5 ms·
Well looking at where the Microsoft ecosystem is now and where the Apple ecosystem is, I think Apple made the right choice. Apple alone sells more devices run
by scarface74 7y ago
Well looking at where the Microsoft ecosystem is now and where the Apple ecosystem is, I think Apple made the right choice. Apple alone sells more devices running macOS variants than all Windows PC makers combined.
As far as backwards compatibility though - MS’s new ARM based Surface won’t run 64 bit x86 Windows apps and run 32 bit x86 apps slowly and still gets half the advertised life of iPads.
Windows on Surface took 12GB of hard drive space compared to about 3GB for iOS on iPads.
- einr 7y agoApple alone sells more devices running macOS variants than all Windows PC makers combined. Where did you find those numbers? https://www.macrumors.com/2019/01/10/apple-mac-sales-drop-q4-2018/ https://www.macrumors.com/2019/01/10/apple-mac-sales-drop-q4... In Q4 of 2018, Apple sold 4.9 million Macs. Lenovo alone sold 16.6 million PC's. All brands except apple sold 63.7 million.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 7y agoI said MacOS variants - iPhones, iPads, and Macs. Those are three areas where we have recent real numbers from Apple before they stopped reporting volume numbers. I could include Watches and AppleTVs but those are far from generally purpose computing devices.
- walterstucco666 7y ago> iPhones, iPads, and Macs Which is just two variants meanwhile Windows 7 support will end in 2020 and is still being sold https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/help/4057281/windows-7-support-will-end-on-january-14-2020 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/help/4057281/windows-7-s...
- scarface74 7y agoIf you want to be pedantic, macOS and variants. I didn’t say that MS isn’t good at maintaining backwards compatibility. My mom in fact uses my old Mac Mini 1.66Ghz Core Duo introduced in 2006 running Windows 7 and I just retired a Core 2 Duo 2.66Ghz laptop introduced in 2009 from running my Plex Server running Windows 10. I’m saying that it hasn’t been a sound business strategy as the rest of the tech industry has moved on. Windows (not Microsoft) has failed in the cloud, the web browser market, and mobile.
- walterstucco666 7y ago> Windows (not Microsoft) has failed in the cloud, the web browser market, and mobile. I don't agree on the Cloud, it's the strongest competitor to Amazon, and on the other businesses there is no competition: mobile and browser is Google. Amazon failed as well in the mobile business.
- scarface74 7y agoThat’s what I meant. Microsoft hasn’t failed in the cloud - Windows has. As far as mobile being “google”. In terms of revenue, it came out in the Oracle lawsuit that Android has only made Google about $33 billion its entire existence. Less than the amount that Apple makes in two quarters on iPhones. Google also reportedly still pays Apple $8 billion a year to bectge default search engine in Apple devices.
- walterstucco666 7y ago> Microsoft hasn’t failed in the cloud - Windows has. as a server, maybe. as a client not really. > Android has only made Google about $33 billion its entire existence Yeah, they are good at hiding profits and they are an ADV company which dominated the mobile market because it was strategic, they don't need to profit from selling (and manufacturing) the HW, they just need your screen time. There are between 2.5 and 3 billion android devices around the world. And it's almost impossible to own an android devices without Google SW on it. > Less than the amount that Apple makes in two quarters on iPhones. That's not really true, and iPhone revenues are declining every year. In 2018 thy made $33.36 billions, down of 9.2% from the previous year. If Apple loses the mobile market, it's finished. But people would still watch YouTube advs on iPhone replacements.
- NikolaNovak 7y ago>> MacOS variants - iPhones, iPads, and Macs As an outsider, it is very difficult for me to understand Apple's story on whether these devices are, or are not, on the same OS; what its/their "root" was; and what's the future direction (separate OS, or convergence, and if latter which one will form the core and which one will transform). The newest "iPad OS" or whatever it is called does not help matters - again, as an outsider, I cannot tell if this is a marketing differentiation or a true one. All that being said, I rather thought that iPhones & iPads run "iOS", and Macs run "OSX", and that they were different.
- scarface74 7y agoFirst there were two operating systems Classic MacOS and Next. Apple acquired Next and they combined some parts of classic MacOS and NextStep to create OS X. Apple then stripped OS X down, got rid of some Mac specific parts, added some new frameworks to create “iPhone OS” and introduced the iPhone Initially they claimed that the iPhone was “.running OS X”. They introduced the iPod Touch later the same year and the iPad 3 years later at this point, they renamed “iPhone OS” to “iOS”. They introduced watchOS and tvOS as more variants of iOS. There is also some iOS variant running on HomePods. Over the years the two operating systems have both somewhat diverged and they still share both some old code and new code between the two. This year, they renamed the version of iOS running on the iPad “iPadOS” as they started adding more iPad specific features. They also introduced the “Catalyst” framework to bring iOS specific frameworks to the Mac to make porting from iPad to the Mac easier. Finally, they introduced Swift UI as a common cross platform framework for watchOS, iOS, macOS, iPadOS and tvOS.
- oneplane 7y agoThey all run the same kernel and runtimes, but some diversified distributions have extra runtimes and frameworks for their task-specific implementations. - Cocoa - Objective-C - XNU It used to be all based on pure Darwin (also from Apple, but OSS). But since the iOS releases it has been diversified too much and Apple no longer wanted to backport to their own OSS (but they still backport to all GPLv2 and lower).
