6 ms·
Anti-trust laws are there for economic reasons, ie, monopolies preventing competition leaving society worse-off as a whole than can be gained from efficiencies
by dmix 7y ago
Anti-trust laws are there for economic reasons, ie, monopolies preventing competition leaving society worse-off as a whole than can be gained from efficiencies of a single organization. It also typically requires proof of anti-competitive behaviour, beyond just being the biggest in the market.
A lot of companies dominate their markets but don't engage in overt anti-competitive behaviour.
I don't think they've ever been enforced to serve some political end, like punishing companies for not serving some greater democratic purpose to appease the political parties.
- vkou 7y agoYours is a very US-centric viewpoint. The US sees anti-trust as necessary when consumers are negatively impacted. The EU sees anti-trust as necessary when producers are negatively impacted. The latter is, of course, always colored by politics. I will also note that the nature of the social network market, with its network effects, means that a large enough system with a closed API is, under those constraints, by definition anti-competitive - certainly to producers, and possibly to consumers.
- filoleg 7y ago>The US sees anti-trust as necessary when consumers are negatively impacted. The EU sees anti-trust as necessary when producers are negatively impacted. This statement is interesting, considering what it implies about the purpose of existence of producers for each respective side. With this stance, US is more like "producers exist to satisfy needs of customers", while EU is "producers exist just to compete with each other".
- vkou 7y agoThe EU, roughly, sees producers as a vehicle that exists to create jobs, and thus create prosperity for their employees. Once basic life needs are met, optimizing for customers tends to only good for someone who is living off their savings/welfare/etc. Optimizing for employees is good if you, like the majority of the people on Earth, have to work for a living, or are supported by someone who has to work for a living.
- philwelch 7y agoEven in America, often producers wield more political power than consumers. Farm policies are often dictated by the interests of farmers more than the interests of people who eat food. Tariffs have traditionally been a mechanism to protect domestic producers at the expense of domestic consumers. Immigration provides economic benefits but some of these come at the expense of individual workers who face more competition. Even defense policy is affected: decisions are largely driven by the goal of creating or protecting jobs in particular states and districts rather than by the actual needs of the military. Everybody eats food, pays taxes, pays tariffs, and benefits from the protection of the military, but 300 million people who pay marginally fewer taxes and tariffs, eat marginally cheaper food, and enjoy the defense of a marginally more effective and efficient military are often "outvoted" by geographic concentrations of tens of thousands of people who have substantial vested interests. Given this inherent bias in democracy, I think it makes sense for policy to at least try to favor the consumer over the producer, just because producers do a good job taking care of themselves already.
- unethical_ban 7y agoWe've never had communications platforms so centralized, nor had comms companies with so much editorial control over peoples' exposure to information.
- soperj 7y agoAT&T?
- unethical_ban 7y ago>editorial control And as mentioned elsewhere, it was broken up, and then allowed to recongeal.
- layoutIfNeeded 7y agoWhich was broken up in 1984 via antitrust regulation?
- soperj 7y agoResponding to this specifically: >We've never had communications platforms so centralized
- x220 7y agoThe United States Postal Service? Although it's illegal for them to open mail without a specific warrant.
- qubex 7y agoThe USPS is my go-to example of why “Net Neutrality” is a requirement for communication.
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoThe USPS mail service is frankly bullshit. It exists to spam the hell out of you.
- zaphod4prez 7y agoYour last sentence does not seem right to me, and it also seems to be phrased in a disingenuous way. "punishing companies for not serving some greater democratic service" is a very weird way to describe a legitimate worry about consolidation of private power (which, by the way, has a very long history). Of course, healthy competition & pricing is a core issue here (duh). But power, in all its forms, is also a key issue. The founding fathers were very concerned about a corporation gaining too much power and interfering with democracy [1]. In addition, Facebook is constantly engaged in anti-competitive and unacceptable behavior, including buying multiple competitors (anti-competitive) and lying about its product (the recent inflated-ad-views scandal, which was literally a scam). The antitrust case against fb is complicated by the nature of the business, but there are plenty of very good reasons for the gov to investigate fb for antitrust violations [2]. Matt Stoller has done some good writing on monopoly, so has Binyamin Appelbaum. Both of them have books worth reading. [1]: In 1816, Thomas Jefferson, principal author of the Declaration of Independence, said he hoped to "crush in its birth the aristocracy of our monied corporations, which dare already to challenge our government to a trial of strength and bid defiance to the laws of our country." (https://www.stamfordadvocate.com/local/article/Angela-Carella-Founding-fathers-worried-about-3628729.php https://www.stamfordadvocate.com/local/article/Angela-Carell...) [2]: https://scholarship.law.berkeley.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1139&context=bblj https://scholarship.law.berkeley.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?art...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bduerst 7y agoHey, Thomas Jefferson also said, "The natural progress of things is for liberty to yield and government to gain ground." Like many of Jefferson's quotes, this one and yours are both out of context, with yours being in reference to a wealthy elite dodging taxes illegally. That context is a bit different than wanting the government breaking up a social media company because you disagree with it's methods of managing free speech.
- pron 7y ago
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y ago> It also typically requires proof of anti-competitive behaviour, beyond just being the biggest in the market. That wasn't always true. The US was once fond of trust- busting.