4 ms·
No, you are not naive. The hand-wavy way that this gets done is that everyone is a 1099 contractor or owns their own "business". That's great for the company,
by Spooky23 7y ago
No, you are not naive.
The hand-wavy way that this gets done is that everyone is a 1099 contractor or owns their own "business". That's great for the company, as it pushes alot of bullshit to the employee (payroll tax, benefits, etc). It's great, that is, until it isn't because many of these independent contractors aren't really independent at all, and the tax and labor authorities will be less than amused.
- Crinus 7y agoCan you elaborate on that last part?
- taftster 7y agoFor example, in the United States, the IRS applies a set of tests to determine if a person can be considered a 1099 contractor or a W2 employee. In the US, the primary determination is if the contractor can set their own schedule and client list. Also if the contractor can determine the best way to perform a task or get to a result. It's an interesting take in the context of remote work, for sure. I couldn't find the direct IRS link, but this looks official enough to reference: https://galachoruses.org/sites/default/files/IRS-20-questions-W2-vs-1099.pdf https://galachoruses.org/sites/default/files/IRS-20-question...
- Spooky23 7y agoThis is a big one, but don't forget about Worker's Compensation. When your "contractor" gets hurt when working/travelling/etc at your direction, the "contractor"'s health or auto insurer will likely figure out that the contractor meets the test to be an employee and will pursue action against the company.
- paulmd 7y agoContractors essentially need to be entirely piecework - I am paying you to accomplish this task, by this date, end of story. If the employer attempts to impose conditions on how the work is done, or when it is done (in terms of working hours, etc) then those are characteristics which point towards the contractor actually being an employee of the company.
- PeterisP 7y agoThe difference between an employee and an independent contractor isn't an arbitrary choice that the company and worker can contract as they wish. If the de-facto nature of the interaction is that of an employee, then (mis)classifying that as a contractor relationship is generally illegal; the specifics depend on the jurisdiction (which is especially tricky if you have people in many jurisdictions) but it may be considered tax fraud because you're not reporting/paying taxes in the way employment requires, it may be considered violation of worker's right laws, etc. If you're treating your remote workers as independent contractors, then you have to treat them as independent contractors - i.e. they can sell their services also to other employers at the same time, they can set their own hours, they can choose how they achieve the goals and possibly (this may depend on location) subcontract their work instead of doing it themselves, etc.
- em-bee 7y agothe problem is not that false choice between employee and contractor, but that there is no choice. when employer and employee are in two different countries, then employment is not an option. neither can the employers country force the company to get a work visa for the "employee", nor can the employees country force the employer to open a legal entity in the country. the only thing the employees country can do is to make it hard for the "employee" to work as an independent contractor. or both countries can set up an international agreement to deal with this situation. the company is not trying to get around the law, and presumably most, or all who for example work for gitlab in the US are employees. most likely in europe too, since a single company is enough to cover the whole european union so it's likely that they set one up. they are not employees in countries where there are to few people to make it worth setting up a local company.