4 ms·
This article is just catnip for hacker news. There are good reasons why 'big tech' exists, as Schumpeter explained many decades ago (or Tyler Cowen recently in
by Barrin92 7y ago
This article is just catnip for hacker news. There are good reasons why 'big tech' exists, as Schumpeter explained many decades ago (or Tyler Cowen recently in his book on big business), large companies are productive, innovative and essentially more dynamic due to capital they accumulate than some bazaar economy that writers like Doctorow imagine. Small is not beautiful.
Large scale complex problems can only be solved by institutions that are sufficiently complex and large to deal with them. Monopolistic competition produces better outcomes than a sort of hyper-competitive market of small players who are constantly squeezed to produce short-term results.
Competition and lack of regulation do not necessarily result in more safety or higher standards as a look at the 'crypto-economy' proves, and consumers will probably not benefit from having big tech broken up, and it would hurt regions like the EU or the US internationally to stifle their own businesses.
The problem with big tech isn't the size, it's that many company's goals are not aligned with the interests of society at large or the state. The thing to do is to regulate them, provide incentives and rules to fix their problems even if it comes at the cost of competition.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe best results don't come from stagnant monopolies or ruinous price competition. They come from winners winning big but only as long as they continue to do good. A major component of that is antitrust. AT&T gave us Bell Labs, but it's good they don't still own the internet. Microsoft commoditized PC hardware, but it's good that still don't own the internet. Apple and Google gave us modern smartphones, but they shouldn't be allowed to own the internet either. But that's what you get from antitrust enforcement, not from FDA-style "entrench the incumbents forever" rules. The laws need to promote competition so that when, as is the rule with large bureaucracies, the incumbents stagnate, someone new can give them a kick in the butt and pick up the ball when it's necessary.
- ozymandias12 7y agoWhat folks like Cowen advocate imho is that there are huge benefits. That's it. But are you prepared to have just one online vendor for everything (Amazon), or have just two major phone OSs (Android iOS) forever, or just one search engine? Just one streaming service grouping netflix, disney et al (that will eventually arise and be the cable 2.0) The fashion industry is fragmented, hugely fragmented, and I don't see people claiming everyone should wear just Adidas or Nike. What big corps are creating is just this plutocrat monopsony where about 100-200 families control the planet finances. So here's where I and my love for the big corp tend to go sour. But when you say: >many company's goals are not aligned with the interests of society at large or the state. The thing to do is to regulate them, provide incentives and rules to fix their problems even if it comes at the cost of competition You go back to where we are now. The solution for the big corps isn't to regulate them, is to regulate their commodities. People need to be able to create. That's what we do as humans. Big corps are blocking us here. Big automation is coming, so what then? Wanna keep Nestle accountable for bottling our water? Regulate access to it. Wanna curb Facebook data monopoly? Make them erase all their data and start over, now any company can make a new Facebook. Wanna curb big pharma? Stop acting like fools with the patent trolling. We have all means in the world to promote healthy economics, everyone is just too busy getting richer while enabling big corps to promote their entry deterrence as business as usual. No.