6 ms·
People need to leave. There is a supply and demand problem where there is an enormous demand for a small area when there are so many other great places to be i
by colechristensen 7y ago
People need to leave.
There is a supply and demand problem where there is an enormous demand for a small area when there are so many other great places to be in this country.
Jobs are abundant all over. If you want to solve the housing problems in the bay area, start programs that give people $10,000 to go anywhere else. You'll enormously increase the quality of life of the people who leave.
There's nothing wrong with an area that doesn't aspire to intense density. Nobody is entitled to that, there's nothing wrong with self determination and choosing not to grow. People need to realize there are other places to be, companies need to realize there are other places to be.
- shuckles 7y agoWhy would you subsidize people to leave if the market for labor suggests that for high income households, living in Bay Area is still totally worth it?
- colechristensen 7y agoYou have to be pretty far up in order to meet that bar, not many do. People (including myself) overvalue the dollar amount and undervalue the various increased costs. If I had never come to the bay area, I would be earning half as much, but I would be saving more, I would be living in better housing in a better neighborhood, and I would have less pressure. By all metrics but a W-2 I would be wealthier. At some point it's entirely possible that I will reach that threshold where the bay area income will blow everything else out of the water, but that's a gamble and ultimately probably not "worth it" when I consider what I want in life.
- shuckles 7y agoIt is unfortunate that regionally self-imposed policies have put you into this situation. I still don’t understand why that justifies a further subsidy. Are you saying the extra 10 grand would help people overcome a mental hurdle which has trapped them in a bad situation?
- colechristensen 7y agoAn overwhelming number of people live mostly paycheck to paycheck, like 80% of the population. Moving across the country is just expensive and many people simply can't, or doing so would be an enormous risk mostly surrounding the large cost to relocate. Give people a little bump to afford to change places and then home-city choice becomes much more elastic.
- shuckles 7y agoThis sounds like a program that needs to be justified at a federal level.
- alteria 7y agoA personal example of this from the past week. I got an offer in SF for ~150k, which would require me moving from a medium/high COL location. My friend gets an offer in Huntsville, Alabama for ~90k. Guess who has the higher cost of living adjusted salary? 90k in Huntsville is nearly 200k in SF, manly due to the "474% higher" cost of housing. [1] https://www.nerdwallet.com/cost-of-living-calculator/compare/huntsville-al-vs-san-francisco-ca https://www.nerdwallet.com/cost-of-living-calculator/compare...
- ahumanperson 7y agoBut is it really worth it if you have to live in Alabama?
- u10 7y agoThe converse can be argued, that individuals are not entitled to state-protected property values at the expense of others. Furthermore, it isn't self-determination, it's rent-seeking behaviour that is detrimental to the rest of society, essentially luck that they managed to purchase a property at the right time at the right price.
- colechristensen 7y agoAn individual isn't, but if the existing population consistently votes in a certain way, a new minority who want to change things aren't entitled to their desires.
- eli_gottlieb 7y ago> People need to leave. Ah yes, the perfect solution to a housing crisis: xenophobia, and using market mechanisms to enact the kinds of mass expulsions whose mere suggestion gets Trump labeled all kinds of mean things. Mean things like racist or Nazi. All because he wants to do on paper what California does every day with prices: make the people he believes are inferior get out of "his" land.
- papln 7y ago"California" doesn't do this. Certain urban regions in California do this. There are low-cost areas of California.
- eli_gottlieb 7y agoCalifornia as a whole passed Prop 13 by a ballot measure, which prevents localities from fixing the problem by taxing long-time housing wealth at the same rate it inflates in value.
- caseysoftware 7y agoThat was the entire point of the Princeton study from this weekend: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21431061 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21431061 Having all the "desirable" people in one place maximizes capital efficiency and damn the consequences. Feels like more and more people agree with Trump at some level but they're couching it in other terms to.. not get called names? I'm not 100% sure on that bit.
- eli_gottlieb 7y ago>Feels like more and more people agree with Trump at some level but they're couching it in other terms to.. not get called names? I'm not 100% sure on that bit. IME, loads and loads of people agree with Trump on the level that some people ought to be made to GTFO from Wherever They Live. The big disagreements are on who society should target for enforced expulsion, how expulsion should be enforced (housing prices vs "canceling" vs ICE raids), and what mean names we're allowed to call people whose targets differ from ours (eg: expelling "immigrants" is Bad and Racist, but expelling "techbros" is Good and Woke, even at the intersection of immigrant tech-workers).
- papln 7y agoPeople who don't want to live in big city can leave, instead of erecting barriers to growth.
- dmitrygr 7y agoBy your very logic it is equally fair to say that people who want a big city can go move to one, though.
- Kalium 7y ago> Jobs are abundant all over. If you want to solve the housing problems in the bay area, start programs that give people $10,000 to go anywhere else. You'll enormously increase the quality of life of the people who leave. This is such a good idea that some places are already doing it! This article describes several implementations: https://www.forbes.com/sites/laurabegleybloom/2018/11/13/this-city-will-pay-you-10000-to-move-there-and-thats-not-all/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/laurabegleybloom/2018/11/13/thi... On a personal note, it's been my experience that the number of people willing to suggest that such programs should exist is perhaps not quite the same as the number of people willing to take advantage of the same.
- pascalxus 7y agoI actually agree with some of this. But, jobs are NOT abundant all over. They key is not for people to leave, but for companies to leave. Once the jobs leave, the people have no choice but to follow. People are just pawns. Jobs determine where people will go. Voters have made it abundantly clear, they don't want more building. I live here, and I even get a postcard in the mail anytime some developer wants to start building from angry voters. And then they start creating all kinds of problems for those developers at the local level. Then when developers do finally jump through all the stupid hurdles, they get sued to pieces by selfish voters. I don't even know why the judges allow that to happen: seems like a huge abuse of the legal system.
- skyyler 7y agoWeird, why are there other dense urban centres in the world without the problems the bay area has? Why don't apartment buildings get built here? I've heard a lot of people claim earthquakes are the reason. What does Japan know that California doesn't?