3 ms·
That argument would be emotionally manipulative, but that isn't the major problem here. Society's use of oil and gas is a totally political question of how muc
by roenxi 7y ago
That argument would be emotionally manipulative, but that isn't the major problem here.
Society's use of oil and gas is a totally political question of how much pain we experience in the near term vs the long term and who pays for any trade-offs that get made. It is not kosher for employees of a company to use their corporate position to push what are private political goals.
Particularly because Google's position in the world is to provide people with facts and evidence - if they are being pressured internally by political actors then that compromises their trustworthiness as a search provider. They aren't a traditional media organisation where a page full of propaganda and lies is par for the course and everyone knows it. People expect them to use a politically neutral algorithm.
Are there people who believe that we need "urgent and decisive action" on political topics who have influence over the search index? How are they using that influence? What would happen if the next generation of employees have a radically different political view? These aren't new questions; Google's rankings are always going to be an interesting subject - and there is every chance that someone is running a smear campaign with stories of these intercompany issues. However, they are the important questions when Google employees do something political.
- magicalist 7y ago> Society's use of oil and gas is a totally political question of how much pain we experience in the near term vs the long term and who pays for any trade-offs that get made. It is not kosher for employees of a company to use their corporate position to push what are private political goals. lol, yes, when it comes to oil and gas, it's widely expected that companies not push for political goals. Oil and gas companies companies steer well clear of those politics. Yep.
- viridian 7y agoYour comment is the least charitable possible interpretation of the above user's statement, and adds nothing except for biting sarcasm to the discussion. I hope that every user here tries to leave hacker news a better, more thoughtful place than they found it.
- magicalist 7y ago> Your comment is the least charitable possible interpretation of the above user's statement Please, do tell, then. Because "that's not a nice reaction" is not the same as an uncharitable interpretation. It's ridiculous on its face to call for employees of a company to not engage in politics and define the use of oil and gas as political and therefore out of bounds, when the actions being taken here are engaging with the actions of oil and gas companies. (leaving aside the idea that it's ok for me, internet commentator, to have strong opinions, but not the employees that make some product I use)
- viridian 7y agoYou interpreted "employees of a company to use their corporate position to push what are private political goals" as "companies not push[ing] for political goals" in order to sarcastically respond. There is a difference between a company and it's individual employees, and rephrasing the statement such that "employees of a company" is replaced with "a company" in order to mock a user is rude and also not substantive.
- magicalist 7y ago> There is a difference between a company and it's individual employees, and rephrasing the statement such that "employees of a company" is replaced with "a company" Unless there's a good argument that managers and executives are somehow different than other employees, companies pushing for political goals absolutely are employees of a company using their position to push private political goals.
- cbnotfromthere 7y agoUnless there's a good argument that managers and executives are somehow different than other employees By definition managers/executives are different than (other) employees. That's why managers / executives can't unionize. That's why managers / executives represent the company, while the (other) employees just work there. Clear now?
- coliveira 7y ago> People expect them to use a politically neutral algorithm. There is no such thing as a politically neutral algorithm. Algorithms exist to implement decisions that have been previously made, and these decisions are political in nature. Neutrality is the name given to people and institutions that support the status quo, and therefore they cannot be viewed as apolitical, even though, for lack of understanding, many believe to be operating outside of politics.
- blotter_paper 7y ago> Neutrality is the name given to people and institutions that support the status quo Strongly disagree. If google censors information relating to Tiananmen Square, that supports the status quo without being neutral. If they don't filter that information out they undermine the status quo while remaining neutral. I could at least understand the position that no censorship can be construed as being politically opposed to censorship, but I don't really think that's the case in all cases; it is simpler to make a tool for finding knowledge in the general case than it is to make a tool that additionally filters that knowledge on ideological grounds.
- coliveira 7y agoChina is not the status quo in the US. Thus, it is very easy for Google to pretend to be neutral regarding political facts occurring there. But even that is not entirely true. The Tiananmen Square events are very important for the narrative of western governments against China, so what appears there has also a political connotation.
- blotter_paper 7y agoIt's an arbitrary example of information which is commonly censored to support the status quo, if you want an example targeted at America we could just as easily use pirated media.
- babycake 7y ago> It is not kosher for employees of a company to use their corporate position to push what are private political goals. What's the difference between employees of a company pushing for political change versus company executives using their position and influence to affect politics? ie, https://time.com/5713537/amazon-seattle-city-council/ https://time.com/5713537/amazon-seattle-city-council/ The answer is there is none. A company is founded by people, and people run the company, either as workers, shareholders, or both. In the end, this is a good sign for us regular people. We want change, and the only way to get it is to get political. Either that, or riots.
- buboard 7y agoexecutives can be held accountable, nobody is going to go after employees. Nobody would call FB engineers to the congress.
- roenxi 7y ago> What's the difference between employees of a company pushing for political change versus company executives using their position and influence to affect politics? The executives shouldn't be doing that either. However, the core role of the executive is to decide how to deploy a companies resources. That is a pretty substantial difference. > We want change ... 'We' is presumably a group of people living in a democratic first world country. We have systems for deciding what 'we' want, and it frequently spits out results that suggest 'we' do not want change.