, in order to return their fund. This "How are you going to win your market?" is driven by venture capitalism. Most startups in the Bay Area are VC-backed.
- dheera 7y agoChevron, Shell, UPS, and FedEx are all billion dollar companies. They succeeded not because of differentiating product, but because the market is so big that it's hard for a single company to dominate it.
- a13n 7y agoSo you think if you pick a big enough market, then building a billion dollar company with no product differentiation will be trivial?
- dheera 7y agoNot trivial, but very possible with a lot of hard work. Let's say you want to start a new grocery store chain and compete with Safeway. Differentiating your product (e.g. Trader Joe's) is one way, but another way is to just build new grocery stores where people want them and they don't already exist.
- a13n 7y agoAll of these companies were started between 50 and 150 years ago, when there was much less competition. These days you need a better story for how you're going to win a market and keep it.
- dheera 7y agoWhile that's true that there were fewer people starting businesses, there were also proportionally fewer consumers in the world. I'm not sure things were any easier 50-150 years ago in that respect. IMO only VCs want a bullsh!t "story". The rest of the world just wants X for $C and doesn't have access to it yet because the competitors aren't big enough. Brand loyalty, network effects, and cost of switching applies to some certain markets, but also doesn't apply to a lot of markets. Nobody reads the story behind the founding of Taco Bell or Del Taco. They just get hungry, see the sign, and eat. Billion dollar business right there.
- a13n 7y agoI think VCs want a good story because they've been burned too many times by companies that sound like they could be big, but then fail because: – not enough product differentiation – not a large enough market – not defensible enough Again, Taco Bell / Del Taco were both started 50+ years ago, and have nothing to do with starting a company in today's internet age.
- blfr 7y agoMaybe but here on the Internet there seems to be one search engine which rakes in most of the money, one social network where most people have accounts, one electronic toy maker which sits on top of a mountain on cash. Second prize is a set of steak knives.
- soperj 7y agoAnd yet here I am using Duckduckgo and twitter on firefox...
- kristopolous 7y agoIs that top search engine Baidu? Yandex? Google? Depends on who and where you ask.
- blfr 7y agoYandex has about ~1.5% revenues of Google. Baidu ~11%. It's not even a contest which rakes in the most money.
- kristopolous 7y agoIf I had a company that made even 0.1% of Google, I'd probably start each day running around the room in feats of joy and delight. Seriously, if I could pay talented people many hundreds of thousands of dollars, have a nice office, happy customers, a decent product, and only make a paltry 136 million a year, where do I sign up?!
- blfr 7y agoYou're getting away from the tread though. At 0.1% you're not FedEx to Google's UPS. And if you're running a similar service, say a speciality search engine, Google might come after you at a moment's notice.
- ci5er 7y agoI see (at the time of this post) a regional person and a techno-geek respond to your comment, trying to disqualify it as not being universal (sorry globalist techno-geeks!), even though it is, measured by global magnitude. But I am baffled by the reference to the toy maker? Who is that? Unless you mean Apple?
- lacker 7y agoI think that's a reasonable question to ask. Most startups do have some way to differentiate themselves from their competitors, and if you ask them what it is, that's often the fastest way of understanding what they value and what their company is like. I am guessing that you find this question annoying because you have to answer it a gazillion times for Robby. ;-) https://robby.io/ https://robby.io/ But to me I am pretty interested to hear your answer, of how do you differentiate from all the other delivery robots out there. And if the answer really is "well there's several that are just like us but I think we can all be winners", that's an interesting answer too.
- ronilan 7y ago> how UPS differentiates themselves from FedEx. Wikipedia will tell you that UPS started as a parcel delivery service in the early 20th century. Naturally it was ground based and evolved that way. FedEx was founded in the 70s as a technology driven startup with the idea of using planes for delivery. FedEx was UPS for Express Deliveries. X for Y.
- kristopolous 7y agoLet's try it another way, "there can be more than one sandwich shop"
- ci5er 7y agoBut not more than one bar per 10,200 residents in Salt Lake City!
- nostrademons 7y agoYou wouldn't want to invest in a sandwich shop, and the reason is precisely why investors ask about differentiation.
- dheera 7y agoKnowing Subway's market cap now, would you invest in them as an angel investor? You'd be a billionaire right now. They didn't become big by differentiating product. Their sandwiches aren't that special. They became big by coming into existence where people wanted sandwiches.
- nostrademons 7y agoSee the sibling thread about VC-funded branded chains: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21465969 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21465969 They absolutely did become big by differentiating product. There's a Jersey Mike's and an Arby's near my home, as well as a Subway about a mile away. The former two chains came into existence right around the same time (and slightly before) Subway did. They struggle for business, both nationwide and locally. It wouldn't surprise me if most readers of this comment haven't heard of them, while most everyone has heard of Subway. That's despite having a similar product (sandwiches) and similar locations to Subway. What they're missing is the brand. Subway pushed heavily on being a healthy, quick-service chain with good selection in the late 90s, right as America was waking up to the virtues of healthy food and wanting something different from burgers. (They'd actually been around since the 60s, but I never heard about them until the early 2000s.) Nobody buys a Subway for the sandwich; they buy a subway because they want something quick & easy, from a known source, and don't feel like getting a burger. There are plenty of other sandwich shops that sell sandwiches cheaper, oftentimes with better ingredients (i.e. not 49% soy protein in their chicken), but you'll never have heard of them, and most close up in a few years. Invest in them and you go broke.
