4 ms·
Except that Soros did not hurt UK economy. Just bruised some egos at the Bank of England by showing their stupid mistakes.
by nabla9 7y ago
Except that Soros did not hurt UK economy. Just bruised some egos at the Bank of England by showing their stupid mistakes.
- hogFeast 7y agoThe only reason he could put on the trade in the size that he did was because the BoE took the other side (they sold $27bn worth of £ and Soros had a $10bn position) and believed they were omnipotent (even amongst British civil servants, the BoE was unusually stacked with "god complex" types...and still is to a certain extent). Documentary on this - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_oET45GzMI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_oET45GzMI
- scottlamb 7y agoHuh? He gained billions of dollars (pounds, Deutschmarks, whatever), the UK government lost billions. That clearly hurt their economy. Letting the currency float was better in the long term, and his actions made that happen, but I'd like to think there were other ways. And I doubt helping the UK was his goal; I can think of billions of other more likely reasons. Many people would say he stole this money from the government. It was legal, clever, and successful. He did some good things with some of the money afterward. Still, I'm not going to like him for it. (That sums up my feelings on much of the finance industry, in fact.)
- sukilot 7y agoThe UK government did not by inventing a phony exchange rate.
- PeterisP 7y agoThe point is that the money lost by UK government was lost because they stupidly gambled away that money by betting against reality - they asserted that the rate of pound "should" be at an unrealistic, unsustainable position, and they bet a lot of money on that. It turned out that they were wrong - making these large bets did prolong that fiction for a while longer, but it was unsustainable. Thus everyone in the market who was right about the "proper" position of GBP (Soros was just one of them, the largest but not the majority) won a bunch of money, and everyone who was wrong but still chose to bet more and more billions instead of accepting the reality - namely, UK government - lost billions. They could have chosen not to attempt to artificially prop up the exchange rate with these major transactions, and float the currency earlier, when it had to be floated. Heck, floating the currency a single day earlier wouldn't have any meaningful drawbacks but would have avoided much of the losses. It's not that the money was taken from the government, but rather the government wasted a huge amount of taxpayer's money betting on the false assumption (wishful thinking for domestic political reasons) that the pound doesn't have to be floated. Such bluffs are punished by the market, with the people calling the bluff getting the money (and people falsely calling a bluff losing their money if they turn out to be wrong).
- scottlamb 7y agoNothing you said is wrong, per se, but... > Such bluffs are punished by the market, with the people calling the bluff getting the money (and people falsely calling a bluff losing their money if they turn out to be wrong). I think this kind of wording (the market does this, not the individual actors) can be misleading. Look at this quote from the article: > "Our total position by Black Wednesday had to be worth almost $10 billion. We planned to sell more than that. In fact, when Norman Lamont [the British finance minister] said just before the devaluation that he would borrow nearly $15 billion to defend sterling, we were amused because that was about how much we wanted to sell." They weren't just placing bets on events outside their control. They deliberately created the situation where the UK couldn't borrow sufficient money to maintain the rate. The fall was arguably inevitable, but they caused it to happen at a time of their choosing, in a way that enriched themselves at the UK's enormous expense. Sure, the BoE folks should have yielded sooner, but they didn't, and the people paid for it while Soros profited. This isn't something I would be proud of.
- m-i-l 7y ago"Soros did not hurt UK economy. Just bruised some egos at the Bank of England by showing their stupid mistakes." From the article: "At 11AM, the British government announced they would increase interest rates 200 basis points, from 10% to 12%. ... [later that day] an interest rate increase of another 300 basis points, from 12% to 15%." That means millions of ordinary people suddenly, not even overnight but on the same day, found themselves paying 5% more on large loans such as mortgages. To make completely clear, that had a very significant negative impact on a very large number of ordinary people. Also from the article: "The cost to British taxpayers was estimated at roughly £3.3 billion." That's an average of over £128 per tax payer (3,300,000,000 / 25,700,000 tax payers in 1991-92 according to [0]). Again, to clarify, tax payers are not some "egos at the Bank of England", but ordinary people like me and you. Or to summarise in simpler terms, a small number of the very rich got significantly richer by making a large number of ordinary people significantly poorer. EDIT: Corrected figures. Thanks @philipkglass for spotting. [0] https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/812855/Table_2.1.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
- philipkglass 7y ago"The cost to British taxpayers was estimated at roughly £3.3 billion." That's an average of over £100,000 per tax payer. Again, to clarify, tax payers are not some "egos at the Bank of England", but ordinary people like me and you. There were only 33,000 tax payers in the UK in 1992? I don't know how many tax payers there were, but dividing by the population at the time comes out to £58 per person.
- m-i-l 7y agoGood spot. I must have been either using the British definition of billion (million million) rather than the US definition (thousand million), or failed to spot that the 25,700 taxpayers in the referenced document actually represented 25,700,000. Anyway figure corrected. Thanks.
- scaphandre 7y ago