4 ms·
One question I have - which model is the best for stewardship of a resource?
by m463 7y ago
One question I have - which model is the best for stewardship of a resource?
- roenxi 7y agoRelated question; under what circumstances does it make sense to ignore NPV when calculating value. Net Present Value generally recommends against what most people would call good stewardship of a finite resource. It seems likely that the mental model behind NPV doesn't work out over long timeframes.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> which model is the best for stewardship of a resource? What do "stewardship" and "resource" mean? Who agree on one of those definitions? Who form a natural conflicts with them? Considering stewardship of natural ecosystems. Does that mean holding it in stasis? Keeping out human effects? How do you know if a snail went extinct because of natural or human factors? Which model influences that decision? The chief advantage--and defining feature--of economic ownership models is they convert almost every question into currency. That seems base at first. But it enables competing sets of goals to be discussed within a common language. If we won't assign natural resources a dollar value, and a set of owners incentivized to defending that value, or protect them absolutely under the law, those resources will be lost. (If there is a silver lining to California's NIMBYs, it is this. That energy results from an ownership system and defense mechanism. Tweak the variables and that energy could fight for our wetlands.)
- wpietri 7y agoI am a big fan of markets and economic incentives, but they're pretty limited tools for a lot of important things. For example, if you apply them to voting or having children, you get results that are obviously absurd. Not everything should be commoditized.
- m463 7y agoSorry, in relation to PG&E I meant stewardship of the power infrastructure on behalf of the public. Obviously capitalism is efficient, but when it comes to a regulated monopoly like PG&E, I see it like a cost plus government contract.