2 ms·
It's not my fault that the entire conservative and libertarian movement decided to adopt the most idiotic possible stance and stick with it long after it was ob
by ZeroGravitas 7y ago
It's not my fault that the entire conservative and libertarian movement decided to adopt the most idiotic possible stance and stick with it long after it was obvious to everyone that it was a low quality lie.
Am I now supposed to pretend that didn't happen and naively assume that those same people are genuinely curious about the impact of mining rare earths, or wether gas backup of renewables is better economically and environmentally than burning coal, or about bird deaths from wind turbines?
No thanks, unlike the people who believe this nonsense I'm not a complete chump. Maybe you're only pretending to be ill informed about renewable energy, but either way repeating talking points you learned from climate change deniers isn't in the least bit convincing.
Yes the guy in the video sounds like he's talking to very slow children. That's how you talk to people with opinions unmoored from reality. He's right though. Tesla didn't look at whether EVs were possible and say "this doesn't exist therefore it never can" they looked at the physics of it and will be creating large amounts of electricity storage that is cheaper and more environmentally sound than what came before.
Just repeating "this isn't possible" when lots of domain experts think it will be isn't convincing. Just like denying climate change wasn't convincing, just politically convenient.
- macspoofing 7y agoYou keep focusing on climate change denialists. I am with you on that. It is irrational to dismiss the findings of a multitude of good well-meaning scientists across a wide spectrum of scientific disciplines. Having said that, climate change denialists are not the problem. In fact, they are great for proponents of solar and wind because it shifts the conversation to how dumb and evil the denialists are instead of seeing how bad wind and solar are for the environment and climate change action. Look at our conversation. You keep going back to denialists and not actually any answer any question I have on renewables. And annoyingly you keep linking me with climate-change denialists. Can you stop? Being skeptical about renewables is not the same as denying climage-change or for action to comabt climate-change. >Yes the guy in the video sounds like he's talking to very slow children. That wasn't my concern. My objection was that he skirted answering a question in the same place that everyone from the cult of renewables does. It always ends up with an argument that we just need to tap human ingenunity to invent new technology just as we did when we went to the moon. Maybe we can, maybe we can't. Going to the moon turns out to be easier than a lot of other things that feel like they should be easy. >Just repeating "this isn't possible" when lots of domain experts think it will be isn't convincing. I listed reasons why it isn't possible. You sent me a link that argued the same except the youtuber argued we just need a 'can-do-attitude'. Let me send you a link. Here's a 'Real Engineering' Youtube video on reasonable issues with (California's) renewables: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5cm7HOAqZY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5cm7HOAqZY and even that video ends in the same place ... we just need to invent new battery technologies.