4 ms·
And that reason is? I have very good reason to think it will, as do the plasma physicists who work on magnetic confinement.
by willis936 7y ago
And that reason is? I have very good reason to think it will, as do the plasma physicists who work on magnetic confinement.
- pfdietz 7y agoThe volumetric power density of fusion reactors is inherently lower than fission reactors, because of the square cube law and the need for the fusion reactor to radiate it's output through the wall of the reactor. This means th e nuclear core of the fusion reactor will be both much larger and much more complex than a fission reactor.
- willis936 7y agoCertainly a fusion reactor will be a large, expensive, and complicated device. If it’s going to be directly compared to fission solely on cost to generate power then yes fission is less expensive. The allures of fusion is its lack of ability to meltdown, global abundance of fuel, and the ability to choose what elements get activated. That seems like things that add value to me, but I don’t think the conversations on funding fusion research are at that level. I’ve read the transcripts of the US House Subcommittee on Science, Space, and Technology’s discussions on fusion energy science. It’s clear that the politicians that represent fusion scientists when the budget is made don’t have a strong grasp of what the devices are, their potential impact, the realistic failure modes for these projects, etc. It’s simply a game of politics.
- pfdietz 7y agoYou are repeating the hoary old argument for fusion. That argument depended on it competing only against fission, and making grand nebulous claims that environmental and safety credits would let it pull ahead, even though it was otherwise more expendive than fission. But fission has now lost to renewables, which are now at a levelized cost 3-4x lower than fission. Fusion's putative safety/env benefits mean nothing now. The program now is existing on institutional inertia. I don't see this coming to anything but an inglorious end.
- DennisP 7y agoWind/solar aren't that cheap if you include enough storage to get through a windless night, and enough overcapacity to get through cloudy winter weeks. If you're backing them up with fossil, then sure, they're pretty darn cheap.
- pfdietz 7y agoYou back them up with short term storage and hydrogen. With plausible costs for 2030 a CO2-free grid optimizes to 0% nuclear.
- DennisP 7y agoHow about today's costs? After all, presumably you're using today's cost for nuclear. It's plausible that, for example, some molten salt reactors currently under development will be a lot cheaper than light water reactors, so it doesn't make sense to compare future renewables with nuclear today.
- pfdietz 7y agoNo molten salt reactor could be available by 2030. Simply resolving material issues would take at least that long. Proving materials will last X years takes at least X years. More importantly, the decision whether to build such a reactor will depend on decline in costs of its competition in the future, not just now, when the business case for the reactor requires it operate for 40 years or more.
- DennisP 7y agoThere are several ways to fix the materials issue, pursued by active projects. One is simply to replace the reactor core every few years; Terrestrial Energy and Thorcon are using that approach. So I'll ask again: how do the numbers look if you compare today's wind/solar/storage costs without fossil backup to today's nuclear costs? We can argue until our fingers wear out about what the costs will be in eleven years, but there are hard numbers for today.