4 ms·
They don’t write tax laws or run housing associations. Policymakers and older Californians have managed to shift blame to a younger generation of working people
by gamblor956 7y ago
They don’t write tax laws or run housing associations. Policymakers and older Californians have managed to shift blame to a younger generation of working people.
Apple is also one of the most notorious tax avoiders in world history. They've taken extreme efforts to avoid paying taxes in every jurisdiction in which they do business, to the extent that a number of their tax structurings have been deemed illegal.
On the one hand, it's good that Apple is finally putting its money where its marketing is. On the other hand, if they hadn't spent 40 years avoiding taxes, they wouldn't have driven the development of an entire cottage industry of multinationals avoiding taxes.
- notyourwork 7y agoWould more tax money from Apple result in a larger supply of housing or a more affordable housing situation? I'm not clear on how it would.
- wesammikhail 7y agoIt Wouldn´t. Tax revenue is not the cause of the housing shortage. If you give more money to a bad manager, he won´t suddenly become a better manager. Same with politicians and their public policy.
- droithomme 7y ago> If you give more money to a bad manager, he won´t suddenly become a better manager. If we increase teacher pay will the bad teachers become good teachers?
- Gibbon1 7y agoMy old long dead relatives liked to say, you get what you pay for.
- mcbutterbunz 7y agoPotentially. If the teacher is working a second job just to make rent instead of preparing a lesson plan or possibly working on their mental health. It won't help every bad teacher but it could help some.
- droithomme 7y agoGreat point. Here's some articles that provide support to the observation that teachers are more likely than other professions to have to have a second job: https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/4/4/17164718/teachers-work-part-time-jobs https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/4/4/17164718/te... https://www.brookings.edu/blog/brown-center-chalkboard/2018/03/23/why-are-teachers-more-likely-than-others-to-work-second-jobs/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/brown-center-chalkboard/2018/... > To begin, how do we know who works a second job? The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) conducts a year-round survey, called the American Time Use Survey, in which it asks individuals how they have spent their time both on the day of the survey and in the very recent past. In addition to asking about a person’s main occupation, the BLS asks if they worked another job in the last seven days. Our sample is made up of individuals with a college education who report being employed full-time from 2003 through 2016, giving us just over 36,000 observations. > Overall, teachers (defined as elementary and secondary teachers, excluding special ed) are about 30 percent more likely than non-teachers to work a second job based on survey responses. That comes down to about 11 percent of non-teachers and 14 percent of teachers. Now possibly this difference is due to having summers off and time to take on a job and that job doesn't affect their main seasonal work of teaching. However, we don't know as these studies didn't look into that. Wait, or do they?!? > What time of year would you expect to find that teachers are most likely to hold second jobs? Like me, you may have guessed summer, but it turns out that’s not what the data says. First, teachers are more likely than non-teachers to have a second job all year, except in the October and November run-up to the holiday season. For teachers, the big months for second jobs are January and February. I would have thought that teachers are more likely to pick up outside work when school is not in session. But you can see from the chart that that’s not what’s going on.
- austhrow743 7y agoThe current bad teachers that get the pay rise would just be lucky. The value there would be for 5+ years down the line as more highly effective, ambitious people choose teaching as a career path and take teaching positions that future bad teachers would have received.
- TrackerFF 7y agoWell, I guess if you tax companies harder, maybe they'd pay their workers less, which would result in lower housing prices? If you pay people whatever, then they're gonna start competing against each others for the same finite resources (housing), driving up prices to artificially high levels. You see this is cities with tech, oil & gas, finance, or other high-paying industries.
- shsjxjbsbs 7y agoInternational tax law doesn’t seem very relevant to the housing crisis.
- endorphone 7y agoApple is also one of the most notorious tax avoiders in world history. This is quite a stretch. Apple's effective tax rate is somewhere near 24-26%, which is far above many of its peers. However when the tax conversation comes up, every level and every jurisdiction has self-serving ideas about how much of that tax should be payable to them. e.g. "Apple made $X worldwide, therefore they owe Cupertino/California/United States N% of $X", etc.
- Traster 7y agoIt's worth noting, tax laws don't come out of nowhere. They literally do write the tax laws. They don't sign them in to law, sure, but they do write them.
- rmah 7y agoApple paid $10B in income taxes on $65B of income in FY 2019. In addition they paid billions in sales/vat/gst tax and various taxes associated with employees. Apple's tax structure in Ireland was not "deemed illegal". The EU retroactively declared that an Irish tax law was invalid. Apple complied with the laws at the time they were operating. As far as I'm aware, Apple (as do most large corporations) follows various tax laws in the various jurisdictions they operate in. If you feel those laws are unfair then you should lobby your government to change the laws. IMO, blaming companies for the laws they follow is not a good way to fix the problem you see.
- guelo 7y agoMy lobbying would be going up against Apple's multimillion dollar annual lobbying budget plus their massive propaganda reach. For example, I was opposed to letting Apple "repatriate" their international cash hoard but Apple was able to get that legislation passed after a multi-year lobbying and propaganda campaign. My email to my senator did not matter at all but theirs mattered a lot.
- millstone 7y agoSeems weird to single Apple out here. Apple routinely spends significantly less on lobbying compared to other tech companies. Facebook and Amazon both spent twice what Apple did, and Google 3x.
- Bud 7y agoApple is doing nothing——nothing at all——that isn't being done by every single other large corporation. They're doing this because it's what US tax law allows. People can whine about Apple being a "tax avoider" but that's just a fig leaf to cover the truth, which is that you can't call Apple a "tax evader" because it's untrue. Want Apple to repatriate all that income? Great. Change the tax law, which means, get rich Republicans to change it. Til then? Stop blaming the companies for working within the system that we, the voters, have set up.
- solidsnack9000 7y agoThe tax law of relevance here is California’s property tax, which disincentivizes redevelopment. State revenues on corporate income don’t have anything to do with the housing shortage.