5 ms·
From my perspective, watching the markets since 2013, the 2017 boom was caused by Ethereum. Before Bitcoin shot up, Ethereum had shot up from $8 in December 20
by chrisco255 7y ago
From my perspective, watching the markets since 2013, the 2017 boom was caused by Ethereum. Before Bitcoin shot up, Ethereum had shot up from $8 in December 2016 to nearly $50 a couple months later.
Now, Ethereum is a novel innovation on blockchain tech. The smart contract hype was very real at the time. (For the record, I still think smart contracts have tremendous potential) ETH had navigated a fork, secured corporate alliances, setup several foundations to promote work and was starting to generate a lot excitement around projects like Augur, Ox, etc. Then on top of that, the ICO boom happened when several projects raised tens of millions of dollars. That caused a run on ETH.
ETH boomed and then BTC followed, at least for the 2017 boom. And then the speculators danced between altcoins, Tether, Bitcoin and ETH, trying to maximize their returns while paying little attention to fundamental adoption.
I think we've seen certain technologies take over markets very quickly in the past couple decades, like desktops and wifi and mobile and then smart phones and social media...that we've gotten used to rapid disruption in tech. However, with financial tech like blockchain and crypto, it necessitates slow adoption. Why is this? Because it's real money on the line. It's cool to move fast and break things when it's an app or a fitness tracker, but when it's significant amounts of money on the line, maturity, trust, and security are tantamount.
I still think blockchain will win in the long run against legacy tech. But it will be a slow disruption.
- grubles 7y agoBitcoin has smart contracts, and has for many years now. Ethereum's marketing for the phrase is kind of misleading. Why the downvoting? Apparently a number of people haven't heard of Bitcoin Script, or are upset I pointed out this very factual item about Bitcoin? Seems somewhat odd.
- bitcoinbutter 7y agoEthereum's smart contracts are obviously more developer friendly and easier to implement. Ethereum smart contracts are the go-to for dapps, despite having a significantly smaller userbase and market cap than bitcoin. To say Bitcoin smart contracts are equal to Ethereum smart contracts would be akin to comparing Myspace to Facebook.
- sterlind 7y agoBitcoin originated smart contracts, but they were severely limited due to a filter that was imposed. Arbitrary scrypt execution was seen as a security risk (despite not being Turing-complete), so a set of scrypt templates were whitelisted. I think all clients would accept blocks with any scrypt in them, but most pools would only accept transactions with the fixed templates. Bitcoin does have enough flexibility to do trustless cross-chain trading though, so it's possible to do dapp logic in Eth and manipulate BTC funds indirectly. (IIRC)
- jimmaswell 7y agoAnd MySpace was better all around in objective terms, but facebook was dumbed down for mass appeal so it won out?
- wnevets 7y ago>was dumbed down for mass appeal so it won out? thats usually how it works
- jimmaswell 7y agoYes, I just don't think the analogy worked very well.
- ethbro 7y agoThis is a false narrative. Facebook better optimized for the fact that most people are too stupid to avoid using full-page background images and auto-playing music.
- jimmaswell 7y agoI thought it was a lot cooler back then. People got their own customized little places about themselves, maybe with some fun media playing. Now it's all boring and sterilized.
- 7y ago
- AlexCoventry 7y agoDiscreet-log contracts are a miracle, but in the same way that a dancing bear is a miracle. There's no way they can compete with smart contracts on a platform designed with smart contracts in mind, at least on a technical level. (Maybe we'll all end up using discrete-log contracts and their descendants due to network effects, but I doubt it. Or maybe some richer zero-knowledge contract-enforcement scheme can be devised on bitcoin... Maybe.)
- grubles 7y agoEthereum as a platform has made many bad design decisions. It's not really suitable for a lot of things; including, well, things it was marketed for (unstoppable, uncensorable, scalable applications).
- AlexCoventry 7y agoI'm sure something better for those design goals than Ethereum will come along, but I seriously doubt it's going to be Bitcoin.
- robcohen 7y agoCardano, although still not ready for primetime, seems like a likely candidate. EDIT : I do work for IOHK and I am biased.
- grubles 7y agoSurely you haven't heard of Simplicity then. A potential replacement for Bitcoin's current scripting language. https://blockstream.com/2018/11/28/en-simplicity-github/ https://blockstream.com/2018/11/28/en-simplicity-github/
- keymone 7y agoBitcoin was literally designed with contracts (programs deciding transactions) in mind from its inception. Ethereum is just script kiddies piling JavaScript onto blockchain and calling it the greatest invention in human history.
- zelly 7y agoEthereum was responsible for the 2017 bubble, but not because it is useful or smart contracts are useful or blockchain is useful. It was ICOs/scams running on Ethereum. Everyone saw their friends getting rich from Bitcoin and wanted in on one of the supposedly Next Bitcoins. Blockchain is just a database, a slow and expensive one at that. “Legacy” tech (like a RDBMS) is much more efficient, reliable, and cutting-edge than blockchain. The only benefit of a blockchain is censorship-resistance—not needing to rely on government or centralized third-parties because a swarm maintains consensus (the longest Merkle tree). Financial markets operate in broad daylight with real identities enforced by judges and men with guns. There is absolutely no use case for censorship-resistance in that space. It is a lose/lose. How is it even supposed to work? Bankers pay miners to secure a log of their transactions? Ok, say someone robs a bank. A banker calls in to report the loss; a block gets mined showing that money is lost. Why did you need a blockchain? Why not just trust the banker to update a RDBMS cluster since you're trusting the banker's word anyway? Blockchain only works for purely digital things...like Bitcoin. Smart contracts also do not need censorship resistance. People get along fine with the current legal system at least for civil lawsuits. You need a blockchain iff: - The data you are representing are other data in the same tree, not entities outside the data structure (much less entities irl). - You need censorship-resistance because you're Silk Road or Wikileaks or trying to overthrow your government. - The data is publicly/www world accessible by parties who do not trust each other. TL;DR A blockchain is a domain-specific data structure internal to the Bitcoin project circa 2009.
- 0beah 7y agoI created an account just to respond to you. You're too focused on the trees, you can't see the forest. https://thedefiant.substack.com/p/ether-is-the-best-model-for-money https://thedefiant.substack.com/p/ether-is-the-best-model-fo...
- lightedman 7y agoBlockchain is raw garbage. The bitcoin network ALONE undid every single bit of good we achieved in terrestrial-used solar energy over 40 years, literally every gain from that wiped straight out in less than two years. Ethereum was #2 as far as energy usage goes. We had this back in the 70s, FWIW. It failed as a miserable hunk of garbage then, it's failing as a miserable hunk of garbage now by all metrics except how efficiently it parts fools from their money.