3 ms·
Land prices rise as a result of people wanting to buy the land and competing with other people with means to buy it. You are proposing that the taxes of someon
by zepto 7y ago
Land prices rise as a result of people wanting to buy the land and competing with other people with means to buy it.
You are proposing that the taxes of someone who owns a house should be based on the ability of other people to buy it.
Nothing could be more regressive than that. It is absolutely discriminatory and in no way equitable.
Living in the house you bought for yourself is clearly not ‘hoarding’. It seems like you are getting emotional now.
There is nothing discriminatory about basing taxes on the purchase price. If you buy now, you will benefit from prop 13 the same as anyone else.
Also, using taxes to force people out of their houses as you propose, is a terrible idea for the development of the economy since it disincentivizes the development of productive industry in other less developed areas.
- lmm 7y ago> You are proposing that the taxes of someone who owns a house should be based on the ability of other people to buy it. > Nothing could be more regressive than that. It is absolutely discriminatory and in no way equitable. How so? The tax rate on a given house should be independent of who is living in it. Two people living in identical houses (in equivalent locations) should be paying identical taxes. That's obviously the fair approach. > Living in the house you bought for yourself is clearly not ‘hoarding’. It easily can be, if you're living in a bigger house than you need, or living in a prime job area when you're not working. Hoarding always means keeping hold of something you bought for yourself so there's no contradiction there. > There is nothing discriminatory about basing taxes on the purchase price. If you buy now, you will benefit from prop 13 the same as anyone else. I didn't have the opportunity to buy 40 years ago because I wasn't alive then. I didn't have the opportunity to buy 10 years ago because my parents weren't rich enough to pay my deposit. Prop 13 is very much age/class discrimination in practice. > is a terrible idea for the development of the economy since it disincentivizes the development of productive industry in other less developed areas. Subsidising development in cheap areas is just as distortionary and counterproductive as subsidizing development in expensive areas. The best taxes - and land value tax is well known among economists as the perfect tax - don't distort in either direction, leaving the free market to get on with efficient allocation.
- zepto 7y agoThe tax rate on the house being proportional to what other people would like to pay for it now vs what you actually paid is clearly discriminatory. “If you are living in a bigger house than you ‘need’ or if you are living in a prime job area and not working” I see, so you have decided that homes should temporarily allocated to those who are working in the area, and should be sized according to a political opinion about what they ‘need’. A segregated society where we have worker only zones and industry is more and more concentrated in the places it is already established is a grotesque, quasi-fascist dystopia. This is what you are advocating for? At least your position is consistent. If you buy now, over time you will benefit from prop 13 in the same way that everyone else has. In 40 years you’ll have the benefit that people who bought 40 years ago now have.
- lmm 7y ago> The tax rate on the house being proportional to what other people would like to pay for it now vs what you actually paid is clearly discriminatory. How is it discriminatory? It has nothing to do with who you are (indeed one doesn't have to know anything about you to figure it out), which is the opposite of discriminatory. > I see, so you have decided that homes should temporarily allocated to those who are working in the area, and should be sized according to a political opinion about what they ‘need’. Better that than allocating them by whoever first called dibs. There's a reason we believe most goods should be brought and sold at a market price that's the same for everyone, not different prices for different people. Do you acknowledge that there's such a thing as a luxury home? I would rather people who just want somewhere to live near where they work had a level playing field with people who want to live in a mansion they don't need. (I'm not even arguing for favouring the workers, just for stopping subsidising the mansion-owners). There's nothing wrong with spending your honestly-earned money on luxuries, but you shouldn't get a tax break for it, particularly when your luxury is someone else's necessity. > A segregated society where we have worker only zones and industry is more and more concentrated in the places it is already established is a grotesque, quasi-fascist dystopia. A society where people can't move into the places where the jobs are is far more all of those things (not being able to move freely was one of the biggest criticisms of the Soviet Union; we called ourselves a free country in contrast, precisely because people were free to move wherever they wanted) - and that's what we have at the moment by subsidising the lucky few who happen to live in those places at present. > If you buy now, over time you will benefit from prop 13 in the same way that everyone else has. In 40 years you’ll have the benefit that people who bought 40 years ago now have. By that logic it's fine to refuse to hire over-50s because 30 years ago they had the same benefit that people who are currently 20 have. But actually we still consider that age discrimination, because it is.