3 ms·
In general, a scientist will never "claim as true" anything. They will make claims of the following nature: Theoretical: Given assumptions A, we derive conclus
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
In general, a scientist will never "claim as true" anything. They will make claims of the following nature:
Theoretical: Given assumptions A, we derive conclusion Y.
Experimental: We observe phenomena Y. This is consistent with A, but inconsistent with A2. Thus, assumption A2 must be false.
The fact that you don't believe theory A doesn't make your experiment refuting A2 invalid. And the fact that you don't believe A doesn't mean that it's incorrect to make conclusions about what would happen if they were true.
And in particular, none of this has any bearing on holding beliefs which are not even wrong. You might believe in Copenhagen QM, I might be a Bohmian, but that doesn't make either of us frauds when we do calculations involving the Schrodinger equation. That's the thing - science isn't religion. The correctness of a theory or the usefulness of an experiment is not dependent on the beliefs of the person performing it.