9 ms·
Illumos is a Unix operating system which provides next-generation features
- phendrenad2 7y agoIllumos is a fork of OpenSolaris that's under active development, and the last Unix based on AT&T Unix System V. It's features have been around forever, and have been ported to Linux and BSD (with various levels of success). So "next-gen" is a strange way to describe it...
- mikece 7y agoIt might have been around the block a few(?) times but it’s good to know that OpenSolaris is still being worked on.
- tracker1 7y agoI think part of the reason for not mentioning OpenSolaris in the main page is because it, in fact, isn't really being worked on... it's effectively dead, and Illumos really isn't the same as it was a decade ago.
- tedunangst 7y agoWhat makes it the last?
- bbanyc 7y agoSolaris, HP-UX, AIX are all in hard maintenance mode as far as I can tell. Illumos seems to be the last System V still being actively worked on.
- jzelinskie 7y agoIt's also useful to know that SmartOS, the Joyent product, is based on Illumos.
- saagarjha 7y ago> It's features have been around forever, and have been ported to Linux and BSD (with various levels of success). And Windows, apparently, at least for DTrace.
- throw0101a 7y agoAlso (Open)ZFS on Windows: * https://openzfsonwindows.org https://openzfsonwindows.org * https://twitter.com/openzfsonwindow https://twitter.com/openzfsonwindow
- johnisgood 7y agohttps://www.openindiana.org/ https://www.openindiana.org/ - Community-driven Illumos Distribution (OpenSolaris -> OpenIndiana)
- loeg 7y agoAnd several others of varying popularity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illumos#Current_distributions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illumos#Current_distributions
- TallGuyShort 7y agoHP-UX 11 is also based on System V [1], and that had a release as recently as 6 months ago [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unix#/media/File:Unix_history-simple.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unix#/media/File:Unix_history-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HP-UX https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HP-UX
- tilt_error 7y agoI wonder what letter hides behind the ‘-‘? Probably the worst ever OS to develop against. I worked for almost 10 years with a product codebase that was maintained on Solaris (really nice), Linux (nice), AIX (not so nice) and HP-UX (not at all nice).
- protomyth 7y agoHP-UX always felt old. It was like everything stopped at some point and they didn't keep going. Did they decide if they would port it (again) to x86 from Itanium. I know they ported NonStop already.
- paol 7y agoThe longstanding joke is to substitute 'S' for the '-'. Around 2000 I briefly worked at a telco equipment manufacturer that shipped for Solaris, AIX and HP-UX. Back then the hierarchy was already as you described.
- hvs 7y agoThat was true in the mid-90's as well, although I remember hating AIX and HP-UX about equally.
- Annatar 7y agoI loved using it and porting software to it. It was really cool to make such a fast yet exotic OS and CPU (PA-RISC) usable and comfortable. Really cool OS. Excellent, high quality hardware.
- mitchty 7y ago
- loeg 7y agoAFAIK, nothing else has a concept quite like Zones. Jails are a subset. Containers in the Linux sense are made from pieces that are small subsets.
- michaelmrose 7y agoI was under the impression that zones were still significantly more powerful than containers. A good contrast between zones, jails, containers in linux https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BsA4DcX47E0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BsA4DcX47E0 ZFS is still a pain to use for your root filesystem not because zfs on linux doesn't work but because its been legally questionable due to license constraints.
- loeg 7y ago> ZFS is still a pain to use for your root filesystem not because zfs on linux doesn't work but because its been legally questionable due to license constraints. There are also technical reasons. ZFS is designed for Solaris' virtual filesystem (VFS) so every other operating system has to wrap some sort of Solaris Porting Layer ("SPL") on top to integrate it into their system. These are not insurmountable (clearly, it works well now). As an OS person, I found this summary on the subject pretty interesting: https://wiki.freebsd.org/AndriyGapon/AvgVfsSolarisVsFreeBSD https://wiki.freebsd.org/AndriyGapon/AvgVfsSolarisVsFreeBSD
- thinkingkong 7y agoIllumos has some incredible technology packed into it but lots of those have been ported, re-implemented, or turned into billion dollar companies. The extra special parts like being able to debug v8 in mdb have this strange alignment issue: How many node developers are going to fire up an alternative operating system and learn a new debugger to be able to find a memory leak?
