4 ms·
Wow, such a propaganda tone that I am not used to seeing in HN. "9 billion a year for a voting right" is like saying that the average software developer in Lon
by mrtksn 7y ago
Wow, such a propaganda tone that I am not used to seeing in HN.
"9 billion a year for a voting right" is like saying that the average software developer in London pays 20K a year to the government for voting rights every 5 years. You obviously don't pay taxes for voting rights, you pay taxes to sustain or improve the environment you operate in and the voting is about choosing the people and the path to that.
The "divorce bill" makes it sound like it some kind of a fine or something but it's actually about the obligation that the UK committed through the years. A good analogy would be the UK participating in a birthday dinner party, promising to chip in for the present, ordering the food and the desert but leaving before the desert arrives so people expect the UK to pay for its desert as it was already cooked and pay its part for the present they bought. This is not going away no matter if the Brexit would be hard, soft, mellow or squishy. If the UK does not honour its obligations, it would be incorporated in the future trade agreements.
Please don't use propaganda catchwords and talking points here, the topic itself is divisive but this is beyond that. It is a dishonest portrayal of reality.
- aembleton 7y agoIf a net recipient country were to leave the EU would the EU continue paying them after they had left?
- mrtksn 7y agoPaying what exactly? These are not really money transfers, it's not like UK sending 100 bucks and the EU giving 80 of it to Bulgaria and sending 20 back to the UK. It doesn't work like that. The money is used for infrastructure and other stuff, maybe Bulgaria gets 80 bucks for road building but the UK benefits from it by getting the engineering contract and after the project is completed they use these roads to make moving nuts from Turkey cheaper and faster so making their chocolate industry more competitive. Maybe it was UK's proposal to build that road and France supported the idea because they also want to make the rose petals imports from Bulgaria and electric hardware exports to Turkey cheaper? It's not a charity. So yes, if a net recipient country leaves the EU chances are that they will continue receiving EU funds just like the other countries that receive EU funds despite never being the EU in the first place.
- Traster 7y agoAs a matter of fact, the EU is committed to continue to fund projects in the UK that had already budgeted. From the Institute for government. >If there is a withdrawal agreement, UK recipients will receive EU funding for projects agreed in the current funding cycle from the EU Budget. So yes, the already committed projects would continue and so the net recipient would continue to be a net recipient until the currently committed projects were completed. That is exactly why there is a divorce bill - because the UK is paying for the obligations its already committed to, and in return the EU is going to provide the services and funding that it has committed to. There is reason to think any other country would be treated differently.
- bArray 7y ago> Wow, such a propaganda tone that I am not used to seeing in > HN. I think we have a very different definition of propaganda. I suggest getting into the comments early when a keyword is used in the title. > "9 billion a year for a voting right" is like saying that > the average software developer in London pays 20K a year > to the government for voting rights every 5 years. It's clearly a tongue in cheek exaggeration. > The "divorce bill" makes it sound like it some kind of a > fine or something but it's actually about the obligation > that the UK committed through the years. I used "divorce settlement" - and it is very much like a divorce settlement. Both parties are expected to settle remaining costs and you end up losing the kids. > A good analogy would be the UK participating in a birthday > dinner party, promising to chip in for the present, > ordering the food and the desert but leaving before the > desert arrives so people expect the UK to pay for its > desert as it was already cooked and pay its part for the > present they bought. Maybe, but then you would expect to be able to chose what to do with the desert if you've paid for it? > If the UK does not honour its obligations, it would be > incorporated in the future trade agreements. Unfortunately, yes. > Please don't use propaganda catchwords and talking points > here, the topic itself is divisive but this is beyond > that. It is a dishonest portrayal of reality. I purposely put the word "divorce" in speech marks as it's what it is commonly referred to, rightly or wrongly. I wasn't aiming to paint a picture perfect version of reality, I would need several books to describe Brexit accurately (and no doubt somebody will write them). The purpose is simply to show that £3.3 billion is really not that much compared to our ongoing projects. Hell, another one to look at is the Trident project.
- mrtksn 7y agoSure, UK will have it's desert that paid for and can decide what to do with it. These things are settled in the withdrawal agreement. After all, it's not a fine.