5 ms·
Many? Anything running a browser needs it because of js. Anything running connected to the internet at all would be well advised to have them because you can
by gpm 7y ago
Many?
Anything running a browser needs it because of js.
Anything running connected to the internet at all would be well advised to have them because you can take advantage of the exploits via the network stack.
Anything running on a vm has to have them since microcode is set by the hypervisor.
So, we're talking about desktops not used to browse the internet, and bare metal servers whose network stacks aren't exposed to hostile actors?
- jolmg 7y ago> So, we're talking about desktops not used to browse the internet You can browse the internet without JS. Many people here seem to do so.
- gpm 7y agoTechnically true. The number of people who do isn't statistically interesting though. If you are I still wouldn't advise doing so while turning off the mitigations since you're still parsing and displaying hostile ip/tcp/http/(html/CSS/image/video/...). For example, http://www.misc0110.net/web/files/netspectre.pdf http://www.misc0110.net/web/files/netspectre.pdf
- vkou 7y agoIf you're browsing the internet without JS, you don't need a CPU that was built this decade to do so.
- jolmg 7y agoYet, Meltdown is said to probably effect every processor since 25 years ago[1], so I doubt people would have one from before then by chance or be willing to use it. [1] https://meltdownattack.com/#faq-systems-meltdown https://meltdownattack.com/#faq-systems-meltdown
- lonelappde 7y agoEvery Intel processor.
- enriquto 7y agoIndeed, I need my CPU for other things that browsing the web.
- dijit 7y ago>Many people here seem to do so. And many more are ardent that "I should not build a non-js version of my website just for the >1% of users who disable javascript". Personally I do not disable javascript because it makes huge portions of the web inaccessible, in weird and frustratingly ambiguous ways. But I used to, and I am the kind of person who would again if it were a remote option.
- p1necone 7y agoI think it's also possible that the people who do are just much more prone to talking about it. Who talks about how they don't disable javascript unprompted?
- sp332 7y agoI'm not clear what your point was about the VMs. Why do hypervisors need Meltdown mitigated? I think you're underestimating the % of HPC networks with properly-configured firewalls and only running code from trusted sources.
- gpm 7y agoIf you trust all the code (and other inputs, or outputs) on all the VMs, and you are running it in a secure environment, you don't. I admit, it's possible I'm underestimating how common this is. Why you generally do need it is the above isn't true, and microcode has to be loaded at the hypervisor level for everyone or for no one
- sliken 7y agoHPC doesn't generally use VMs or Hypervisors.
- eyegor 7y ago> it's possible I'm underestimating how common this is This is quite common in the engineering/research sectors, which love clusters. Think Sandia, oak ridge, etc. I also personally know of several private companies with research clusters. I'm curious how common hpcs are outside of the research community, because honestly I'm struggling to think of a practical need for one.
- atq2119 7y agoHPC is quite common in mechanical engineering type industries. Think mechanical stress simulations, wind simulations, that kind of thing. I wouldn't call that part of the research community.
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoHPC is not the real use case (target). The percentage of HPC compared to the rest of the target market (public cloud) is insignificantly small. The real question is do you trust any potential co-tenants in a public cloud that share a hypervisor with you, when said hypervisor does NOT have Spectre/Meltdown fixes applied? (There is only one correct answer...) Also you can fairly easily mitigate this in a public cloud setting by running your VM on a dedicated hypervisor. AWS calls these "EC2 Dedicated Instances". Interestingly enough for most compute sizes the cost different is negligable. I imagine that isn't the case everywhere / for-everything, but if you A) need pre-Spectre/Meltdown perf and B) need protection against co-tenancy attacks, paying a few more dollars for a dedicated hypervisor host seems like a no-brainer to me.
- guelo 7y ago> Anything running a browser needs it because of js. All the javascript engines have implemented spectre and meltdown mitigations. EDIT: Are the downvotes because people don't believe that the JS mitigations are effective?
- kllrnohj 7y ago> So, we're talking about desktops not used to browse the internet, and bare metal servers whose network stacks aren't exposed to hostile actors? To be fair the context here is HPC. Nobody is installing Chrome on something like IBM's Summit supercomputer. Nor is it running "untrusted" code. It's configured to go as fast as possible, nothing more. Anyone in cloud hosting or desktop would be insane to not install spectre/meltdown fixes. But in this particular niche of HPC supercomputers it's actually reasonable to not have those mitigations.
- snoman 7y agoIs it though? There's a significant security bug that has a known fix, on your supercomputer. The second anything remotely security-related happens and it gets out that you've opted to hedge your bets that no untrusted code will ever execute on that machine... and you could be in some seriously hot water. I'm not really in the HPC space, but I can't really see any vp/cto/cio reasonably putting that asterisk on a security audit. If you've got cyber insurance, you probably wouldn't be able to keep coverage if you did that.
- zepearl 7y agoI agree - factors involving insurance, compliance, auditing, etc... will play a big role for any company using such systems to process any kind of even slightly confidential information. Any CIO that decides not to use such security patches will carry on his/her shoulders the full risk. Big bosses don't like risk and like even less to be personally accountable for anything => I don't see that happening. Even if the tests mentioned in the article might be related to HPC, the HW is for general computing therefore its usage doesn't have to be restricted to HPC, but people might still decide to use (as well) those HPC-results to compare the types of CPUs.
- kllrnohj 7y agoWhat do you think is the actual risk? Who is attacking whom, and how? If you're running on HPC you basically rented the hardware. It's a time-share system. The entire thing is yours, all yours, for the hours you managed to procure. So who are you attacking? And what vp/cto/cio are you even talking about? The ones who own the hardware, or the ones who are renting it? And why do you think a security policy is needed here at all instead of just, you know, laws & contracts? You can't just anonymously rent time on these systems even if you have the money - you need your usage approved, too, and it's a big whole process. If you then go and successfully launch a security attack, why does that require technical safeguards instead of just the FBI knocking down your door and hauling your ass to jail?