5 ms·
I don't understand why anyone wants these listening devices in their home
by exabrial 7y ago
I don't understand why anyone wants these listening devices in their home
- travbrack 7y agoThere's already one in your pocket
- temp2206 7y agoAlso I believe it will move towards a voice free AI determined system. Because at some point in future decision making will be the toughest activity. (Currently moving and switching on buttons is)
- bduerst 7y agoYep, predictive decision making is the next steps. An example of this is on the newer versions of Android, where when you pull up the app tray, it predicts and shows which apps it thinks you're most likely to want to use based on datetime, location, connected peripherals, accelerometer (driving), etc. For the connected home it could be the same.
- sp332 7y agoThe ads make them look cool. Amazon puts them at the top of the site so it looks like they're popular and everyone wants one. The industrial design makes them super unobtrusive, and the cheerful voice comes off as ultra benign.
- lostgame 7y agoOkay, but they’re still the largest global privacy violation technology in history...you couldn’t pay me to have one of these in my home, and I mean; a lot - you could offer me cash every month to keep this in my house and I would still say no. These devices are as literally Big Brother as it gets. I personally boycott Google products and do not purchase from Amazon. Google has gone from ‘don’t be evil’ to ‘be evil and pretend we’re still cool’.
- engineer_22 7y agoPlease forgive my tone, but it doesn't take a genius to recognize that you shouldn't have sensitive conversations around a microphone. Most of the things this appliance does are similar to the ones accomplished by a cell phone or computer. And like those things, the microphone works best when the device is connected to a power source. When it comes down to it, we are all compromised, and it's just a question of what you are comfortable with. Some people choose not to use electricity at home, and yet they go on living. Your choices are your own, and of the billions of people you should take pride in your individuality and be comfortable in your choices.
- lostgame 7y ago>> Please forgive my tone, but it doesn't take a genius to recognize that you shouldn't have sensitive conversations around a microphone. Then, forgive my tone, but it doesn’t take a genius to understand that you don’t want one constantly monitoring you in your home. Where you have private conversations. This is my point. These devices are physical spyware - they’re as useful and terrible as Bonzi Buddy but people pay for it.
- lostgame 7y agoTo add, I’ve actually opened up my 2011 MacBook Pro and physically removed the wire connecting the microphone and video camera from the device. I use TOR, for everything. Even basic browsing. I’ll take the performance hit any day. I also disable JS on 90% of sites I visit. I’ve stayed at an iPhone 6S that I could jailbreak to observe outgoing and incoming network information and block IPs where necessary, and redirect to TOR in the background. I don’t keep Android devices and let all of my friends know about all the serious security risks involved, and beg them to at least get a refurbished iPhone instead. I have friends in the psychedelic scene who literally text each other openly about LSD like total idiots when Signal is free. I have friends who have ended up in prison, not even jail, from this kind of shit. I talk about psychedelics, I talk about occultism, I talk about revolutionary political ideas, and I talk about private details like my sex life, comfortably, at home, as do many, many of my friends. Having one of these devices in their home alone could be a ticket to jail or prison for them. You’re telling me there are advantages for this shit? Because you can turn your lights on without having to grab your phone, or, God forbid, stand up and go flick a light switch, it’s worth it to have corporations listening in to all your shit? You’ve obviously never had to watch a best friend dragged off by police due to getting nabbed by information grabbed through technology. Good for you! Have a cookie. Some people are involved in progressing society beyond its pathetic, self destructive status-quo, to move the world forward, and we need privacy to do that. If you wanna live your little work, wife, and kids life, where you’d never be concerned about a single thing you say while your Echo is around, go for it. Myself? I actually intend to change the world while I’m on it. So no, I’m not alright with anyone listening in to what I’m doing.
- kiseleon 7y agoFor me it is because when I am home I don't want to have to use my phone. I want to spend time with my family. Every time I pull out my phone there is the temptation to check my email, message friends, etc. But with my echo dot (or google home mini, I currently have both while I decide which to keep) I can control my lights by voice without missing a beat, I can play music for my kids to dance to without fumbling through an app, I can check the weather forecast while I'm digging through the coat closet, all without being distracted from what I'm doing and without any extra fluff. I do not have any locks or security systems connected to them as I do not trust them that far, but for informational and recreational use they have made things considerably more convenient.
- ouid 7y agohow does not wanting to use your phone have anything to do with using a listening device to turn off your lights?
- rtkwe 7y agoI don't see how it's not clear. Kiseleon wants the convenience features of various bits of smart home tech without having to use their phone to do it so that they can avoid the attention maw that is the cell phone.
- ouid 7y agoThat's not the parent comment's point at all. Parent comment is clearly arguing that the convenience provided by an alexa over having no smart home stuff at all is not worth the privacy invasion. Pointing out that you can accomplish the same thing with your phone only improves that position.
- sparrish 7y agoCause my kids need help spelling and I really suck at it.
- engineer_22 7y agoDon't worry, neurodiversity is trending
- ryandvm 7y agoDo you really not understand or are you just not accepting the same answers everyone gives every time this question comes up? They're terribly useful for listening to music, setting timers, alarms, reminders, checking weather, traffic, unit conversions, and just general web lookups. I suspect what you meant was, "why do people trade their privacy for convenience?" Which of course is ALWAYS the trade-off one makes when it comes to security. I personally have decided (for now) that the convenience of the devices outweighs the likely harm they will have on me. Would I have one if I were running for political office? Absolutely not.
- satokema_work 7y agoIt's weird that I manage to do that entire list of things without saying a word aloud. It's luxury tech. That's where the market is.
- nimajneb 7y agoIf your phone has a mic, it's most likely also listening. Most new phones have the same technology as the smart speakers. And even if it doesn't have the feature, it's can still be compromised to be listening.
- bduerst 7y agoBy that logic, a TV remote control is "luxury tech". VUI is just another new interface for devices that provides convenience.
- compiler-guy 7y agoTotally luxury tech. Just like nice phones, wide-screen TVs, and a million other things that people find useful, convenient, and fun.
- dwild 7y ago> It's weird that I manage to do that entire list of things without saying a word aloud. That's a incredibly broad statement... anything you do can be done in another way which someone could define as luxury. I can churn butter, but I like the luxury to buy it instead, I expect you are the same ;).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gwbas1c 7y agoI find voice controls so frustrating that I don't see the appeal. Maybe once "okay google" works correctly on my phone, I'll start using one of these.
- roywiggins 7y agoI use mine as a glorified internet radio. My grandparents use it as a glorified Clapper(tm) to switch room lights on and off. If you can find a standalone internet radio that's as convenient as an Amazon Echo, please let me know. It's an underserved market.