- gnode 7y ago> How many node developers are going to fire up an alternative operating system and learn a new debugger to be able to find a memory leak? I don't think this is much of a barrier, especially when "fire up" means: run a VM instance. Using various VMs and/or containers for development is already a common workflow. I think the unfamiliarity of Illumos for most developers would be more of a barrier.
- cies 7y agoWhy not state that it is a fork of OpenSolaris on the homepage? Also the "next gen FS" is just ZFS, first released in 2005 (and they say software moves fast). I think the homepage is mostly tageting techies, why not put a little more jargon in there and be transparent about the origins?
- loeg 7y agoOpenSolaris has been dead since 2009. illumos is the hard fork of that (taking control out of Oracle's hands).
- cies 7y agoI'd just put this on the front page. I'm not going to do anything serious with this OS before figuring this out at some point.
- rzezeski 7y agoYou just figured it out.
- cies 7y agoIt half rang a bell, the name, Illumos. Then I saw the "next gen OS" was ZFS (and DTrace was the other buzzword-thingy) which gave it away. I'm trying to help here. I think they can do better marketing when being maximum transparent from the start. As someone whom just chimed in says: they think that refering to Solaris is bad marketing. I believe the opposite. Also to get people to take you serious could be done by other means than hiding your origins. Like testemonials and contribution stats.
- Annatar 7y agoThere are a lot of people who never managed to learn and understand Solaris more than superficially and then didn't keep up with his quite revolutionary and violent improvement, so quite often you'll read deeply wrong and misinformed jabs about how Solaris is "Slowlaris" and so on. These have no basis in reality for almost 15 years, but illumos and his derivatives want to distance themselves from such nonsense, and one can't really blame them for that. illumos based operating systems are the most advanced on the planet bar none, and it would be a great waste to have that ruined by poorly informed superficial opinions from people with no skin in the game incorrecting each other.
- miker64 7y agoIs there something new that's happened for this to be news?
- ryancnelson 7y agothere's an OpenZFS summit going on this week, so I imagine that's why this and OmniOS became top-of-mind for some: http://www.open-zfs.org/wiki/OpenZFS_Developer_Summit_2019 http://www.open-zfs.org/wiki/OpenZFS_Developer_Summit_2019
- miker64 7y agoThanks for the context!
- snw 7y agoOmniOS, one of the illumos distributions also had a release today: https://github.com/omniosorg/omnios-build/blob/r151032/doc/ReleaseNotes.md https://github.com/omniosorg/omnios-build/blob/r151032/doc/R...
- mapgrep 7y agoI really hope users and developers can embrace the amazing technology that is present in illumos and its derivatives, much of which came out of Sun Solaris. Things like ZFS, Zones, DTrace, SMF, and Crossbow were locked up inside Sun Solaris for many years because it was proprietary. The effort to open source it took a long time and because of how Solaris was built (with various third party things) Sun essentially had to release under a slightly odd license, the CDDL. Meanwhile Linux, which had ascended to dominance post dot com bubble, solidified its lead as the defacto default server operating system, a fairly well earned dominance built on being the first truly free Unix available for x86/PC hardware, and at a time when that was a truly lesser tier of hardware (unlike today). But today I worry we've settled into a mindset of "the linux way is best because it is dominant" - if you use linux you can google your stack traces, you know that even if the tech is inferior (coughbtrfscoughsystemtapcoughsystemdcoughepoll*cough) many other people are in the same boat and in theory hordes of developers will -- might? -- make patches to fix the problem. No one ever got fired for choosing linux, basically. I've migrated a bunch of personal projects to a server I own running SmartOS, an Illumos derivative. One thing I've learned is that it's actually really viable and nice these days to use an alternative operating system. I imagine it's similar with FreeBSD, OpenBSD, vanilla Illumos, etc. These systems run on a pretty impressive array of hardware and are able to leverage the near total standardization of the hardware/bios stack and the inroads made by other projects to bootstrap to viability. E.g. SmartOS uses pkgsrc from the netbsd project for packaging, took some boot technology from FreeBSD, and in general is able to tap into the universe of "unix like" tools, even if many of those tools are most often used on linux. Anyway if you get a chance give this stuff a spin, it's pretty eye opening what you can accomplish. Zones, to me in particular, feel like a game changer.
