5 ms·
How do we help those kids that are in 'gen pop', though? Simply pulling the smarter kids out, helping them, and ignoring the rest doesn't seem like a good answe
by cortesoft 7y ago
How do we help those kids that are in 'gen pop', though? Simply pulling the smarter kids out, helping them, and ignoring the rest doesn't seem like a good answer, either.
I feel like HN is not the best place for this sort of discussion, since everyone is coming at the problem from the perspective of the high achiever. The low achievers deserve help, too.
- borski 7y agoI agree with this 100%, but the issues are not intertwined. We need to fix how classes are taught in "low achieving schools," but that's really hard to do when teachers are paid so poorly. Teaching isn't a lucrative career, and thus those that would be great teachers don't generally go into it. It's a really complex and difficult problem that I don't know I have a solution for. I do know that getting rid of magnet schools isn't it, though.
- virtuous_signal 7y agoAnd I agree with this 100%. I think that if we could somehow by fiat pay teachers as much as we paid doctors or lawyers we would attract the same calibre of talent. But we pay teachers as much as janitors or secretaries and somehow expect them to inspire intellectuals. One thing I'm not saying is that we should just give raises to everyone who's currently in the profession. It would have to be for jobs from here on out. I know of one school that does this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Equity_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Equity_Project
- barry-cotter 7y ago> on average, public-school teachers receive total compensation that is roughly 50 percent higher than what they would receive in private-sector employment. While salaries are at appropriate levels, fringe benefits push teacher compensation far ahead of what private-sector workers enjoy. Consequently, recruiting more effective teachers for public schools will be much more difficult than simply raising salaries. https://www.heritage.org/education/report/critical-issues-assessing-teacher-compensation https://www.heritage.org/education/report/critical-issues-as...
- nitrogen 7y agoAs someone raised by two teachers I can say that my parents both had to work two to four different jobs at times just to struggle to keep up. Whatever that statistic is claiming, it doesn't reflect reality in at least some cases.
- cortesoft 7y agoInteresting... both my parents were teachers, and we lived comfortably enough (not rich, but never felt deprived)
- sokoloff 7y agoSame here, but I recall my parents doing side hustles working nights at the drive-in, on summer breaks filling gardens for cash, cutting firewood, doing renovation projects on rental properties we would buy to fix and rent, running a snow plow truck 12-16 hours during storms (teachers get snow days in MD, so snow plow is a near-perfect side hustle), etc.
- barry-cotter 7y agoIf you could share something about where and when your parents were working that would be most informative, thanks. Certainly there are outliers in every population but the study is talking about the teaching population, on average.
- nitrogen 7y agoUtah, in a not-particularly-rich-but-not-middle-of-nowhere rural/suburban district, starting in the 1980s
- TylerE 7y agoHave you ever, like, talked to any teachers? Because that's total bullshit, which isn't surprising being from the Good Ole Boys Propaganda Office. https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/heritage-foundation/ https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/heritage-foundation/
- underpand 7y agoThe bottom 10-20% (larger in 'inner city' schools) of people with behavioral issues will always ruin it for everyone else. Behavioral issues negatively correlates with intelligence and effort in school (by both the parents and the students). Increased tracking (i.e. separate low achieving and regular achieving) can be used to 'rescue' the majority of students that are average from having their education disrupted from the behavioral issue kids. Effort and behavioral (i.e. evaluate based on behavioral infractions) based hoops for parents and students can be used to separate the low achieving from the disruptive.
- borski 7y agoBe careful how you define 'behavioral issues.' I think I know what you mean, but you should more carefully define it; I had plenty of behavioral issues. In fact, I was constantly in trouble for talking too much, not paying attention, being loud, etc. I was bored af. But I wasn't doing drugs or fighting (minus the one or two times), so there's that.
- nitrogen 7y agoAlso need to be careful not to lump the bully and the victim into the same category of "fighting". Both need different interventions.
- liability 7y agoOn the other hand, there will be some fights that defy such classification of the participants. In those circumstances, improperly classifying one participant as the victim and the other as the bully can make the situation worse than it was before.
- marcusverus 7y agoI don't think anyone is advocating for 'ignoring the rest'. The point is to prevent 'the rest' from setting the pace of development for everyone. You can't optimize educational outcomes for the full spectrum of human beings, from the no-effort types with an IQ of 85, to motivated types with IQs of 115+, in a single classroom with a single curriculum. It just does not make sense. If anything, separating high, medium, and low achievers and allowing them to move at their own pace seems like a preferable situation for everyone.
- lutorm 7y agoYour assumption here is in exact opposition to the article. Unless you can successfully argue that the numbers in the article are wrong, it appears that what seems like a preferable situation is, in fact, not.
- zaroth 7y agoThe article seems to dance around some carefully crafted statistics. Students are “happier,” or more kids are taking classes which are labeled as advanced. I see very little in the form of college admissions rates, SAT scores, etc. It’s also possible that tracking does in fact lower the average performance while increasing the high end performance. One things which would help regardless is for Administrators which permit students to perpetuate bullying and abuse within the student body to be sued out of a job if not charged criminally. The shit we put up with kids doing to kids luckily seems to be changing fairly radically, and that does obviously help you tune down some of the tracking which in the past served as much a behavior as it did a pedagogical purpose. I will say that my 5th grade daughter basically has stopped being taught new material for the last year (2nd half of 4th and first half of 5th) while the whole the class seems to be stuck in perpetual review mode. She complains that the teacher will rarely offer something new, and she doesn’t understand why everyone else in the class can’t just listen the first time it’s explained, and why the teacher spends the rest of the week basically repeating themselves. I’m paranoid of teaching her independently and just making her even more bored. Tracking doesn’t start in my district until 6th grade and we are both very much looking forward to it.
- travisoneill1 7y agoWhy do they need more help? The classes are already designed for them. The problem is that the smart kids are forced to be in them too.
- bcrosby95 7y agoHe said he did bad because he was bullied. Smart people aren't the only ones that get bullied. If the problem is bullying you aren't fixing it by pulling someone out, the bullies will just target other people.
- bg4 7y agoThe bullies aren't living healthy, productive lives either. More than likely, their home life is awful if not horrific.
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agoHonestly... I don’t care much. My school was low on bullying. Nothing torturous like others experience. Most of the gen pop students were pretty rude and dumb. And most of them have lower middle class business jobs that suck ass but put food on the table. And none of their education mattered except for rubber stamping milestones. “Deserves help” doesn’t make sense to me. Their life choices are going to be the determinants of whether they hit a moderate outcome vs an incredibly shitty outcome. Their education isn’t useful. If you want to help them, find a way to improve society that’s overburdened with unskilled workers with middle class aspirations. The gen pop group doesn’t disappear when high school ends. It’s still just the majority of people, just perhaps less socially empowered than in high school. We didn’t fail to make them love science, they just don't care about science. It would be far better to recognize that they would be just fine with less education, no college debt, and some encouragement to make a better society for everyone.
- liability 7y agoYou can help the top 90% by keeping the bottom 10% away from them. And similarly, you can probably help that bottom 10% by removing the bottom 1% (the bottom 10% of the bottom 10%) from their environment. You can probably get good milage out of recursing this up until the point you're dealing with fractional people.
- shard972 7y agoso remove all the blacks?