4 ms·
‘Jaywalkers’ is such an offensive concept. ‘People trying to cross a road.’ Someone told me you can actually be ticketed for crossing a road in the US? In the U
by chrisseaton 7y ago
‘Jaywalkers’ is such an offensive concept. ‘People trying to cross a road.’ Someone told me you can actually be ticketed for crossing a road in the US? In the UK it is always the fault of the car driver if they hit a pedestrian as pedestrians are more vulnerable (code rule 204, but doesn’t apply to motorways.)
- bobly_today 7y agoI’ve lived in towns where it was legal unless otherwise considered dangerous
- Sendotsh 7y agoIllegal in Australia too, and they absolutely will fine for you for it. Not only that, but they do "safety blitzes" where they stick cops near major pedestrian areas and just hand out tickets all day to people who cross on the pedestrian red, or cross more than 'x' metres from the crossing, whether there's cars coming or not. Meanwhile red lights seem to be option for cars, and i've (very regularly) seen cars blow through proper red lights (not late-orange) right in front of cops who do absolutely nothing about it. Wife and kid had to quite literally dodge a car while they were crossing on their pedestrian green, right next to a cop, and when she got his attention he just shrugged and ignore her.
- ralusek 7y agoThat seems like a stupid way of determining guilt.
- chrisseaton 7y agoNot guilt - but the presumption is that drivers should be able to stop, rather than that the person should not be trying to cross the road. People can cross roads wherever they please in the UK, except motorways. They should ensure it is safe, but they can cross. The car is the guest in the pedestrian’s space.
- baroffoos 7y agoIs it? The driver was the one who decided to make the situation dangerous. A walker on their own would find it impossible to harm someone by walking. If you are driving in a place where people are walking (Anywhere not a highway) you must be driving at a speed where you could stop very quickly (30-40km/h). If you were driving at 30km/h it would be almost impossible to seriously hurt someone even if they stepped out in front of you.
- emj 7y agoOf those that are driven over by a car speeding at 30km/h 10% die, at 50km/h 80% die. (Source: drivers education Sweden). Reducing your speed just a little helps a lot.
- baroffoos 7y agoAlso the fact that at 30km moving speed you will come to a total stop if you braked before impact
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chrishynes 7y agoIn this case, however, it was a posted 56 km/h - 72 km/h zone on a 4 lane road. At that speed you can't react to a person that steps out in front of you. Particularly at night. Regardless of speed, a pedestrian who "stepped out in front" of a car is pretty clearly the one with a better view and much more manuverable -- that's the action that made the situation dangerous. Not a car driving within the posted speed.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> At that speed you can't react to a person that steps out in front of you. So why are you going that fast where there are pedestrians?
- 7y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoThanks for your comment. I didn't know that jaywalking doesn't exist as an offense in the UK. Goes to show how commercial interests can get something ingrained in society to the point where you actually think of it as "the natural state of being". Apparently jaywalking as a negative term was promoted by auto interests in the US in the early 20th century, according to Wikipedia.
- SilasX 7y agoI suspect that’s overstating it. If you cross against a red while traffic is coming, I doubt they just throw up their hands and wait.
- chrisseaton 7y agoThe big difference is the ‘default state.’ The default state in the UK is that as a pedestrian you are completely entitled to stride out confidently into any road to cross. The default state in the US is that you shouldn’t be there. Both parties should apply common sense, but by default you are entitled to cross the road.
- SilasX 7y agoThat’s overstating it too. In the US they don’t just spring on everyone who crosses the street without a crosswalk/green.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoNo, they don't ticket everyone who jaywalks, but they certainly can. The arbitrary nature of enforcement (there is plenty of evidence for racial disparities in jaywalking enforcement in some locales, easily Googleable) is in my mind a great argument for getting rid of jaywalking laws - they can still keep traffic obstruction laws.
- cgriswald 7y agoI’d be very surprised if the “default state” is that pedestrians can be wherever they want. Can you cite the UK law that shows this? (I once came upon two guys duking it out in the street. I can’t believe their only crime would be fighting in the UK.) In California (other states vary to varying degrees) there is a crosswalk at every intersection whether marked or not (as well as some marked crosswalks in other places). These are the only places a pedestrian may legally cross a road. Here cars must yield “right-of-way” to pedestrians, but pedestrians also have a “duty of care” for their own safety and others. Cars must yield but pedestrians can’t just step right out and damn the physics. On the road, pedestrians are confined to walking against traffic on the left side of the road if there is no sidewalk. Otherwise they should not be on the road. But, if they are on the road, drivers have a duty of care for their safety. Pedestrians can’t be there but if they are cars can’t just mow them down. In practice, pedestrians generally don’t get tagged for jaywalking. (Walking in my neighborhood without jaywalking would be a death sentence because of blind corners. You have to cross the road often to be seen.) Where the law mostly comes into play is when pedestrians are struck by vehicles. A jaywalking pedestrian will likely be found legally responsible for the accident unless the driver was speeding or otherwise acted irresponsibly, in which case a percentage of responsibility will be assigned to each.
- jacobolus 7y agoMy friend had to go to “pedestrian school” after being ticketed for jaywalking.
- pmiller2 7y agoThat’s amusing. Insane, but amusing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cactus2093 7y agoThose things aren't necessarily mutually exclusive. Yes in the US you can be ticketed for jaywalking, but at least in my experience it's more used on busy highways, where you are also endangering drivers who may have to swerve to avoid you. At least within cities I haven't seen it used when crossing a small street when no cars are coming, but it may be different in different places. Not sure about drivers being at fault, but fault in an accident is a weird concept anyway. For the most part, if you get hit by a car the driver isn't going to suffer serious consequences (they probably won't be convicted of manslaughter, for instance). But, this whole car centered system we have is pretty screwed up there's no denying that. Something like 50,000 people die in car accidents every year in the US and it's just business as usual.
- BurningFrog 7y agoJaywalking is one of many things cop can arrest people for if they want to harass them.
- iscrewyou 7y agoAlso prominent in college towns. You can increase your chances of getting a ticket if you jaywalk while close “enough” to an actually crosswalk.
- halbritt 7y agohttps://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history https://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history
- gok 7y agoThe incident was on a divided 6 lane roadway with high speed limits.
- chrisseaton 7y agoPerhaps they shouldn’t have built that kind of thing where someone would need to cross?
- gok 7y agoHow do you define where someone "needs" to cross?
- chrisseaton 7y agoAnywhere where people live and work.
- cgriswald 7y agoPerhaps they only need to cross to get to the store that only exists there because they built the six lane roadway.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- matz1 7y ago>Someone told me you can actually be ticketed for crossing a road in the US? Of course, not simply crossing but specifically crossing at inappropriate place. I think the UK should also ticket the jaywalkers.
- chrisseaton 7y agoThe idea is that by default everywhere is appropriate, because pedestrians are more vulnerable than cars.
- matz1 7y agoThen they should cross only in the designated place.
- chrisseaton 7y agoBut why? Why should the cars get the priority? Why do they get miles of designated place and the pedestrians only get 2m of it every now and again?
- 7y ago