Arguably, the whole article is in response to this very idea. The idea is succinctly rephrased in his article (as a third party quotation) here: "If Gaskell h

Arguably, the whole article is in response to this very idea. The idea is succinctly rephrased in his article (as a third party quotation) here: "If Gaskell has produced sound, peer-reviewed literature of high quality then I see no reason for denying him the position, even if he believes Mars is the egg of a [giant purple Mongoose]"