4 ms·
In general the answer for consumer protection is to use any escrow service. Multi-signature schemes can even prevent you from a bad escrow, as long as no two pa
by wongarsu 7y ago
In general the answer for consumer protection is to use any escrow service. Multi-signature schemes can even prevent you from a bad escrow, as long as no two parties are colluding.
In general the need for consumer protection mechanisms is of course already a failing of the justice system. Virtually every case where consumer protection is useful is covered by existing laws and shouldn't require anything from the payment facilitator.
- leeoniya 7y ago> Virtually every case where consumer protection is useful is covered by existing laws and shouldn't require anything... ...except a lawyer, more money and a non-trivial part of your life.
- derefr 7y agoYes, that’s the failing. Ideally, justice should be cheaper in both time and monetary costs. I don’t know of any state that has ever tried to optimize for a low-overhead justice system “in the small” (e.g. many, more efficient, more convenient small-claims courts; or the introduction of another triage layer of “medium-claims” courts, where most all civil contractual disputes would land) which is an interesting fact all by itself. Speedy+cheap justice goes somewhat hand-in-hand with things like red-tape reduction, in that both are attempts to “oil the wheels” of the state apparatus—yet you’d never hear the same people (e.g. libertarians) espouse both.
- waqf 7y agoAren't small-claims courts precisely an attempt to optimize for a low-overhead justice system in the small? Doubtless you feel they don't succeed or don't go far enough, but it seems odd to claim that nobody's tried.
- repolfx 7y agoThat's what cryptocurrencies allow, since Bitcoin. People can pick a dispute mediator who gets involved and can reverse the transaction only if there's a dispute. It's all done with OP_CHECKMULTISIG. The mediator is not an escrow service and can't steal the money. So you end up with a competitive market of tiny "courts".
- dragonwriter 7y ago> I don’t know of any state that has ever tried to optimize for a low-overhead justice system “in the small” Both small-claims courts themselves and rules giving effect to binding arbitration agreements are attempts to do that, as are many specialized, domain-specific administrative forums.
- marcoseliziario 7y agoBut if you are going to introduce a third-party anyway, why use crypto?
- rusk 7y agobecause even with a third party, it's still much cheaper, secure, and private.
- Nursie 7y agoI mean, except that it's actually not cheaper, you've just moved the trust and security problems around (to your own opsec and your trust in the counterparty) and the privacy most cryptocurrencies provide is pseudonymity rather than anonoymity... But sure, other than all those things.
- rusk 7y agobut I think, with traditional money exchange the reliance is on regulatory and legal enforcement, rather than making the technology itself watertight, which increases the risk profile, and thus cost. You can do this in traditional approaches because you just pass on these costs and there's no need to improve beyond what people are willing to pay. Crypto represents an asymptote for what a rigorously applied technological approach (as opposed to beaureaucratic/legal approach) can do, using commodity equipment, which is much more available at the endpoints of these transactions now ... (because most people have high-powered, always connected computers available to them).
- Nursie 7y ago> but I think, with traditional money exchange the reliance is on regulatory and legal enforcement, rather than making the technology itself watertight, A lot of money and research has gone into this, and the tech is being tightened up all the time. > which increases the risk profile, and thus cost. Except the cost isn't actually higher. > You can do this in traditional approaches because you just pass on these costs and there's no need to improve beyond what people are willing to pay. In the US perhaps, not in places where these costs are regulated. > Crypto represents... A much more expensive and more risky way to do basically anything, because you have neither solved security nor trust problems, you've just moved them.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> In general the answer for consumer protection is to use any escrow service. No, it's not, because the problem being addressed with consumer protection is power imbalance in the marketplace; mutually voluntary mechanisms cannot be the answer to it. Also, escrow notionally solves exactly the same problem as cryptocurrency: providing the ability to rely on a transaction with an untrusted counterparty. If you need escrow for anything with cryptocurrency, the cryptocurrency is not doing the one thing that is it's defining purpose. So, why cryptocurrency at all?
- scott_s 7y agoI'm confused by your last paragraph. How does the existence of laws that protect consumers actually protect consumers if the payment systems we use don't allow reversals?
- wongarsu 7y agoIf an ebay seller delivers me a faulty product I can sue them for not delivering what I payed for and when I win the court orders them to pay the money back (plus my expenses). If they don't pay I can go after their assets. It's basically the same how a business would recover money from a bad supplier. With small claims court it's even somewhat efficient for small sums, but of course still orders of magnitude more work than a credit card dispute.
- scott_s 7y agoThat's an enormous burden. If we require lawsuits to enforce even minor cases of consumer protection, I argue that there is effectively no actual consumer protection.
- wongarsu 7y agoThe law not working for "minor cases" (which includes cases over hundreds of dollars) is exactly the failing of the justice system I mentioned. This isn't universal, in many places you can get theft of a Mars bar or possession of tiny amounts of drugs prosecuted very effectively, all cases much more minor than the typical credit card dispute.
- scott_s 7y agoSo, rather than having a financial system with basic consumer protections (which would allow transaction reversals and contestation), you would prefer we have a criminal justice system which aggressively enforces and prosecutes minor offenses? I think there is a weak connection between the two, particularly since most situations where we do things like dispute a credit card charge are civil matters. And, as stated above, requiring civil suits for something like disputing a credit card charge is an enormous burden, and puts the burden on the consumer. (Which will also disproportionally affect the poor.)