- jandrese 7y agoA more direct question would be "Why should a potential customer choose you over $established_competitor_x?" If your best answer is "We are adding diversity to the marketplace", then you're probably doomed. If you aren't better in some way (faster, cheaper, better tech, etc...) then people are going to naturally gravitate towards the incumbent who has already shown some staying power and has infrastructure in place that you do not.
- throwaway_law 7y ago>If your best answer is "We are adding diversity to the marketplace", then you're probably doomed. If you aren't better in some way (faster, cheaper, better tech, etc...) We have seen it over and over in tech though...some small time founder starts something and then a VC back startup eats their lunch and takes the market (of course rewriting history along the way to say they invented/disrupted the market). The sad truth is the answer to why a customer will choose us over established competitor is because...VC capital/your money. We will use VC capital/your money to out spend/out market our competitor because they can only grow as fast as their revenue, whereas we can artificially grow using your VC money, even to the point we can subsidize the price of our widget which the established competitor can't, we will grow our market share, even if at a loss because at any time we can "flip the switch and its all profit."
- jandrese 7y agoThat's a completely valid reason. If the competition is underserving the market and you think you can outgrow them because you have an aggressive growth plan then that's something.
- benburleson 7y agoNot always true. Sometimes customers hate the vendor, but there is no viable alternative. Just remove a couple pain points and you can create a shift.
- swalsh 7y agoOften enough though, people are unfamiliar with both your brands. So they're going to choose the person with better marketing. Sometimes marketing IS the difference, and engineers hate to hear that.
- rolltiide 7y agoI just tell people that my neighborhood also has multiple grocery stores
- ghaff 7y agoBut I’m guessing you probably tend to favor one for your regular shopping because it has characteristics you like better than the others.
- SkyPuncher 7y agoThis is exactly the point. I tend to avoid Kroger brands because I do not like that most of their sale prices are dictated by having a Kroger Card. I'm not particularly price conscientious and find Kroger has a great selection and quality. I simply choose elsewhere when I can.
- xur17 7y ago> I tend to avoid Kroger brands because I do not like that most of their sale prices are dictated by having a Kroger Card. Aren't most grocery chains like this?
- ghaff 7y agoNot really. The grocery chain I shop at the most doesn't even have a loyalty card. The other has one but it's a fairly nominal discount only on house-branded items. But there are certainly chains that require a card to get routine large discounts. (Safeway for example.)
- SkyPuncher 7y agoNot in my area. Most of them only offer a discount on gas with their grocery card.
- rolltiide 7y agoyes like proximity or exposed to first.
- tootie 7y agoHow Lyft differentiates from Uber might be more on the nose.
- dheera 7y agoAs far as winning the market goes, actual product differentiation doesn't matter that much. In their particular market it almost all boils down to how much the rides cost. I usually just open both apps and pick the cheaper one.
- ghaff 7y agoAnd I’m honestly not sure what the answer is other than not carrying with it quite the same amount of negative baggage that Uber does. They were differentiated but it turns out most people don’t want to fist bump their taxi driver.
- dominostars 7y agoLyft was “Uber but in a normal persons car and much cheaper” until Uber created their cheap option
- ghaff 7y agoAll the mainstream ride sharing platforms seem to have more or less gravitated towards the same basic offering(s)--which is, perhaps not entirely surprisingly, essentially an app-enabled taxi.
- cortesoft 7y agoWhen Lyft first started, there was no set price for rides... you would pay what you wanted. It was very strange, I didn't like it.
- ghaff 7y agoI only started using Lyft when they transformed themselves into a clone of Uber. (Not that I use either all that much.) I found the whole fist-bump, pink mustache, weird pricing, etc. completely off-putting.
- fortydegrees 7y agoYou need to be able to answer that. The answer can be no, and saying why will only help demonstrate your understanding of your business and the market.
- jdauriemma 7y agoI think the differentiation factor is relevant to venture capitalists more than end users. Having an equity stake in a new business is a risky proposition. A unique market position, or perhaps an idea that is patentable, provides the prospect of risk mitigation - the idea itself may be able to be liquidated if the business fails. There's also the upside of being the only player in a given market.
- BjoernKW 7y agoDifferentiation isn't just about the product. Marketing used to be defined as: product, price, place and promotion. Many competitors compete and differentiate on just the latter three.
- neonate 7y agoYour examples are all big companies, but the question is being asked about startups. That's a category error.
- bobloblaw45 7y agoOne thing I've learned dealing with other businesses in my company is that businesses don't necessarily need to be good. Selling to the public I'm sure you need to good but it seems to matter far less when you sell to other businesses. Just be able to hit their price point. Their employees could complain for years about it before moving on
- redkoala 7y agoIt depends on your vertical. Some online centric verticals are winner takes all and rely on a marketplace critical mass, while others have a local presence element and can support near identical competitors. You can’t have too many Uber or Lyft platforms per city (critical mass) but you definitely can have a lot of coffee shops.