- conception 7y agoYeah, we store PBs on https://omniosce.org/ https://omniosce.org/ and it's rock solid.
- peatmoss 7y agoVehemently agree. Monoculture is a huge risk to IT generally right now. I love Linux and must use it for some things, because nothing else is really supported, but I really worry about a world where all the servers run Linux. I think the thing I miss most about the 90s and early 00s was that different unix-like systems took big, bold, and divergent approaches. Computing felt less “nailed down”... like there were more possibilities.
- nerdponx 7y agoI'm a "casual" user - I do various hobbyist activities (Python and machine learning projects, 3d modeling, photo editing, et al) as well as basic stuff like email and browsing Hacker News. I don't intend to do much "low-level hacking" or application development. Is Illumos interesting for someone like me? Or should I stick with GNU/Linux?
- porker 7y agoStick with whatever you know and are comfortable with.
- npx 7y agoCompetition from Linux has become very stiff. For me, Kubuntu 19.10 delivers on all of the promises that OpenSolaris made back in the day. My laptop has two 1TB SSDs in a ZFS mirror. Docker works as you'd hope, creating a new ZFS dataset for each container. I have remarkably good hardware support, everything just works. I'd say that the user experience rivals or beats MacOS or Windows, although at this point I'd say it is largely just a matter of preference. Linux still lacks the multitenant security guarantees of Solaris Zones but this isn't so bad. Hard multitenancy is a problem that only concerns a fairly small subset of people and even then, there are solutions. You can do hard multitenancy with Linux containers (namespaces/cgroups to be pedantic) if you start restricting the system call table. There is also Firecracker[1] which obviously isn't as efficient as Zones (because it uses VMs), but is proven in production and does provide additional security guarantees. The technical advantages of Illumos are outweighed (or rivaled) at this point, in my opinion. When I show people things on my laptop, I always end up talking about the desktop cube in KDE or my neovim/tmux/zsh setup. Due to ZFS snapshots and the power of zfs send/recv, I expect this system installation to last for years to come. No more reinstalls, we're good, this operating system thing is covered. 1: https://github.com/firecracker-microvm/firecracker-containerd https://github.com/firecracker-microvm/firecracker-container...
- npx 7y agoTo get off into the weeds a bit... I've actually spent quite a bit of time using Illumos. The epicenter of The Suck begins, in my mind, with the effort involved in actually building the system. GCC (and Clang) obviously didn't exist back in the day, so none of the Makefiles for the base system are written for a compiler that was released in the past 20 years. There is actually a wrapper that takes SunCC arguments and calls GCC... so that kinda works, right? Okay, well, yes. It works. But then, it all kinda starts snowballing. There is a big investment in a debugger from the 1980s which can't unwind stacks without frame pointers. So... we have to emit frame pointers. Okay, that works. Because we care a lot about this, we'll also ensure that all function arguments promoted to registers are also copied to the stack so we can always look at them. Okay, fair enough. Is this idiosyncratic enough for you yet? Okay, let's step it up a few notches and actually implement the Linux system call table on top of this. Wait, what? The struggle is real. This is all technically brilliant in any number of ways, but I have things to do this week. All of the man years of effort spent on Linux and the surrounding ecosystem have actually solved a lot of real technical problems and solved them incredibly well.