4 ms·
Well, technically… The GPL does not actually force anyone to give out source code. The GPLv2 requires to either give out source code to customers, or to give
by teddyh 7y ago
Well, technically…
The GPL does not actually force anyone to give out source code. The GPLv2 requires to either give out source code to customers, or to give customers a written offer (valid for anyone, not just customers). It is this optional offer, which, being a promise, forces the giving out of source code to anyone in possession of this offer. Failure to honor such an offer is probably not a GPL violation, but a simple breach of contract/promise.
If no such offer was given, then the GPLv2 was violated, full stop. The Conservancy had really no need to ask for source code, since the GPLv2 violation occurred when no offer nor source code was given to customers. The fact that the Conservancy did offer the violators a way out by asking for source code is a pure nicety on their part, since they really didn’t have to.
- pricechild 7y agoWell technically... you left out an important word after "offer": > a written offer, valid for at least three ... So it's not just requiring an offer be made, it's requiring a offer being made which is valid (with certain conditions) If you make an offer you have no intention of honouring, surely that's not a valid offer?
- teddyh 7y agoUnless Ubiquiti actually provided such an offer (valid or not), this discussion is getting unnecessarily complicated.
- shakna 7y ago> Some of the software in the firmware is licensed under the GNU General Public License and other Open Source and Free Software licenses. You can find the complete and corresponding source in the GPL archive. [0] They seem to have plenty of GPL sources available for download when you grab the firmware (and without having a device to test, it may actually include the source code with itself), so it seems they do offer up this source code. (The firmware download does come with a EULA, but the EULA specifically spells out it only applies to the proprietary bits, and not GPL and other Open Source software.) So it seems that the claim "Specifically, in our analysis of the facts, we have found that both Cambium and Ubiquiti fail to provide any source code for their respective routers and access points..." needs more information before we can be certain that it is correct. [0] https://www.ui.com/download/edgemax/default/default/edgeswitch-firmware-v190 https://www.ui.com/download/edgemax/default/default/edgeswit...
- teddyh 7y agoAgain, technically, GPLv2 does not allow the source code to be made available only for download. Only GPLv3 allows that. And, since Linux is GPLv2 only, the GPLv2 applies. Therefore, the source code has to be either a) shipped with the product (it obviously wasn’t) or b) available upon request as specified in a written offer, which must be shipped with the product. If neither option a) nor b) was used, Ubiquiti unambiguously violated the GPLv2, and has no defense.