- Macha 7y agoIf you want to use iOS to claim that macos is more popular than windows, then I may as well use Android to claim Linux as the most popular consumer OS
- scarface74 7y agoWell, if I wanted to say that, that’s what I would have said.... But I said variants. But, if you take MacOS out, the statement remains. And seeing that iOS is now running Microsoft Office a version of Photoshop and is using more powerful processors than most x86 based PCs, we can complete take out MacOS and just iOS. I said nothing about popularity, I was saying successful. Success in a business isn’t marketshare or popularity its profitability. Seeing how little profit that OEMs are making selling either Android devices (most of whom are losing money - except for Samsung) or PCs, I wouldn’t be surprised that Apple is more successful than all of the PC makers combined selling Macs and its well known that Apple captures more than 70% of the profit in mobile.
- computerex 7y agoPeople don't use their phones to write documents or do professional image/video editing or any professional workload, really. And I think market share is as good a metric as any when it comes to defining "success". Profitability is due to many reasons and it's not always due creating the best product.
- scarface74 7y agoCan you spend “marketshare”? Can you sustain a business on “marketshare”? A company can’t stay viable based on “marketshars”. Next am I arguing what’s “best”. Do you think Dell would rather be in Apple’s position with “market share” or Apple’s in Dell’s? There are plenty of people whose only personal computing device is their phone either by choice or necessity. Heck I am a developer and the only thing I use my computer at home for is as a Plex server. It’s on my list to get a powerful enough NAS to transcode movies and I won’t even use it for that. I’ll run Plex and bit torrent (to uhh download Linux ISO’s) and B2 backed cloud backup app directly on it. My wife gave her computer to our son because she uses her iPad for everything including Office. Now that Apple (finally) supports a mouse, I connect my same Bluetooth keyboard+mouse to my iPad that I use for my work computer when I bring it home.
- computerex 7y agoMacOS is a desktop operating system, the other devices you mentioned don't run desktop operating systems. You have to do an Apples to Apples comparison, because otherwise linux wipes the floor with every OS if all we are talking about is market share on metal.
- scarface74 7y agoWhy do you have to compare desktop operating systems? An iPad Pro running the latest OS is faster than most x86 PCs, run Office and now Photoshop and can easily take the place of a desktop computer for many people. But regardless, if you are referring to “successful”. Which I’m discussing, success from a business standpoint is profitable. Apple is definitely making more in profit and revenue than Microsoft. As in, Apple had the more successful strategy. There are plenty of people whose only computing device is a phone and others who are hardly ever use a computer for personal use. Even the iPhone can keep up performance wise with some low end PCs being sold.
- saagarjha 7y ago> I said MacOS variants - iPhones, iPads, and Macs. Oh, come on. That's profoundly misleading and you know it.
- scarface74 7y agoWhat does “variant” mean? It’s not some obscure word that no one understands. Would it have been more clear if I said Darwin variants? Who the heck knows what Darwin is besides a few nerds?
- saagarjha 7y ago> Would it have been more clear if I said Darwin variants? Yes.
- scarface74 7y agoHow so? iOS evolved from MacOS not Darwin. Darwin is at best a grandparent of iOS.
- criley2 7y ago"Well looking at where the Microsoft ecosystem is now and where the Apple ecosystem is, I think Apple made the right choice. Apple alone sells more devices running macOS variants than all Windows PC makers combined." This is a fancy way of saying that Apple sells more watches and phones than Microsoft does computers, which is a whole lot less impressive than the disinformation version you wrote above. When I look at the microsoft ecosystem: something like 90% of all computers, nearly every corporation and business in the world, etc, I don't see anything to be ashamed of.
- scarface74 7y agoThis is a fancy way of saying that Apple sells more watches and phones than Microsoft does computers, which is a whole lot less impressive than the disinformation version you wrote above How is it “disinformation”? Do you think anyone on HN doesn’t understand the statement to mean what I said for it to mean? I said nothing about the computers MS sells (the Surface line). I said Windows PCs in general. Microsoft sells a lot of Windows licenses to business and consumers but all of the energy from a development and usage standpoint is on the web. I bet most businesses could replace a lot of their computers with Chrome OS boxes and not miss a beat. Apple sells a >$1000 phone labeled for "Professionals" which comes with 32GB of on board memory.... total. When you upcharge high end customers $150 for a $15 stick of NAND, yeah, people are more touchy about 8GB of system file It’s not about the “system file”. It’s also about RAM usage. Lowend Surface laptops come with the same amount of storage as iPads but between using x86 chips that are a lot slower and less energy efficient and the boost of Windows, it’s nowhere near the same experience. No iPhone Pro comes with less than the 64GB of storage. Do you really want to talk about marginal price and marginal cost? A Windows license has no marginal cost.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- oarsinsync 7y ago> How is it “disinformation”? Do you think anyone on HN doesn’t understand the statement to mean what I said for it to mean? At least one person[0] didn't understand and publicly stated as much. While iOS was originally spun off from macOS, it's very much it's own system, with there being no ability to run macOS applications on iOS, and vice versa (although the latter is slowly changing with recent macOS releases). Comparing the two is disingenuous at best. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21452862 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21452862 EDIT: And here's at least one more: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21453368 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21453368
- yyyk 7y agoMicrosoft for once acted very differently from its usual self, and Windows Phone repeatedly broke backward compatibility. Arguably even more than iOS did - and this was one of the factors in its failure. So this is not the argument against backward compatibility you think it is. Besides, if you're comparing MS and Apple, you need to include all the VMs running Windows (it's not a physical device - but MS makes the same amount of money on it), and also MS's foothold in Cloud. Apple practically does not exist in those spaces, and Microsoft would have been in the same position had it broke compat as often as Apple does on the desktop.